I want to know exactly how much people know about Civil War medicine, what they think about it, and would they be interested in learning more about it. I'm an avid scholar of Civil War medical history and I'm trying to get a feel for contemporary opinions and breadth of knowledge about Civil War medicine, particularly what people today think about the surgeons.

Views: 56

Replies to This Discussion

I know nothing. Just stereotypes of saw-bone doctors in field hospitals, using whiskey as anaesthetic and antiseptic... these are probably stereotypes that aren't supported by evidence. I have read some of Walt Whitman's work as a nurse in the Civil War, via a biography of him.

I'd love to know more. I'm sure it's a history that can be written well and in an interesting manner!

I do know that morphine was available, and plentifully used as an analgesic. In fact, it was so commonly used that morphine addiction came to be known as "Soldier's Disease". Bear in mind, it was still a very new drug, and the concept of physiological as well as psychological addiction were not really understood.

I believe that it was during the civil war that the technique of intravenous injection of drugs was first tested in the field, although not via a dedicated intravenous catheter, as is the case nowadays. Drugs were injected directly from a syringe into a punctured vein (a technique we call a "hot shot" these days). Syringes back then were glass and steel affairs, and the needles had to be sharpened periodically so that they could puncture skin. In fact, my grandmother (a nurse for 60 years) left me a set of such syringes when she passed away. I keep them in a shadow box on my wall. Quite beautiful, i think.

I could be wrong, but i believe that this was around the time when the concept of antisepsis (proposed by one Baron Von Lister, from whom listerine took it's namesake) was first beginning to take hold. In those early days, the readily available anitseptics were either alcohol (yes Vy, the whiskey antiseptic story is true), phenol, or creosote (imagine rubbing that on a fresh stump. OUCH!)

Again, check the books, but i do believe that ether was available as an anesthetic, although rarely used in the field due to its explosive nature.

    I once heard a story that a doctor doing amputations in a two story building would drop the bad limb in a pile out the window. Eventually the pile became level with the window. I also saw a picture of a typical Civil War doctor's briefcase. It has a lot of saws.

    I think heroin was invented during the Civil War in an attempt to create a pain killer less addictive than morphine. We see how that turned out...

RSS

Latest Activity

Jack Bauer replied to Sam K's discussion MGTOW - the worst of the "men's movement" websites?
"We've had serious and combative discussions since long before you came along.  That's not it. JB"
8 minutes ago
Gentleman Engineer replied to Mongoose's discussion How Your Dress Affects Your Future
"Despite the lack of requirement for such, one does don a tie most every morn. Such an accessory would allow for versatility upon the weather or whims. In the event that the tie of four-in-hand would exist precluded, the tie of the bow would exist as…"
15 minutes ago
GK replied to GK's discussion Fear of abandonment
"I'm not lookI'll try to pick this up as well, thank you for your advice!"
18 minutes ago
Sam K replied to Sam K's discussion MGTOW - the worst of the "men's movement" websites?
"So does it:1. Interfere with the tone of the website? (Style is overly-serous or combatative)(My main purpose is to give onlookers a chance to have some of these concepts illustrated for them. Most people here want to keep it lighter and…"
19 minutes ago
Rick Shelton replied to Sam K's discussion Materialism and Marxism in the group The Great Debate
"Possibly in the right cultural context socialism can be fairly applied to the benefit of the entire population but I wonder.  Is there a minimum amount that one is required to put into the system (taxes)?  Is it an 'across the…"
21 minutes ago
Sam K replied to Sam K's discussion Materialism and Marxism in the group The Great Debate
"Well Rick fact is you reguarily reply to my topics with contradictory claims, then claim frustration when replied back to.So that seems a little manipulative to me. If you don't want to discuss something you don't have to reply, but…"
23 minutes ago
Esgrimma replied to Sam K's discussion Materialism and Marxism in the group The Great Debate
"You should really stop saying "communism and socialism" like they are the same. They are worlds apart. As Regular Joe said "it's like lumping capitalism and fascism in the same bucket." What you said about socialism not…"
24 minutes ago
Liam Strain replied to Sam K's discussion MGTOW - the worst of the "men's movement" websites?
"Your style of discussion interferes with your actual arguments."
24 minutes ago

© 2016   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service