• Blog Posts
  • Discussions (4)
  • Groups
  • Photos
  • Photo Albums
  • Videos

Julian Ross's Discussions

Women in Combat?

Started this discussion. Last reply by Loki Nov 30, 2012. 97 Replies

I don't know how many of you guys heard about this in the news today, but today 4 women filed a suit against the Department of Defense over the rules that exclude women in combat. My college class…Continue

 

Julian Ross's Page

Latest Activity

Julian Ross replied to beardsworthy's discussion Manly Baby Names
"I believe George Carlin put it best http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oo8CrY_ZfFk"
Jan 31, 2013
Loki replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"I say let them fight but they have to be as physically fit as their male counterparts. I know in many fields (I am unsure of american military standards) such as the Canadian Forces the requirements for females are far less then a male.…"
Nov 30, 2012
The Dutch Dastard replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"Ohh, if I wasn't clear: the losing of the cycle might indeed be a good thing, definitely not bad! Saves those tampons for survival purposes right?"
Nov 30, 2012
Nick H replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"I remember reading a story from a Brit on the first line trenches in WWI talking about groups of soldiers gang raping other soldiers like prison gangs. "
Nov 30, 2012
Mike S. replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"As Shane pointed out, you have the shooters (infantry) and everyone else is there to ensure that the shooters have what they need to do their job effectively. Sometimes that means going out with them, sometimes it doesn't. With that said, just…"
Nov 29, 2012
Mike S. replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"You apparently haven't had to sit through Equal Opportunity training a jillion times a year."
Nov 29, 2012
Mike S. replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"Its also a 6 month cycle for the army (not that it changes anything, just wanted to clear that up)."
Nov 29, 2012
Liam S. replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"This is a common argument for same sex education. My recollection, however, is that the data (by and large) doesn't bear this out. "
Nov 29, 2012
Rebekah replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"And if you reject experimentation, and reject data from existing American co-ed units, and reject data from other cultures, you're locked into the status quo perpetually. You can never test a policy change completely before implementation,…"
Nov 29, 2012
Rick Shelton replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"We have women successfully working on the "Most Dangerous Two Acres", carrier flight decks."
Nov 29, 2012
Liam S. replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"Drastically different cultures, maybe. But those are few and far between these days. "
Nov 29, 2012
Rick Shelton replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"Liam: Different cultures may get different results. Shane: Not sure if that would be a good test case either as most non-Combat Arms units don't train for combat as their primary operation.  It is closer, however and may provide some…"
Nov 29, 2012
Rick Shelton replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"Unfortunately body-weight standards don't equal getting to the fight with all your gear.  Combat units that I've been in required unit members to carry everything they'd need for the mission.  That means that the guy…"
Nov 29, 2012
Rick Shelton replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"Mike, No women and men aren't the same, but the requirements of combat for both are the same.  Everybody will have to hump their 135lb ruck into the bush for extended marches, each will have to carry their own weapon, ammo, water, rations,…"
Nov 29, 2012
Mike M. replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"No.  I'm sure there are plenty of women who can do 40 pushups.  I'm saying it's not an apples to apples comparison.  A woman who can do 40 pushups is probably stronger and more athletic than a man who can do the same."
Nov 28, 2012
Rebekah replied to Julian Ross's discussion Women in Combat?
"And maybe they wouldn't have to make men take those assignments if they let women. This is the flip side to what I write above about why someone would want those assignments."
Nov 28, 2012

Comment Wall

You need to be a member of Art of Manliness to add comments!

Join Art of Manliness

  • No comments yet!
 
 
 

Latest Activity

Brad Williams replied to Augustin's discussion The Mask You Live In - Don't tell boy to man up! (Says video)
"Here's my crackpot theory.  I have no evidence for it except personal experience and that of my friends.  I think the issue is larger than just what's happening with boys -- I don't think it's a gender issue.  It…"
7 minutes ago
Mitch left a comment for Lon R.
"Any time man.  If you see me on AOM let me know.  I would be glad to chat. "
13 minutes ago
Brad Williams replied to Brad Williams's discussion Hunting Big Game if you Could?
"Thanks for your perspective, Shane.  It has a lot more weight because you've actually done this sort of thing.  So far the absence of someone who's done it chiming in and telling me how much they loved it is very telling. …"
27 minutes ago
Nick H replied to Augustin's discussion The Mask You Live In - Don't tell boy to man up! (Says video)
"You guys have no recess in the USA? In Canada they keep cutting phys ed."
3 hours ago
YL replied to Scott J's discussion A Good Easter to you all. The most sacred day of the year. in the group Christian Men
"Thanks Scott! Great video reminding us of the greatest act."
3 hours ago
Andrew D, USA Ret replied to Augustin's discussion The Mask You Live In - Don't tell boy to man up! (Says video)
"Engage his male instinct for problem solving." Boys and girls are different!  Wow, what a novel thought.  As much as some fool might wish that to not be true, and go through all manner of fallacious contortions to try to prove…"
3 hours ago
Andrew D, USA Ret replied to Andrew D, USA Ret's discussion Atheism ascendant throughout the world? Evidence shows the opposite in the group The Great Debate
"If the powers that be in Muslim nations feel Christianity or any other infidel faith to be ascendant, they will quash it with blood and fire as they've always done, and continue to do.   Bloody conquest is the only path for Christianity to…"
4 hours ago
Profile IconStephen Jashub Comstock and Matt joined Roberto's group
Thumbnail

Bird Watching

For men who enjoy birding - finding, tracking and sharing sightings of different bird species.See More
5 hours ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service