I want to know exactly how much people know about Civil War medicine, what they think about it, and would they be interested in learning more about it. I'm an avid scholar of Civil War medical history and I'm trying to get a feel for contemporary opinions and breadth of knowledge about Civil War medicine, particularly what people today think about the surgeons.

Views: 54

Replies to This Discussion

I know nothing. Just stereotypes of saw-bone doctors in field hospitals, using whiskey as anaesthetic and antiseptic... these are probably stereotypes that aren't supported by evidence. I have read some of Walt Whitman's work as a nurse in the Civil War, via a biography of him.

I'd love to know more. I'm sure it's a history that can be written well and in an interesting manner!

I do know that morphine was available, and plentifully used as an analgesic. In fact, it was so commonly used that morphine addiction came to be known as "Soldier's Disease". Bear in mind, it was still a very new drug, and the concept of physiological as well as psychological addiction were not really understood.

I believe that it was during the civil war that the technique of intravenous injection of drugs was first tested in the field, although not via a dedicated intravenous catheter, as is the case nowadays. Drugs were injected directly from a syringe into a punctured vein (a technique we call a "hot shot" these days). Syringes back then were glass and steel affairs, and the needles had to be sharpened periodically so that they could puncture skin. In fact, my grandmother (a nurse for 60 years) left me a set of such syringes when she passed away. I keep them in a shadow box on my wall. Quite beautiful, i think.

I could be wrong, but i believe that this was around the time when the concept of antisepsis (proposed by one Baron Von Lister, from whom listerine took it's namesake) was first beginning to take hold. In those early days, the readily available anitseptics were either alcohol (yes Vy, the whiskey antiseptic story is true), phenol, or creosote (imagine rubbing that on a fresh stump. OUCH!)

Again, check the books, but i do believe that ether was available as an anesthetic, although rarely used in the field due to its explosive nature.

    I once heard a story that a doctor doing amputations in a two story building would drop the bad limb in a pile out the window. Eventually the pile became level with the window. I also saw a picture of a typical Civil War doctor's briefcase. It has a lot of saws.

    I think heroin was invented during the Civil War in an attempt to create a pain killer less addictive than morphine. We see how that turned out...


Latest Activity

Jay posted a discussion

An orange in a bag of apples

My name is Jay and I'm a 20 year old male living in Queensland, Australia. I am existentialist in my beliefs and pragmatic in my views. I study and enjoy natural science and have a secondary hobby interest in psychology and the potential origin of conscience for which I have currently made a 3 variable emotional prediction scale test.  Online I can take the time to express and articulate my views coherently, in real life this week, I was diagnosed with bi-polar 2 disorder by my psychiatrist and…See More
16 minutes ago
Shane replied to Sir's discussion How goes the war in the group The Great Debate
"That and the SU-24 used Walmart grade GPS for navigation."
35 minutes ago
Native Son replied to Sir's discussion How goes the war in the group The Great Debate
"More likely the Russians are still using the same operations manual from back when they shot down that Korean airliner.  That's the one that says you do exactly what the guy on the ground back at the air base says to do.   Russian…"
1 hour ago
certified male replied to Tim Merrill's discussion Hello, from Ohio
"Hi Tim.  Work in Elyria, live in Amherst."
2 hours ago
certified male replied to Robert Edwin House's discussion Hello everyone
"This site is pretty interesting.  Guys being guys."
2 hours ago
Sam K replied to Sam K's discussion Spectre film
"I agree that it was definitely an attempt to get Bond back to his roots; Skyfall was setting up for this too by bringing back Moneypenny and Q, and the gadget car.Personally I prefer the grittier style of Casino Royale to the campier Bond movies,…"
2 hours ago
Regular Joe replied to Regular Joe's discussion World's Best Whisky Officially Declared
"Japanese whisky has been considered among the best in the world for some time now.  "For some time it was believed by many that whisky made in the Scottish style, but not produced in Scotland, could not possibly measure up to the…"
3 hours ago
Sam K replied to Johnny Luka's discussion Not sure how to handle situation
"It's important to maintain the mindset that there are "lots of fish", and no matter how awesome this particular woman seems at a glance, you don't really know her yet at all and the rest is your imagination of how you'd…"
3 hours ago

© 2015   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service