As Professor Kirk in the first Narnia book said -- appalled that these young children weren't thinking logically enough -- "I wonder what they do teach them in these schools."

We were just talking on another thread about rhetoric -- something they didn't teach me back when and aren't teaching now. I'd like to see it: sound thinking, reasoned analysis of argument.

They *were* teaching geometry when I was in school, that is, Euclidean proofs. In my home state, at least, they've stopped doing that. Geometry is now descriptive -- "that's a square; that's a circle" -- and proofs are gone. (Possibly as a result of this trend, a math prof at a local college admitted to me he thinks some of his majors graduate without understanding how to do proofs. That's sort of like graduating an English major who can't read.)

I started thinking of this when a preacher I heard commented that whereas in the past, most people knew (or thought they did) the basics of the Judaic and Christian world view, the modern school system has inculcated ignorance of such things, and it's worked beautifully -- more people know next to nothing of this than ever before! But it occurs to me that although this was a special focus, our school system has also eliminated an understanding of how to think logically (by removing proofs). We don't get the basics of philosophy even in college (at least, I didn't, and I did take two philosophy classes).

To a sometimes partisan but less sweeping degree, parts of history have disappeared (and some have been disappeared for a long time). That can be fixed by better textbooks.

Geography also disappeared entirely from the curriculum while I was in school, which explains why we kept hearing about people who thought New Mexico was a foreign country.

What else is missing? What parts are worth fixing?

What will you do with your own children, if you have any, so they won't miss out on what our schools won't teach?

...and if you think this far, what materials will you be using?

Views: 82

Reply to This

Latest Activity

Michael D. Denny replied to John Muir's discussion Now the time for a gas tax to pay off the national debt? in the group The Great Debate
""Good enough for government work" used to be an euphamism that implied quality." No. It didn't."
10 minutes ago
John Muir replied to John Muir's discussion Now the time for a gas tax to pay off the national debt? in the group The Great Debate
"From what I've read, most of what we gave Europe (and the Soviet Union) under lend-lease we ended up giving them for 10% of actual value. The Marshall plan is a whole other thing. "
38 minutes ago
Shane replied to John Muir's discussion Now the time for a gas tax to pay off the national debt? in the group The Great Debate
"Lend lease and the US was the world's manufacturing base."
51 minutes ago
John Muir replied to David R.'s discussion Profanity and Vulgarity
"David - yep, either they were Anglo-Saxon or Germanic Non-barbaric vocabulary was in latin "
1 hour ago
Tim replied to David R.'s discussion Profanity and Vulgarity
"Cussing is unimaginative. Smart speakers and writers don't need to cuss to get their point across with the frequency they do nowadays. The English language has so many amazing words, yet too many people rely on cusswords because they don't…"
1 hour ago
Michael Martin commented on Dylan Cheesman's group Scottish Heritage
"Hello guys. I have a lot of Scottish heritage. My paternal Grandfather is almost 100% with a very small amount of English. We have traced his ancestry back to about the 1200's.  "
1 hour ago
Tyler M. replied to Joshua's discussion Favorite Truck?
"You can always change that. I'm 6'1 and still have to hop up into my baby. "
2 hours ago
Chuck Knight replied to Justin's discussion Tips on waking up earlier?
"My FitBit allows me to track sleep quality. Over the last week I've been adjusting my hang, ever so slightly, to find the perfect setting. This imgur album showcases my results. Friday was an anomaly, and even so, still represented a decent…"
2 hours ago

© 2016   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service