I don't know how many of you guys heard about this in the news today, but today 4 women filed a suit against the Department of Defense over the rules that exclude women in combat. My college class discussed this issue today and of no consensus was met.  Just wonder how you guys or gals feel about this issue. Should they let the ladies fight? If yes, in what capacity? Heres an article about it incase you missed it. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/11/27/women-in-combat-defense-de... 

Views: 1244

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Should they let the ladies fight? If yes, in what capacity?

 

Yes. In whatever capacity they are qualified physically and mentally to do so. If a woman passes the same standards for physical fitness, skills and such as a man in a similar role - I see no reason for her sex to be barrier to her service. 

 

With that said, I do not expect the roles, responsibilities and requirements to be modified (or not much anyway) to accommodate. E.g. if the requirement for an infantryman is to march 10 miles with a 50lb pack (hypothetical) - there should not be a separate standard for woman infantry. 

I totally agree with this.

I know of one lady at West Point who's nick name was Rucksack.  It's all you saw when she was running with her kit.  It was the same kit as everyone else.  

If the person can do the job physically and mentally then let them do it.  Be it militarily  fire, police, EMT, CEO, etc.

That's not exactly possible.  Military physical fitness standards don't measure you're full physical abilities... they use a couple of tests that are supposed to be representative of your overall strength and stamina.  I'm not exactly a fitness machine... I go to the gym approximately never... and yet I can do more pushups than a lot of very fit women because I have a male frame.

Women in the military currently don't have to do nearly as many pushups as men do to pass their PT tests, because the number of pushups you can do is irrelevant except as a gauge for your broader fitness level.  A woman who can do as many pushups as I can could probably kick my ass.

It's not so easy to compare men and women that way.

Not to mention one can imagine situations where women's general smaller frames and greater flexibility would be a tactical advantage. There's also issues of brain structure regarding multi-tasking, the ability to learn languages, and likely stuff about sleep deprivation, pain tolerance, etc.

Of course, if the military is going to consider being short and flexible a tactical advantage, that involves a re-thinking of the traditional ideal of uniformity for soldiers. But, again, maybe modern combat suggests we should be open to that.

Tunnel rats.  Snipers. Tankers.  Submariners.

Those aren't Direct Action units though.

It's not a comparison.  It's a base standard everyone begins with.  Minimum requirements are minimum requirements.  There shouldn't be gender norming for requirements.

The standards are different... very, very different.  A man in his 20s (22-26) has to do a minimum of 40 pushups to pass.  A woman the same age has to do 17.  The situp standards, on the other hand, are identical for each gender.

No s hit. I'm saying raise the standards. Gender norming places equality on outcome. Gender neutral places equality on opportunity. Make everyone's minimum standards the same. That way everyone has the same starting line.

If the goal is to ensure that people from each sex are equally physically capable of performing the job, having uniform pushup standards doesn't do that. 

But, telling girls they don't even need to do half as many pushups as men somehow makes them capable of trying out?

That was my point.  It's not so easy to measure men and women the same way.  They're not the same.

So, you think there is some over arching reason a healthy, physically fit female in her 20's is incapable of performing 40 pushups (or in my case 3 pullups) other than she's never been told she must, and therefore never trains for it?

RSS

Latest Activity

Pale Horse replied to Drew McAuliffe's discussion Any Guys looking forward to NCAA 2015 TOURNEY?
"I figured he might react the way he did, but it was mainly for your sake anyway, since you listed it,"
5 minutes ago
Pale Horse replied to Drew McAuliffe's discussion Any Guys looking forward to NCAA 2015 TOURNEY?
"No, not at all. I was referring to Steve. On a previous thread about AoM noobs, saying Shane is a jerk is one of the characteristics."
10 minutes ago
Adrian McPherson added a discussion to the group Teachers' Club (for men in Education)
Thumbnail

Ideal teacher = female teacher? Uh...

Hi all,I didn't expect this to happen, but there is something on which I am desperate to get other male teachers' opinions.Short backstory: After a career in finance I have returned to university to study teaching (I'm 32). After completing a 4 year Bachelor of Arts, I am in my final year, studying a Graduate Diploma in order to get my teaching qualifications.Sitting in a room of 90+ students, with only 4 others being male, the lecturer asked us to form groups to discuss what we would consider…See More
20 minutes ago
Adrian McPherson joined Andrioux's group
Thumbnail

Teachers' Club (for men in Education)

Virtual staff room for visionary teachers of every discipline. This is a good place for educators to discuss their collective role in society--particularly in regards to their duty as role models for young men. What does it mean to be a male role model for young boys in the classroom? How can we serve them best? See More
39 minutes ago
Max replied to Drew McAuliffe's discussion Any Guys looking forward to NCAA 2015 TOURNEY?
"Yes, but is the dress black and blue or gold and white? :o"
41 minutes ago
Will replied to Drew McAuliffe's discussion Any Guys looking forward to NCAA 2015 TOURNEY?
"Men poke at each other. I often dont like it either, but it doesnt mean they hate you. It just means they're having some fun. And you'll notice nobody said anything bad abt you or your momma. They did some inside jokes, which wasn't…"
45 minutes ago
Adrian McPherson replied to Drew McAuliffe's discussion Any Guys looking forward to NCAA 2015 TOURNEY?
"It's the internet; there will always be trolls, just don't engage. Your post was perfectly reasonable. I'm not in the US, but I love watching American Football. Fast paced, genuine tactics, good action. Sadly though it's rare to…"
51 minutes ago
Drew McAuliffe replied to Drew McAuliffe's discussion Any Guys looking forward to NCAA 2015 TOURNEY?
"If this is in reference to me, yeah, i am new to the site. I was under the (potentially false?) impression that there would be maybe some other guys that shared a mutual appreciation for collegiate sports. Sadly, it seems you some of you guys just…"
1 hour ago

© 2015   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service