When we create a blog post on this site, we are sharing with the community. We may be sharing our personal lives, reviewing the latest (albeit, 80+years old) shaving gear we bought, entertaining our fellow members with the history of facial hair, or arguing our political views in an essay.

 

When we, the members of this site, create a blog post, we are injecting our own ideas, however small, petty, or provincial, into the marketplace of ideas--however small, petty, or provincial that marketplace may be. And it does not matter how small or great the subject is, because we choose to participate here and choose to be a part of this website community.

 

So if one is sharing and participating in an exchange, why would one close a blog post to comments from other members? If one is sharing and laying his ideas on the table, why would he put a fence around his post?

 

It smacks of cowardice, particularly if the person is making a strong or controversial argument. The act of blocking comments seems to say: I may express my views, but rebuttals are verboten! And is not cowardice an unmanly trait? If one wants to make an argument, one has to be prepared to face criticism. That is what an exchange of ideas is all about.

 

No argument can be considered legitimate if it is closed to commentary and criticism. Without the opportunity to discuss and rebut, an argument becomes a dictated command, as if it were a decree handed down from on high. But an argument derives its legitimacy from free and reasoned discussion. And when the writer or speaker--whoever is making the argument--closes off free discussion, neither he nor his argument is any longer deserving of respect.

Views: 74

Comment

You need to be a member of Art of Manliness to add comments!

Join Art of Manliness

Comment by Carl Monster on April 2, 2012 at 2:40pm

I totally agree. Do remember there is setting where friends can comment, so if you are not a friend of the person you cannot comment.

I always keep mine open, while I may not like it, I am open to a good kick in the ass. That's why I'm here.

Otherwise I'd be in my room with my secret diary, writing....Dear Diary...today I......

Comment by Steve Dallas on April 2, 2012 at 2:20pm

Can someone please tell me why the hell you would have cake and not eat it?

Comment by Vytautas on April 2, 2012 at 11:52am

I can imagine those scenarios too, Chuck. But particularly when it comes to commentary on society, philosophical theses, and essays about politics or community, these discussions must be open. Otherwise, the author simply appears to want to have his cake and eat it too. One cannot publish an opinion of these kinds without allowing for it to be criticized. When that is the case, it is completely illegitimate and deserves not a speck of respect or consideration.

Comment by Chuck Knight on April 2, 2012 at 11:44am

It's also possible that the purpose of the blog was not to invite discussion, but merely to allow the poster to vent.

 

I can imagine several scenarios in which closing it to comments would be appropriate, even if it does seem confusing or counterproductive.

Comment by Vytautas on April 2, 2012 at 9:56am

Hi Carpe: First, I usually wouldn't comment on my own blog, even in reply to someone, because I think, at least, the format of a blog works best when the author presents his views, and then allows other interlocutors to discuss. When the author gets involved, it usually gets really messy.

 

But my topic isn't particularly controversial, and I don't think I will have a gaggle of respondents!

 

Anyway, thank you for your response. I agree with you that things can "devolve into flame warfare". But I think it is best, for an author of a blog at least, to allow that to happen because it usually just makes the repliers look foolish for their "flame war" responses. And the reasonable interlocutors will always stand out and it will be clear who is conducting the discussion in an appropriate manner.

 

Also, as someone who enjoys Latin poetry, I love your handle!

Latest Activity

Vytautas replied to Vytautas's discussion What Do We Learn From History?
"I can't extend the generosity or benefit of the doubt to a person whose arguments have consistently lacked credibility. If you prove worthy of such generosity, I'd gladly extend it.  I am trying to understand what you are saying.…"
5 minutes ago
Profile IconTodd Heavner and Tim joined Herb Munson's group
Thumbnail

The Great Debate

"Iron sharpens iron." A place for men to impact each other by debate and exchange of ideas. This is a group where no ideas are off limits. If your motto is, "I never talk about politics or religion," this group is probably not for you. A "gym" for thinkers.See More
16 minutes ago
Davis commented on Rusty Rogers's photo
Thumbnail

Week27

"OK, Shane,..."But hell, you're 70. All bets are off at that age."!!! I'll take that as a compliment. As my mother used to say, "I may look old but my mind is everything young." Now, more posterior work than…"
25 minutes ago
Zachary Warner joined Shaun Daws's group
Thumbnail

Men in the Kitchen

This groups if for those men who love to cook. It's a place to discuss techniques, recipes and suggestions. Bon apetit!
57 minutes ago
Zachary Warner joined Shaun Daws's group
Thumbnail

Man Skills

A group for sharing and discussing those amazing practical skills that every man aquires in an effort to make his world run the way he wants it to.
1 hour ago
Regular Joe replied to Shane's discussion Secret Lives of Men in the group The Great Debate
"So I've re-read the article you posted and noticed something. The author writes "I see" 6 times. In one of those instances, the statement is "I see the same pain in men that I carry in myself.".  To me, this appears to…"
1 hour ago
Steve Dallas replied to Vytautas's discussion What Do We Learn From History?
"I can't, I see knowledge as fluid, adaptive infinite, and other wonderful descriptive words. The way I understand your(and Socrates) argument is that knowledge is finite, inflexible and most follow specific directions."
1 hour ago
Shane commented on Rusty Rogers's photo
Thumbnail

Week27

"Yeah. You got me. Davis, That core workout still looks a little front heavy to me. Generally speaking, there's so much imbalance in modern society, there's a general recommendation to perform back:front/pull:push in a 3:2 ratio. That is,…"
1 hour ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service