Information

Stoicism

For the discussion of the Philosophy of Stoicism.

Website: http://www.motfu.com.au/tau/category/stoicism
Members: 55
Latest Activity: Aug 21

Discussion Forum

Can an athiest be a stoic?

Started by John Thomas. Last reply by Liam Strain Oct 11, 2010. 8 Replies

Marcus Aurelius: "an individual's mind is God, and is of God", "God gave each of us to lead and guideus, a fragment of himself. Which is our mind, our logos." A question I've heared posed many times…Continue

RSS

Loading… Loading feed

Comment Wall

Comment

You need to be a member of Stoicism to add comments!

Comment by Jdog on December 12, 2011 at 9:27pm

Read "Meditations" by MA. Enjoyed it thoroughly but it must be taken with a grain of salt. 

One book also worthy of mention, though not a book about Stoicism (the author did behave stoically) is "Man's Search for Meaning" by Victor E. Frankl. 

Comment by platypanda on November 27, 2010 at 3:09pm
First became "attracted" to stoicism when hearing about Admiral Stockdale's experiences in Vietnam. (Comedian Dennis Miller's defense of Admiral Stockdale was truly moving). But, I don't really quite "get it" beyond a version of "accept what is happening" and some vaguely understood implication as to what truly exists and what is false. Tried reading Epictetus a few times, and it didn't go too well... Any ideas for books that may be interesting? (for me, I almost have to read about it well before doing anything about it). Mahalo.
Comment by John Thomas on August 17, 2010 at 11:36am
Stoicism and Manliness~
Greeks are often depicted as aloof rational thinkers, but the real ethos was quite different. The values associated with manliess transfered to Rome, later through Christianity to the rest of the west. Stoicism if not the main impetus, was an essential component. Since the death of Socrates, an example was set as the philosopher to be "scholar-warrior". Willing to suffer and die for truth.

Stoicism in the Hellenistic age epitomised maniliness. Modeling Spartan values rather than Athens the value of Androsyne was to be cultivated by a philosopher.Androsyne means, manliness, courage, fortitude. It is derived from the Greek word for man, andros. This meant the philospher is fearless, and does not shy from even death if necessary.

The Romans later accepted stoicism as a philosophy wholeheartedly because it resonated with Roman traditional values. The very word virtue actually means manliness. The roman ethic of virtus, or bravery, was derived from vir meaning man.

Early evangalizing Christians accepted this classical ideal to represent the zeal in working for Christ. They called themselves, agonistes or strugglers or athletes/champions of the Christian message. This effort was part of the ethos of the western world ever since.
Comment by John Thomas on August 17, 2010 at 11:11am
First off hello, I'm suprised no one has anything to say on a site about manhood, anything to say on Stoicism. I think it was a good idea to create this group.
 

Members (55)

 
 
 

Latest Activity

Native Son replied to Tim the Enforcer's discussion Ammo shortage or manufactured crisis?
"One west coast paper did an investigative article on this.  One reason ammo is short is that demand has outstripped supply. One reason is that with two hot wars going on for years, the bulk of US ammunition production went to making 5.56NATO,…"
15 minutes ago
Native Son replied to Tim the Enforcer's discussion Ammo shortage or manufactured crisis?
"Agree about WWII.  In the late 1960s, an uncle of mine was still buying new in the box military ball .30-06 rifle and .30 carbine ammunition headstamped as loaded during WWII."
22 minutes ago
Bob Brower replied to PSharikov's discussion Anyone else sick to death of MANLY-discussions?
"I agree somewhat . there are guys here that have grown up lets say in a city or without a father , or in a less than manly environment . these guys really are looking for guidance . where do you think there going to find it?  there is nothing…"
32 minutes ago
Will replied to PSharikov's discussion Anyone else sick to death of MANLY-discussions?
"I keep trying to reply to Shane,  and it keeps moving the post.  Will fix when I am on a regular computer. "
33 minutes ago
John Lee Pettimore replied to PSharikov's discussion Anyone else sick to death of MANLY-discussions?
"Lighten up Francis."
34 minutes ago
Will replied to PSharikov's discussion Anyone else sick to death of MANLY-discussions?
"I see what you did there.  I think."
36 minutes ago
Will replied to PSharikov's discussion Anyone else sick to death of MANLY-discussions?
"I love the is it manly discussions.  Especially my own: manliest ice cream flavor. The serious ones, too, and the serious answer that it's not the activity but the attitude is an easy answer to give. It's for entertainment.  If…"
38 minutes ago
Augustin replied to PSharikov's discussion Anyone else sick to death of MANLY-discussions?
"Great post. Agreed. "
47 minutes ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service