• Blog Posts
  • Discussions (2)
  • Groups
  • Photos
  • Photo Albums
  • Videos

Ben's Discussions

To circumcise or not?

Started this discussion. Last reply by Andrew Z May 26, 2013. 68 Replies

My wife and I are expecting our first son in a couple of months, and I was wondering if anyone had any pertinent advice/experience regarding circumcising a newborn.I grew up in the States and am…Continue

Tags: fatherhood, newborn, Circumcision

 

Ben's Page

Latest Activity

Andrew Z replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"As I learned in the last 10 months bringing a child into the world is essentially an extended exercise in evaluating risks and making decisions you think will do them the most good. I went back and forth on this for awhile, but then a few months ago…"
May 26, 2013
David Johns replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"It has been pointed out that females would avoid many "problems" if they had their labia removed soon after birth, but no one would do that because it would be considered barbaric. Unfortunately, male circumcision has a history in…"
May 25, 2013
Aaron Lancaster replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"Exactly! Circumcision is mutilation. I mean, would you circumcise your daughter?"
May 25, 2013
David Johns replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"The basic principle is this: The foreskin is not a birth defect that needs to be corrected.  God/nature did not make a mistake when a foreskin was put on the penis.  It's there for a reason."
Nov 8, 2012
Shane replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"1) No, but then, my genetics don't need enhancements.   2) Every day apparently.   3) The line of work I'm in, and my leisure time activities, precludes me from thinking anything that happens in a doctors office is…"
Sep 9, 2011
Penelope replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"Will is correct. Mine was a rebuttal, not a positive argument.   For #3, absolutely Yes. It's very hard to explain to a non-Semite what it feels like to be culturally or ethnically Jewish. I can give examples of concerns and offenses that…"
Sep 9, 2011
Patrick Smith replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"To those who say a circumcised penis is more aesthetically pleasing, do you also bleach your childrens hair and make them wear blue contact lenses because that looks more attractive too?   To those who say they do it to their sons "to look…"
Sep 9, 2011
Will replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"If you'll read Rebecca's post in context, you'll see it was not intended to argue that circumcision is the way to go, but that comparisons to FGM are invalid."
Sep 9, 2011
Patrick Smith replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"Thank you Michael! My sentiments exactly! It is barbaric, antiquated and perverse to wilfully sexually mutilate a child. (as it is seen at least by us here in Europe.)   I can understand that there are religious aspects and they have their…"
Sep 9, 2011
Patrick Smith replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"Not been online for a while  but I am going to answer a few points here:   We have to invent the female equivalent out of words. Let's lay out the important characteristics: 1. Millennia-old practice - Yup, can't argue with that,…"
Sep 9, 2011
Michael D. Denny replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"No.  Cutting off a body part just so that it does not have to be washed is barbaric, and that is the most flattering adjective I can offer.   Appearance is a non issue. If it is, your son is a flasher. Or has really, really,…"
Sep 2, 2011
Jack Bauer replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"You answered your own question.   JB"
Aug 29, 2011
Ben replied to Penelope's discussion To circumcise or not? in the group Christian Men
"This hot off the press from Christianity Today mag: http://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2011/september/criminalizingcircumcision.html"
Aug 29, 2011
Will replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"Rebecca wins the thread, for reasons of proportion.  (Except on the infant pain thing, I'd say; infants can't console themselves that it'll soon be over or it's worth it or anything; they just feel.)  But the female…"
Aug 29, 2011
Penelope replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"We have to invent the female equivalent out of words. Let's lay out the important characteristics: 1. Millennia-old practice 2. Deep religious significance 3. Deep ethnic/cultural significance 4. Possibly puts patient at reduced risk of…"
Aug 29, 2011
Penelope replied to Ben's discussion To circumcise or not?
"Not relevant. No one's killing anyone these days just because he's cut."
Aug 29, 2011

Comment Wall

You need to be a member of Art of Manliness to add comments!

Join Art of Manliness

  • No comments yet!
 
 
 

Latest Activity

Jack Bauer replied to Will's discussion What's going on in those heads in the group The Great Debate
"Condescension isn't necessary.  If you can't tell the difference between a savings account and an unemployment check, it also isn't warranted. JB"
14 minutes ago
Jack Bauer replied to Kevin's discussion Will someone please explain Jesus to me? in the group Christian Men
"This is a long (about an hour), but very good, video interview with Mark Driscoll that speaks to many of the questions asked here.  I very highly recommend it.  The interviewer is doing a documentary called "Hellbound?"…"
16 minutes ago
John Muir replied to Will's discussion What's going on in those heads in the group The Great Debate
"You don't need to - I was wondering if YOU understood that when you get money out of the bank you put in it's not a handout, since you seem to struggle with the concept of paying for something then getting it"
18 minutes ago
Rick Shelton commented on Josh Allen's photo
Thumbnail

Josh100LuBu - Such A Powerful Photo!

"Josh, re-read my previous post regarding misunderstanding of science.  I can't help you understand it, even if you wanted to, because you lack even the most basic understanding of science so there's nothing to build upon.  A…"
26 minutes ago
Jack Bauer replied to Will's discussion What's going on in those heads in the group The Great Debate
"No.  Not even going to bother explaining that one. JB"
30 minutes ago
WhiteBeard replied to Regular Joe's discussion Suggestions For A Sub-30K Station Wagon?
"You can find a pre-owned certified Volvo XC60 for well under 30K.  As Volvo is still hurting on the market, I find it's very easy to negotiate a good deal with them (I'm on my 2nd Volvo).  The XC60 is not the most exciting ride,…"
32 minutes ago
John Muir replied to Will's discussion What's going on in those heads in the group The Great Debate
"When you withdrawl money you put in the bank, is that a handout?"
35 minutes ago
Leto Atreides II commented on Josh Allen's photo
Thumbnail

Josh100LuBu - Such A Powerful Photo!

"If you're so sure you're being enslaved in that little shell take that hammer and break free."
39 minutes ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service