A Recent Instance in Which I Was Censored

It was but this morning when a fellow member's blog appeared on the front page. Its title, raising awareness about government regulation in a certain industry, intrigued me, so I clicked, and I read it thoroughly. The post amounted to a lot of slogans without much substance to the actual argument, and therefore I brought up some of these issues in the comment section.

 

The author and I ended up participating in an exchange, which was civil and on the whole rather bloodless, though it was clear that I found some problems in the argument he is trying to present. He was even nice enough to send me a friend request.

 

However, when I signed in a few hours later, I found that my posts had been redacted, censored, and expurgated. Only the blog's author and myself are able to do this. And I didn't do it.

 

So why can't people deal with divergent opinions? Must I be censored simply because I brought up some logical issues in the author's argument? This is not about whether my comments were right or wrong, or whether his position is right or wrong. The question is not whether our opinions and arguments are right or wrong, but can we have reasonably civil dialogue about our opinions and arguments. It is certainly the author's right to limit commentary, but when he does so he forfeits any claim that we the public ought to pay him any attention, respect, or legitimacy. If he doesn't want anyone to comment, he can be alone with his self-made righteousness.

Views: 78

Comment

You need to be a member of Art of Manliness to add comments!

Join Art of Manliness

Comment by Carl Monster on April 4, 2012 at 2:03pm

Funny, disagreement, as scary as it is to me (I don't dare join the Great Debate), is one reason I like this place. I'm on FB, and it gets a bit boring after awhile, all preaching to the choir. As long it it is intelligent, I appreciate hearing another viewpoint. It's how we grow, even if it engenders some anger.

Comment by Vytautas on April 3, 2012 at 5:42pm

Thank you again, Carpe, for your considerate response!

 

Actually, my replies did not make invalid his point. A fact which, I think, makes censorship even more reprehensible because it wasn't like I actually tore his argument apart. I just slightly disagreed with some of his reasoning. And for such a reprehensible little difference in opinion I was rewarded by being cut off!

 

Also, what I am saying here is operating on the normative/intellectual level. I am speaking to how things ought to be. I know that when practical factors come into play, people's behavior is different in reality. But just because censorship is expedient doesn't mean that it is acceptable. It is cowardly and stupid. It reflects poorly on the censor and corrodes the community as a whole.

Latest Activity

Jack Bauer commented on Josh Allen's photo
Thumbnail

The New Lexus RX SUV

"According to that Ramsey article ... 61% of America's wealthy (top 2%) drive Fords, Hondas or Toyotas, not 'luxury' brands.  And 8% of people making under $100K drive "luxury" cars.  Most "luxury" cars on…"
26 seconds ago
Marcus Baughurst posted a discussion

Men baking, opinions?

Waiting for the bake off to start, are there many men that enjoy baking?See More
2 minutes ago
Karl Helweg replied to Daniel's discussion Fixed wing to helicopter in the group Pilots
"Last I heard, eye surgery is a disqualifier for military aviation.  LASIK uses scar tissue, which contracts, to reshape and focus the eyeball.  This scar tissue can cause the eyeball to fail or even explode during rapid pressure…"
4 minutes ago
Marcus Baughurst replied to Michael Hill's discussion What is the hardest project you've started? in the group Homeowner's Handyman Homegroup
"Replacing 20 year old taps, one of those jobs you think will be easy until you start and you've still got no water at 10pm at night and your wife sends you to the 24 hour shop for water and you get 16 litres of fizzy water instead. "
9 minutes ago
Josh Allen commented on Josh Allen's photo
9 minutes ago
Josh Allen commented on Josh Allen's photo
10 minutes ago
Marcus Baughurst replied to Ryan Moretti's discussion Cool Man Cave Idea
"Very nice! "
14 minutes ago
Jack Bauer commented on Josh Allen's photo
Thumbnail

The New Lexus RX SUV

"You completely missed the point on that Dave Ramsey link.  His point is that rich people's cars aren't all that special ... because rich people don't get that way by spending stupidly.  His final sentence is…"
15 minutes ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service