As Professor Kirk in the first Narnia book said -- appalled that these young children weren't thinking logically enough -- "I wonder what they do teach them in these schools."

We were just talking on another thread about rhetoric -- something they didn't teach me back when and aren't teaching now. I'd like to see it: sound thinking, reasoned analysis of argument.

They *were* teaching geometry when I was in school, that is, Euclidean proofs. In my home state, at least, they've stopped doing that. Geometry is now descriptive -- "that's a square; that's a circle" -- and proofs are gone. (Possibly as a result of this trend, a math prof at a local college admitted to me he thinks some of his majors graduate without understanding how to do proofs. That's sort of like graduating an English major who can't read.)

I started thinking of this when a preacher I heard commented that whereas in the past, most people knew (or thought they did) the basics of the Judaic and Christian world view, the modern school system has inculcated ignorance of such things, and it's worked beautifully -- more people know next to nothing of this than ever before! But it occurs to me that although this was a special focus, our school system has also eliminated an understanding of how to think logically (by removing proofs). We don't get the basics of philosophy even in college (at least, I didn't, and I did take two philosophy classes).

To a sometimes partisan but less sweeping degree, parts of history have disappeared (and some have been disappeared for a long time). That can be fixed by better textbooks.

Geography also disappeared entirely from the curriculum while I was in school, which explains why we kept hearing about people who thought New Mexico was a foreign country.

What else is missing? What parts are worth fixing?

What will you do with your own children, if you have any, so they won't miss out on what our schools won't teach?

...and if you think this far, what materials will you be using?

Views: 92

Reply to This

Latest Activity

Shane replied to Sir's discussion What college freshmen should know
"It wasn't over classified. I don't even think it was classified. It was just part of a larger curriculum."
35 minutes ago
John Muir replied to Sir's discussion What college freshmen should know
"I think teaching kids hygiene and swimming is very important."
1 hour ago
Native Son replied to Sir's discussion What college freshmen should know
"Sounds like some of your training was overclassified.  A number of intelligence analysis text books are available open source (Amazon), including The Thinker's Tool Kit. "Bias Identification" is a convenient buzzword…"
1 hour ago
David Egerdahl replied to David Salley's discussion Tucking in with shorts
"If you are at an event that requires you to tuck in your shirt you should also wear pants (other than golfing) and, for the love of god, no sandals.    "
2 hours ago
Shane replied to Sir's discussion What college freshmen should know
"Organized PE is. The primary educational landscape is bizarre these days."
2 hours ago
Sir replied to Sir's discussion What college freshmen should know
"Non sequitur?"
6 hours ago
Shane replied to Sir's discussion What college freshmen should know
"You want to bully kids now?"
8 hours ago
Priscus replied to Sir's discussion What college freshmen should know
"Not for college level, but a friend of mine suggested that one of the major focuses of elementary aged education should be how to take care of your physical health, and the importance of doing so, not only in a health class setting, but actually…"
8 hours ago

© 2016   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service