Is our society being desensitised to violent behaviour by television?

Do we in fact live in a more violent world? If so, can it be said that the increase in crime dramas and violent action films are fueling this?

Tags: 6, question, television, violence

Views: 21

Replies to This Discussion

Without any numbers to back me up, I have heard, and I would like to think that despite some current and very mindful examples to the contrary, we are living in the least violent time in history and the trend is continuing.

I would also like to think that if any media is blamed for someone committing violent acts, then it means those criminals cannot tell the difference between fantasy and reality. If the criminal cannot tell the difference between fantasy and reality, then media as a cause seems to be a spurious one and the violence was going to happen anyway.

However, there are those would say that there is a certain percentage of the population that are induced to violent behavior by violent media and therefore because of that percentage the media should be more tightly restricted or even banned. I feel this percentage is small and there is an overwhelmingly larger reciprocal percentage of the population that will not be induced to violent behavior by violent medial. As someone that can tell the difference between fantasy and reality, I would prefer not to be planed down to the level of the mentally unstable (who would mostly likely end up violent without exposure to the media) and have whole genres restricted (from me) or legislated away because of them.

As far as being desensitized to violence. I think we need to be more desensitized. Not to the point that we don't care or stop recognizing violence as something that is not good or and in some cases evil. But to the point we can deal with violence when it occurs in a more efficient (less knee jerk reactive) way because it does occur. I am not saying media violence does that either, but sometimes I feel like society is turning itself into the Eloi (for you HG Wells fans out there).

And don't even get me started on Wednesday's US Supreme Court Ruling against "Fleeting Expletives". Are we really such babies that even accidental swear words are now illegal and actionable? That is a little off the topic but still a little relevant, so I decided to vent.
Very good points David. I'm sure statistically the times must be erring towards less violent, but I think it feels as if the opposite is true as so much more is reported in the news and media. Crime dramas and violent films are not a cause, but could indeed prove a catalyst to an already disturbed mind...
Just to go on a slight tangent, isn't it weird that you can see the most violent and profane videos on youtube, but nothing deemed 'pornographic' such a flash of nipple? Just coming at it from an arts background where there's ample nudity in various media, it seems that the violent content would be a lot more damaging than anything that happens to contain nudity but isn't explicitly exploitative/porn...
Following that aside: I have heard before that American standards on cinema (in constrast to British) were too tolerant of violence and not enough of sex; that is, you can see very violent acts but not a lot of sex. That was 1970's; it's obviously changed.

But even at the time: you can have sex on film or in real life. You can have violence in film or in real life. As for me, I'd rather the sex be real and the violence be special effects!

--

Dave's right: the world is less violent than it used to be. As Kasper points out, we *perceive* it as being more common because it's in the news more...which is true because being rarer, it's more newsworthy! Ironic.

But there may be something in the promotion of violence by *graphic* depictions of violence. Hearing that Hansel & Gretel put the witch in the oven hasn't to my knowledge led any child in history to bake a witch. But if they saw the process, up-close, the witch screaming and dying, and if it were *entertainment* to see it happen ... maybe that would either desensitize the viewer, or at least drive away those who weren't desensitized!
Honestly, I have to take a slightly different stance here. Do I think the amount of violence in our media is helping? Not really no. That said, the old testament is filled with stories of killing and fucking which would make many modern movies sound tame, and until the last century the beating of children was seen as a cultural norm. So in all, exposure to real violence has sharply declined in the last century. That said I believe the primary ill of modern media to be that it gives a stylized and unrealistic view of violence. Firstly, when the media portrays the deaths of millions in the news, and in a brand new TV show 18 people are killed in the first episode, death on a large scale is easier for people to accept, it seems less gruesome, the idea of nuclear weapons or genocide isn't as big of a shock, and this is much more dangerous.
Also, violence touches every life at one time or another, and the stylized unrealistic way it is portrayed means that people are unprepared for it when they most need to be. I was once in the middle of a friendley exchange of insults in front of my coffee shop (the kind in which both guys are bored and just making jokes at the others expense and usually laugh about it and make up) when the other guy pulled a knife on me. Now, this guy has changed things from good-natured banter to life-death struggle in a second and doesn't even realize it. My first thought was that I needed to kill him before he had a chance to react (I believe I could have if necessary.) But honestly he was just a harmless guy who thought it would be cool to look tough and pull a knife like he'd seen on TV. So I told him I would hospitalize him if he didn't put the knife away, and he did. He wasn't a killer, or even a bad guy, he had seen stylized violence like pulling a knife to the point he thought nothing of it and didn't realize he was threatening someone's life. That is the problem I have with the violence in our media, it is portrayed as less serious than it actually is, and unrealistically, gun-fights go on for 30 min. and people are stabbed four times and then win anyway and are having sex later that night. Violence is a fact of life and always will be, but our culture's portrayal of it as a something easy and fun, is horribly harmful.
I think that we, or at least i am, are becoming desensitized to violence on television and the internet. I can pretty solidly state that i could watch a man's head get blown off on TV and not flinch, but im not sure i could say the same thing if it happened right in front of me in real life. Im not sure about how other people view TV. and Video games and what not but I guess in the back of my head i know their not real and stuff like that. Thats just the fictional stuff though, I can sit through the news and "shock videos" on the internet without any feeling, i may feel bad for the person being tormented or suffering but I guess you could say I am desensitized.
No, we don't live in a more violent world, we just live in a more media accessible world. We can now turn on the TV, or go on the internet and see live, pictures or videos of a tribe being murdered in africa, or 3 teens from europe killing a man with a screwdriver. The violence is just more publicized these days.

RSS

Latest Activity

Carl Monster replied to Alberto's discussion Push-ups
"While form is key with any movement, pushups are pretty innocuous when it comes to the ability to get hurt. Only bodyweight is involved. Maybe some knuckle burn?"
14 minutes ago
Rick Shelton replied to Curtis's discussion Can you learn/teach tranquility?
""but I would like to give off an heir of prestige, without putting others off" No you would like to comport yourself with confidence without being overbearing.  English Police: airs not heirs and confidence is the term you want not…"
15 minutes ago
Chip replied to alophant's discussion Acupuncture, massage, and other Eastern medicines in the group Naturopathic Healing
"Yeah, today is the third day we have practiced them in class for myofascial release. I've been doing a cup and drag across some scars from a childhood surgery. It's really beneficial. Also, I just feel great after having it done - even…"
17 minutes ago
Rick Shelton replied to Curtis's discussion Can you learn/teach tranquility?
"I liked Serenity, hell of a good show."
20 minutes ago
Rick Shelton replied to Andreias's discussion Gender Identity vs Gender Expression Or How I Figured Out People Have NO Idea What Masculinity Is
""I don't believe that hormones are that strongly defining" You would be wrong.  Hormones drive behavior and behavior is how the world percieves us. Further if hormones were not that strongly defining how do you explain FtM…"
23 minutes ago
Rick Shelton replied to Alberto's discussion Push-ups
"For pushups the "Optimized Way" is to do them the "Correct Way" other than that it is a matter of your muscles getting stronger and more endurance.  One of the biggest hurdles for newcomers to weight lifting and/or getting…"
33 minutes ago
Carl Monster replied to Curtis's discussion Can you learn/teach tranquility?
44 minutes ago
Will replied to Alex Pape's discussion Moving forward with dating
"Rein in those horses for a few weeks.  If she's for you, you've got a lifetime to enjoy her company."
48 minutes ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service