Is it preferable to be mortal or immortal?

As humans, we are aware of our own mortality from a very early age, and the presence of that knowledge pervades everything we as individuals and as society do. If medical science were advanced enough to grant us immortality, should we take it? Or by doing so would we lose a central part of our humanity?

Tags: 7, Day, Immortality, Mortality, Question

Views: 21

Replies to This Discussion

If by immortality we mean you can *never* die, maybe that would be too much. Sounds like a Greek myth: someone cursed by never being allowed to die.

If it means you won't die of old age...it would be interesting to see what five hundred year old people would be like. Oldsters now are less tolerant of risk, often more set in their ways. They're sometimes (not always) less doctrinaire than they were in their youth. Would a thousand-year-old man be stuck in 600-year-old routine, disdaining to do anything uncomfortable or risky, and dismissing college-age idealism as a waste of time? Or would he have to reset to an earlier perspective? Don't know.
Intriguing thought. However, I disagree with the premise. While we are aware of our own mortality, we also have a deep set idea that we aren't supposed to die. If we are all aware that we will die, and that it is supposed to be that way, when they do we fight death as hard as we do?

I think living with the idea that what we do is eternal is not counter to our humanity, but in fact central.
If we alter the characteristics of humanity we alter the way we define it. I don't know if we would lose or gain anything, but it would be different. I do know that it would be very crowded and that the current problems with the social security system would seem mild by comparison.
What if it is the simple fact that we mortal that makes us try and define good and evil and at least try to be good and live the good life? If so, our mortality might indeed be the most central part of our humanity.

Might an immortal being be less concerned with morality because they could get away with so much more without the consequence of death? If so, would immortality be central to inhumanity?
Being an immortal would SUCK.

Can YOU imagine being in a war for 200-300 years?
People would be down in the dumps all the time because there would be no excuse to have goals. "I must do this thing before I die." Can't commit suicide because I'm a frickin' immortal.

Anyway, I have holy rollers who come to my front door promising me immortality if I only write them a check. I just tell them that it's an awfully selfish thing to want to live forever and to continue crowding the planet & using up resourses.



Please allow me to die and do not turn me into a zombie.
It's best to reflect on the "forbidden fruit" scene in Milton's Paradise Lost and in Genesis.
I would lovee to be immortal, I was born a loner so I don't believe that it would bother me too much as long as I stayed secluded and only went to people if I needed something. Of course this would automatically turn anyone into a psycic vampire but you could come out into public with your immortality and become the wisest council that ever lived.

RSS

Latest Activity

Michael D. Denny replied to MiCHAEL J K.'s discussion being myself
"n'kay. "
51 minutes ago
Carl Monster replied to MiCHAEL J K.'s discussion being myself
"Thanks for sharing, but I am sure, like Will says, there is much more to your story."
58 minutes ago
Pale Horse replied to Josh Allen's discussion If you can tell me what religion you are then you are in a prison.
"It must be documented (other than by us) because he mentioned not taking his meds. Maybe he's schizo."
1 hour ago
Jack Bauer replied to Thomas James's discussion Paying off a large credit card debt vs. settlement? Are there pros? How bad are the cons?
"Shane -- It is a moral answer to a moral question that the asker thought was a technical one.  I'm not on opposite side here from the Bundy situation... just answering a different question.   LCA -- That's not how tax…"
1 hour ago
Will replied to MiCHAEL J K.'s discussion being myself
"I am sure there's way more to your story.  Share if you care to."
2 hours ago
Profile IconCollin Daly, Micah J. Kistler, J Hanson and 16 more joined Art of Manliness
2 hours ago
Lucius Artorius Castus replied to Thomas James's discussion Paying off a large credit card debt vs. settlement? Are there pros? How bad are the cons?
"If you pay taxes, it's neither Right or wrong to not pay the full amount. The debt is written off on the company's taxes as a full deduction, so they already got their money, then they sell the debt to a collection agency for pennies on…"
3 hours ago
Rebekah replied to Thomas James's discussion Paying off a large credit card debt vs. settlement? Are there pros? How bad are the cons?
"Probably not immediately sink you deeper into debt that will show up on a balance sheet - but making payments on a debt could keep you from moving to an area with better job prospects, keep you from getting better transportation that would result in…"
3 hours ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service