As Professor Kirk in the first Narnia book said -- appalled that these young children weren't thinking logically enough -- "I wonder what they do teach them in these schools."

We were just talking on another thread about rhetoric -- something they didn't teach me back when and aren't teaching now. I'd like to see it: sound thinking, reasoned analysis of argument.

They *were* teaching geometry when I was in school, that is, Euclidean proofs. In my home state, at least, they've stopped doing that. Geometry is now descriptive -- "that's a square; that's a circle" -- and proofs are gone. (Possibly as a result of this trend, a math prof at a local college admitted to me he thinks some of his majors graduate without understanding how to do proofs. That's sort of like graduating an English major who can't read.)

I started thinking of this when a preacher I heard commented that whereas in the past, most people knew (or thought they did) the basics of the Judaic and Christian world view, the modern school system has inculcated ignorance of such things, and it's worked beautifully -- more people know next to nothing of this than ever before! But it occurs to me that although this was a special focus, our school system has also eliminated an understanding of how to think logically (by removing proofs). We don't get the basics of philosophy even in college (at least, I didn't, and I did take two philosophy classes).

To a sometimes partisan but less sweeping degree, parts of history have disappeared (and some have been disappeared for a long time). That can be fixed by better textbooks.

Geography also disappeared entirely from the curriculum while I was in school, which explains why we kept hearing about people who thought New Mexico was a foreign country.

What else is missing? What parts are worth fixing?

What will you do with your own children, if you have any, so they won't miss out on what our schools won't teach?

...and if you think this far, what materials will you be using?

Views: 80

Reply to This

Latest Activity

Nick the Clever replied to Nick the Clever's discussion What Did You Major in, and Why?
"Sounds like you were stuck between a rock and a hard place and made a tough decision to get out of it! I wish you the best of luck in getting your masters degree, and thanks for sharing! It's surprising to see how many individuals on here have…"
28 minutes ago
Nick the Clever replied to Nick the Clever's discussion What Did You Major in, and Why?
"How do you like teaching in South Korea? Did you have a bit of culture shock initially?!"
29 minutes ago
Michael J. K. added a discussion to the group Philology: A Group for Verbivores
Thumbnail

walking though clouds a poem

Walking Through Clouds . we walk but we do not seeit takes a while to focusthe clouds get in the way.some say they do not seethe clouds in the way butthey are there anyway.I see the clouds clearlybut others never see themthey are looking at their feet.Sometimes the clouds liftand I can see for days butthen the clouds come back.I walk among the cloudsI also see through themwalking careful with open eyes.Some people choose what theywant to see while on Earth, andsome never see well at all.. I…See More
1 hour ago
Todd Serveto replied to Pale Horse's discussion Hillary Clinton in the group The Great Debate
"Kenneth Armstrong said:  And, the pity is, even with the whole litany of felonies laid out for you in basic terms, you still just don't (or won't) "get it" and have that light bulb moment of clarity. That's what people…"
1 hour ago
Madhukar Perumandla updated their profile
1 hour ago
Todd Serveto replied to Pale Horse's discussion Hillary Clinton in the group The Great Debate
"John...I am still looking forward to a link or some information from you.  I realize that other investigations (of one kind or another) have been carried out: TWENTY-TWO individuals (18 who were there prior to the Benghazi affair and 4 who were…"
1 hour ago
Alvaro joined Adam Jablecki's group
Thumbnail

South American Gentlemen's Society

Calling all true gentlemen associated with South American life, culture or spirit.
2 hours ago
Alvaro replied to Sean's discussion Manly singers in the group Manly Singers
2 hours ago

© 2015   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service