For those who believe in the idea of Hell, is there a chance of redemption, a path out of hell, or is the soul stuck in hell for ever?

Views: 366

Replies to This Discussion

hmmm

Tibetan Buddhists see a way out of hell, but, it takes an eon or so.  Islam says believers who sin have a temporary stay in hell before being released.  Judaism doesn't have an afterlife. Your standard Protestant Christians are too enamored with Dante, Blake and Milton to make this discussion worthwhile.

To add to the list; Hinduism says sins are atoned for in Hell prior to rebirth in accordance to the balance of Karma.

First, why should Blake matter? Secondly, only a Philistine would think Dante & Milton are not worth discussing.

Do Dante and Milton represent accurate, biblically supported versions of the afterlife? 

If not, are we considering all fictional accounts in our discussion (by which I mean those presented by writers of literature/fiction, not by the writers of canonically considered religious or mythological texts), or only those by people you respect? 

Liam, you are not forced to discuss any of these things; it's better that you don't, if you're going to talk about them like you talk about Plato.

I'm not sure that Shane is right about the influence of Dante & Milton, but I am inclined to run with him on these matters. I think he introduced the names because he means to discuss what people believe with or without support in authorized writings. Is he being sneaky? Maybe, but the OP did ask believers, not specifying he wants authorized writings...

Now, for my part, I picked up on his trail just because I don't think writers like Dante come up often, or rarely, either; so it would be worth talking about anyway. Milton I don't know much about, just enough not to dismiss him. Strange political goings on in that poem.

Blake illustrated Divine Comedy and Paradise Lost

Dante and Milton are absolutely worth discussing, in their own right.  However, these three are whom provided the standard Christian vision of hell.  The problem for this discussion is, they didn't pull from the Bible, but rather apocrypha and pseudo-epigrapha, for inspiration.

I did not know about the illustration business. As for the rest, yeah, the Bible does not take much interest in the matter...

Ciampolo the Barrator Tormented by the Devils - Inferno

Satan Calling up His Legions - Paradise Lost

The latter illustration is great. Those are men.

Strange men.  There's a distinct lack of emotion in their faces.  One would think the legions of hell would be a bit more excited when the Lord of Darkness called them forth.

I'm not sure what to make of their faces. But I am not sure about the excitement. Determination would be enough, I think. Maybe they have an awareness of fate-

Determination may well be enough.  Awareness, I see none of that either.  Simple flowers growing towards the light.

RSS

Latest Activity

Carl Monster replied to Nerdbeast's discussion hardgainer
"Me too Brian; all age starting bringing me was sag, and boy that does not look good on skinny."
13 minutes ago
The Dutch Dastard replied to Daniel's discussion Casual Belts for Jeans?
"Just remember: if you're wearing a leather belt and leather shoes, make sure the belt (somewhat) matches the shoes. So: brown shoes-brown belt, black shoes-black belt. Then again, if you're wearing white leather trainers, don't get a…"
19 minutes ago
Michael D. Denny replied to Culper Junior's discussion This picture on an AoM article
23 minutes ago
Michael D. Denny replied to Nathan DeParis's discussion Women: The Infallible Baromoter
"Depends on exactly what manners he believed to show a positive reflection on society. "
25 minutes ago
Will replied to Nathan DeParis's discussion Women: The Infallible Baromoter
"The practical outcome if I adopt this perspective is that women will show their rears?  I ordinarily don't like paraphrases of others' posts -- seems too much like straw man -- but you've given me nothing more to work with!"
53 minutes ago
The Dutch Dastard replied to Uncle Sam's discussion 20 years old and enlisting tomorrow. Tips and thoughts?
"Ahh....the army didn't want my crooked back, dinged knees, or flat feet either. A buddy of mine (fit and smart as a whip) didn't get in to flight school because his parents were divorced (yup, that was the only reason).  If you truly…"
1 hour ago
The Dutch Dastard replied to Matt Lange's discussion Mix and match vests
"This; nothing else can be said except for maybe a fabric match/mismatch. "
1 hour ago
Dave Harding replied to The Earl of Essex's discussion Office ideas
"I like a minimalist approach as well: apart from the computer (and necessary cords/ports/etc to plug accessories in) I go for a couple of pens, some paper to scribble on, a filing tray to hold current work, and perhaps one personal item to cheer me…"
1 hour ago

© 2013   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service