Manly Lessons From The Depression: The Civilian Conservation Corps Trains the Greatest Generation

Four images of CCC Men

Picture: Men of the CCC at Work and Play
Source: National Parks Service

Eighty years ago the nation was plunged into Depression when the excesses of the 1920s caught up with society. Like the current recession, the economic bubble and collapse was the result of excessive debt spending by consumers and excessive risk taken on by investors. At the worst depths 25% of the work force was unemployed.

With such high unemployment and the people with jobs suffering major pay cuts, many across the country were suffering. Out in the Plains states years of poor farming practices led to massive soil erosion and the Dust Bowl, leaving millions of fertile acres a wasteland.

The recession hurt young men especially. They had the fewest skills, lowest earnings and savings and many found themselves coming of working age in a decade of high unemployment. They were at the greatest risk for poverty and starvation and any sociologist will tell you that restless young men without a purpose will lead to social instability and crime.

President Franklin Roosevelt saw all these problems and sought ways to fix them. One of the “100 Days” programs he passed was Emergency Conservation Work Act (ECW), a temporary program that would become the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC). Roosevelt described the goals of the CCC when he introduced the legislation.

“I propose to create a civilian conservation corps to be used in simple work, not interfering with normal employment, and confining itself to forestry, the prevention of soil erosion, flood control, and similar projects. I call your attention to the fact that this type of work is of definite practical value, not only through the prevention of great present financial loss but also a means of creation future national wealth...” Franklin Roosevelt

As the Civilian Conservation Corps Legacy put it more succinctly: “Its purpose was two-fold -- conservation of our natural resources and the salvage of our young men.”

The program, which started out with 250,000 men, would employ 3 million young men and WWI veterans throughout its nine year history and leave a legacy of restored natural beauty, economic sustenance for families across the country and a generation of men made better for their experience.

Environmental Degradation

For years the American agricultural sector had grown in output and productivity. During World War I farmers grew more acres to supply the war effort and mechanized tractors and transportation changed how they farmed. Unfortunately these new methods were exploitative and dangerous to the soil. Few farmers knew about crop rotation, fertilization or techniques to prevent soil erosion. The misuse of the land eventually yielded the Dust Bowl and a significant loss of topsoil and farm acreage.


Dallas, South Dakota, 1936
Source: USDA/Wikimedia Commons

In other areas of the country similar ecological problems existed. Clear cut logging had left land scarred and soil at risk. National parks that had been set aside hadn’t yet been fully developed for fire management or access to tourists. The environmental legacy of Theodore Roosevelt had been left to lie for years. His distant cousin Franklin Roosevelt would rise to the challenge of America’s environmental needs while tackling the problem of youth unemployment.

Logistics


Skagit CCC camp, Mt. Baker National Forest, Washington
Source: Oregon State University

Several federal agencies would be involved in the running of the program, but the biggest influence was the Army. The Army was most capable of moving hundreds of thousands of young men into sites across all 48 states and several territories, setting up and supplying camps and getting the work done.

Most of the men in the program came from the urban areas of the East and were moved out West. Few had the experience of being in the wilderness and many hadn’t ventured so far out from their homes. They signed up for six months enlistments, which could be extended up to two years.

The camps, while not officially military, were run much in the same matter as a base or boot camp. The young men were woken up early in the day to the reveille, roll was called, calisthenic drills were run, bunks were made and kept in order and men were given their tasks for the day.

Benefits to the Men


CCC Men Eating, Camp Roosevelt, VA
Source: Oregon State University

The men who signed up for the CCC were generally ages 17-25, unemployed, unmarried and not in school. Exceptions were made for World War I veterans in need of work, but the bulk were young men.

The pay for the work was low, at $1 a day (for contrast Ford introduced his generous $5 a day auto worker compensation in 1914, which was twice the average of $2.50). They earned $30 dollars a month, but $25 dollars of that was withheld and sent to support their families back home. That left them with $5 a month to spend on themselves in towns near their camps.

The men weren’t starving on those wages. In addition to their pay they got food, housing, clothing and medical care provided. CCC member Milton Knapp described the benefits received upon arrival in the camps.

"Well they lined us up, gave us shots, all kinds of shots such as that, explained what it was all about, assigned us barracks and a bunk. And from there, they lined us up. We called it stores in the navy. They called it quartermaster. So they issued those uh, World War I outfits, clothes such as that. Then after that they assigned us work crews and like that and then they introduce us to the mess hall with uh, food was real good. Yeah. From there on it was a daily routine." - Milton Knapp, East Peroria, Illinois

The men often found themselves eating better in the camps then they had ever eaten before. Several men from poor families hadn’t had access to good sources of meat, eggs and fresh vegetables like they received in the camps. In a visit to a camp in Shenandoah National Park Roosevelt mentioned the good health of the members at the camp and how they had an average weight gain of twelve pounds, while he joked about how he wanted to take twelve pounds off himself.
In today’s world where obesity is an epidemic weight gain is seen as bad, but in the 1930’s malnutrition among the poor was a concern. 16% of the men drafted in World War II were disqualified for medical reasons and Major General Lewis B. Hershey would testify to Congress that malnutrition and underfeeding were the cause of 40-60% of those cases. The men in the camps gained healthy muscle weight and with their hard labor, medical care and work outdoors they were healthier than they had been before.

In addition to the financial and health benefits the CCC offered educational benefits for the workers. Strong emphasis was put on insuring all CCC workers would leave literate. More than 40,000 men learned to read during their time with the CCC. Other work skills like carpentry, stone cutting, welding, truck driving and typing were taught to fill the need for skilled craftsmen and supply workers for the projects.

One CCC member explained the value the education has on the mentality of the men of the CCC.

“We were taught the idea that, hey, you can do things. You can do better than what you’ve done in the past. You have a future. And we believed that.” -Harley Jolley, North Carolina.

The greatest benefit to the young men was a sense of purpose the work gave them. No longer bumming around or hitting the rails in search of menial jobs and soup kitchens, the men were learning the value of work and gaining valuable experience.

“We’re eating regular, we got clothes, they teaching us the way, and we were learning something,”- Houston Pritchett, Detroit, Michigan.

Bonding with Their Fellow Men

CCC Football Game

CCC Enlistees Play Football
Source: Oregon State University

The camps weren’t all work. After a day of working 8-10 hours the men would come back and have recreation time. In addition to opportunities for education, sports were an important part of camp life. It helped men bond and at times resolve their differences. When men had a dispute they would often settle it in the boxing ring. The boxing ring also became a proving ground to new recruits who arrived in camp.

One CCC member described his arrival at a CCC camp in Shenandoah National Park.

“I went in, and there was a couple of boys sparring around with boxing gloves. And as I was walking down through the barracks, somebody said, “There’s a guy, let’s get him, give him them gloves.” And I got a good introduction right there… I didn’t get hurt any, but I, I had 4 or 5 people. My name was all over the Camp the next day.” – W. “Curley" Harvey, Corinth, West Virginia.

CCC Member Milton Knapp spoke of the CCC teams participating with other college and semi-pro teams in sports.

“I played baseball, basketball. Yeah we had a good baseball team. One year we wound up in, out in Kansas in the semi-pro league . . . And then we played basketball, we played different towns, and played uh, a lot of the college, in the college there, the fraternity brothers there. Yeah we had a pretty good baseball team. Our basketball team was average.” – Milton Knapp, East Peroria, Illinois

The Environmental Legacy Left Behind

CCC Members Fight A Fire in Angeles National Forest, California
Source: Oregon State University

If a measure of a man is the legacy he leaves behind then the men of the CCC were not found wanting. The 3 million men directly supported 12-15 million family members who received checks sent home. Their work accomplishments were an even longer lasting legacy. A sample of what they accomplished:

Number of Trees Planted: Between 2 and 3 billion
State Parks Developed: 800
Public Campground Development: 52,000 acres
Miles of Roads Built: 125,000
Miles of Telephone Lines Strung: 89,000
Miles of Foot Trails Built: 13,100
Farmlands Benefited from Erosion Control Projects: 40 million acres
Stream and Lake Bank Protection: 154 million square yards
Range Re-vegetation: 814,000 acres
Fire fighting Days: More than 8 million

Source: CCC Legacy

The End of the CCC and Its Contribution to the War.

CCC Members Raise the American Flag
Source: Oregon State University

By the late 1930’s the CCC was reaching the end of its life. While it remained a popular program, the bettering economy and military draft were lowering the unemployment rate and number of men signing up. The need to prepare for war taxed the budget and the Army’s resources. When Japan attacked Pearl Harbor on December 7th, 1941 the immediate needs of the war became apparent and militarization of the country would end the CCC.

The end of the Civilian Conservation Corp in 1941 would not be the end of its benefits to the nation. The 3 million men who participated would be among the most ready to join in the 16.1 million strong American force that would fight in World War II.

CCC member W. “Curley” Harvey spoke about the benefit his time in the CCC had on his time in the military.

“What I learned in the CC Camp went a long ways with me. . . The army knows [that] practically everyone that was in the CC Camp made a heck of a lot better soldier” – W. “Curley" Harvey, Corinth, West Virginia.


General Mark Clark, left, praised the CCC for preparing young men and officers
Source:Army Office of Medical History

General Mark Clark, speaking at the Citadel on October 31st, 1980, explained the significant role the CCC played in preparing young men for the military. General Clark, then a Major, served as a deputy commander of the Civilian Conservation Corps district in Omaha, Nebraska.

“Though military training and drill were not authorized as such at CCC Camps, none-the-less these young men learned the vital factor of being able to live together in mass and were taught urgent and essential specialties that grooved so easily into the military. . . Though we did not realize it at the time, we were training Non-commissioned Officers, Company Clerks, Cooks and Bakers. . . –the list goes on and on.” -General Mark Clark, speaking at the Citadel

General Clark said it wasn’t just the CCC men alone who benefited from the time in the CCC. The camps were run by military officers, who got a unique leadership experience that would test their abilities.

“At the same time, Military Officer personnel were being subtly trained for leadership. The CCC man was enrolled under a civilian Oath of Enrollment, and as such, was not subject to the articles of War or Courts Martial procedures. .. what a challenge this proved to be for military officers.” -General Mark Clark, speaking at the Citadel

Military officers had to make the choice of either figuring out how to lead men without the force of military police and rules, or else face the shame of relying on civilian authorities to do the job for them. General Clark said that helped separate the good leaders from the bad and made for a better Army.

“Who knows but what the incompetents who we weeded out might otherwise have done later on in the War in places of responsibility where the lives of men were at stake.” -General Mark Clark, speaking at the Citadel

The Greatest Legacy Of the CCC- The Men it Left Behind


The great legacy of the CCC was the men it left behind. In its day the program was popular for it’s role in society. Unlike today’s battles over stimulus and jobs programs, this program got support from both sides of the aisle and people opposed to the President.

“The program had great public support. Young men flocked to enroll. A poll of Republicans supported it by 67 percent, and another 95 percent of Californians were for it. Colonel McCormick, publisher of the Chicago Tribune, and an implacable hater of Roosevelt, gave the CCC his support. The Soviet Union praised the program…perhaps it saw a touch of socialism. A Chicago judge thought the CCC was largely responsible for a 55 percent reduction in crime by the young men of that day.” - Source:CCC Legacy

Several famous men would come out of the program.

Chuck Yeager – West Virginia CCC, joined the Army Air Corps during the war, rose to become Brigadier General, first man to break the sound barrier.

Robert Mitchum- Actor from film classics Cape Fear, Winds of War, Night of the Hunter

Norman Borlaug – CCC member who went on to lead the “Green Revolution” in agricultural, helping keep billions of people from starvation. For his efforts he was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1970.

Walter Matthau – Actor and co-star with Jack Lemmon in such classic man films as the Odd Couple, The Fortune Cookie and Grumpy Old Men

Raymond Burr – Actor most famous for his role as the titular character in Perry Mason. Was active in the National Associations of Civilian Conservation Corps Alumni, and successfully lobbied Congress to reinstate the program in 1984, though the program was vetoed by President Reagan later.

Source: CCC Legacy

General Mark Clark praised the program and the effect it had on the youth of the 1930s.

"In my way of thinking, the CCC was a monumental success in saving the youth of the 1930’s. . . endowing the individual CCC enrollee with a feeling of dignity, for he was giving his Country an honorable and worthwhile return for what it was doing for him and for his family economically – such stark contracts to the shameful, character-robbing Welfare Programs of today." -General Mark Clark, speaking at the Citadel


The Civilian Conservation Corps succeeded in its mission to conserve natural resources and salvage the unemployed youth. It took in millions of young boys and turned out men. CCC member Houston Pritchett explains it best.

“The CCC made me a man, made me respect discipline and how to work and how to get along with people”- Houston Pritchett, Detroit, Michigan

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ __ _

To learn more about the CCC, I recommend watching Robert Stone’s documentary “The Civilian Conservation Corps”, part of PBS’s series American Experience. This documentary is the source of the quotes from Houston Pritchett and Harley Jolley used in this article.

The CCC is also part of Ken Burns' documentary The National Parks: America's Best Idea

Views: 1073

Comment

You need to be a member of Art of Manliness to add comments!

Join Art of Manliness

Comment by Raj on December 17, 2009 at 3:29pm
Great post, Phillip! FDR is one of my favorite historical figures, and it's always great to learn more about one of his splendid programs from the New Deal.
Comment by Philip Rodney Moon on December 17, 2009 at 12:35am
Thanks James! and Kate

Re: Kate

In Michigan the tree army succeeded in replanting a lot of the pine forest logged in Northern Michigan. The state had already had an early program, but with the CCC 134,000 acres were restored. Driving up to the Mackinac Bridge you sometimes pass forests of trees growing in straight lines.

http://www.michigan.gov/dnr/0,1607,7-153-10366_46403_46404-211995--...
Comment by James! on December 16, 2009 at 9:55pm
Brilliant. Simply brilliant, thanks for posting this.

Latest Activity

Tony Wolf replied to Joshua Wolf's discussion Fraternal orders for young men?
"Probably about the same thing they'd think of, say, lawn-darts."
47 minutes ago
Joshua Wolf posted a discussion

Fraternal orders for young men?

Hello, I am recently returning to these forums after a couple of years with a new-found interest in old world traditions and community building.I want to combine these two interests by forming a fraternal order for young men to be part of a positive group. Because most young men don't have a lot of disposable income the idea would be to facilitate their practical, rather than financial, contributions to their communities.  We would try out and practice old world skills such as blacksmithing,…See More
1 hour ago
Brody Albers replied to Liam's discussion Advice on which translation of The Bible to read in the group Christian Men
"I prefer the ESV. I am a theology student and so the "essentially-literal" translation is useful to me since the Bible is the bulk of my research material. For my own personal devotions though I have enjoyed using both the NIV and NLT. As…"
5 hours ago
Brody Albers replied to Kevin's discussion Will someone please explain Jesus to me? in the group Christian Men
"There are many, many theories about what you are asking. Simply put, your question boils down to the purpose of the atonement, or "why did Jesus have to die?". I wrote a brief (2 page) essay on the subject for a theology class which was…"
5 hours ago
Pale Horse replied to Jack Bauer's discussion What'cha watchin'? Your manly entertainment recommendations, reviews and discussions ...
"LOLOLOLOL I really shouldn't know what that is."
5 hours ago
Brody Albers joined Tookie's group
Thumbnail

Christian Men

Regardless of the specifics, we can all agree on one thing. Jesus Christ was the perfect Man who died and rose again for us such that we could have fellowship with Him
6 hours ago
Will commented on Leto Atreides II's status
"I posted about it even on his status thread.  That's how I found out he was moderating comments.  I suspect no comments will make it through moderation."
6 hours ago
Leto Atreides II posted a status
"Comments are closed... Comment by John White no comments about the dating scene? Hard to comment when you close comments, Dumbass."
6 hours ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service