http://edwardfeser.blogspot.com/2013/10/some-varieties-of-bullsht.html

What interests me here is the distinction between lies and BS.  With lies, you are against the truth.  With BS, you just don't care.  

So it has a different purpose... or may not!

You may be giving BS not to convince others of your words, but to convince them of something else:  say, you give 'em a lot of crap detail about issue X, not because you care what they think of issue X, but to convince them you're smart.  You may want to distract them from something else (like why you haven't done something you promised).  You may want to make sharp, clear questions seem fuzzy, so you can get away with something.  Or not face something.

On tests, you may simply be hoping some of your guesses happen to be right.  So you make lots of them.

It reminds me of the poetry of T. S. Eliot.  He's not talking about mermaids and peaches and Michelangelo; he's talking about feeling old and insecure... but it works.

Those are my random thoughts on BS.  What's yours?  Do you BS others -- or yourself?  Is your BS detector online -- and do you find others' to work too?  (Feel free to BS, but be warned:  with a thread title like this, everybody's going to be on the lookout for it!)  

Views: 59

Replies to This Discussion

I never read the essay that made this a topic, so I won't talk about that. But I can tell you that this suggestion that big speeches are for self-promotion reminds me of what may have been the hallmark of the classical sophists. That, I suppose, would be the high end of the range. In that case, as far as I understand, there is a kind of skepticism of society--there being no knowledge of the human things, or the political things, there can be no truth. (This could be argued in this way: The science of nature studies the unchanging things--there is knowledge there; science of the very variable human things is impossible; theoretical physics is the most important, or nearly, politics the least, or nearly.) That is why persuasion is important--human beings can be dangerous, or useful--whereas truth simply does not matter.

There is a lot of this nowadays as well; I suppose that whenever there is no persuasive argument that human things do admit of scientific or philosophic inquiry, this opinion may flourish, so to speak, that there is no truth, only opinions.--I think Americans call this spin. I think it goes very far. I remember hearing Mr. Stewart & Mr. Colbert say, as a kind of defense of their shows, that they do comedy, or entertain. (Suggesting that nobody takes them seriously--they are innocent, for their activity is innocuous, & they have no influence on serious life.) But of course their comedy includes criticism of political opinions they dislike; if it is only entertainment, that is because there is no truth about the human things, or political things--all they can do is persuade those who laugh at their jokes to vote their sense of humor, so to speak...

RSS

Latest Activity

Jones replied to Jedi Knight's discussion Getting to Know a Woman
"Collared shirt, no flowers....but you could treat everyone to ice cream.  "
5 minutes ago
Andrew D, USA Ret replied to Josh Allen's discussion If you can tell me what religion you are then you are in a prison.
""...an overall hands off approach..." Very deist of you.  "
15 minutes ago
Karl Helweg replied to Jack Neulist's discussion Finding the "Old Ones": Who really settled North America first? in the group History Buffs
"In 1888 gold prospector George Kershon reported finding an ancient frozen city with strange buildings still partially covered by a…"
18 minutes ago
Rebekah replied to Michael's discussion National Parks
"My sister has worked in Yellowstone and Yosemite.  One of her jobs at Yosemite was finding a place to stay for people who arrived in the middle of the summer with no reservations.  It usually took several phone calls to "nearby"…"
27 minutes ago
Jack Bauer replied to Andrew D, USA Ret's discussion Obama's Press Secretary decorates his home with Soviet Propaganda! in the group The Great Debate
"A quick Crocodile Dundee Test might make it unnecessary.   JB"
29 minutes ago
Rick Shelton replied to Josh Allen's discussion If you can tell me what religion you are then you are in a prison.
"Then God will follow His own laws... I agree with your final conclusion no matter the path you've taken to get there. "
33 minutes ago
Michael replied to Michael's discussion National Parks
"With regards to the first-come, first-served camping, I would have thought that this would seem to make it difficult to find a spot. However, I arrived in Yellowstone last September when all park lodging and camping was entirely full, except for a…"
44 minutes ago
Jack Bauer replied to Jack Bauer's discussion Nevada Ranch War ... in the group The Great Debate
"I'll bet that's the first time a liberal has ever made that argument about somebody who's living off the government.  There are greedy people costing us plenty more that I doubt you even blink an eye at. JB"
48 minutes ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service