This has befuddled me for years, believe it or not.

As a male unsocialized with other men, I have no idea what to do when a guy asks me that (women never do, they say "hi").

In the gym I go to I still feel very uncomfortable with the jock/male/sportstalking guy crowd.

I keep my head down, get my workout done and flee. But there are occasional times when I have to lock eyes with someone, and here it comes; "How's it goin." he will say. I will bluster out a "fine, thanks" but by then I'm usually talking to his back or simply airspace.

Today a guy (some ex military manly man) I'd been avoiding finally bumped into me; "How's it goin." he says. "Hello" I reply, treating it as the greeting it seems to be.

"I ASKED YOU HOW YOU ARE DOING" he replies loudly, a hint of annoyance in his voice. "Fine, thank you." I chirp embarrassedly.

So now I'm really confused; is he being a jerk, or am I? It's come to where I don't want to make any eye contact with anyone there as I haven't the foggiest idea what to say. I don't know who to ask for guidance on this, because it seems to be in the same category of asking how football is played; I should know already. 

I don't.

Views: 2179

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

You are over thinking it. It is just a filler for people who have to be talking, who think they owe you something because you happen to be sharing the same space or made eye contact. Just say "alright" and move on.


 

Agreed.  You're overthinking it.  It's a colloquialism which means essentially, "how are you?"  In the New York metro area, the common variant is, "how you doin'?"  For that matter, "howdy" is a contraction of "how do you do," which is the same thing.

 

It's not necessarily intended as a way to initiate a conversation, it's just a casual greeting.  99% of the time, the response will be something along the lines of, "fine," regardless of whether that's true.

Well, it just seems weird to say "fine, thanks" to someone's back.

Thanks for asking this!  I've had similar experiences.  Now I just say "fantastic" when i get that phrase, but then I wonder if im being impolite by not asking how they're doing. 

Im pretty sure most guys don't expect a response to "how ya doin?" and its just a greeting, but I look forward to reading other's responses to this.

It seems like it is used as a greeting; just seems like a clumsy way to greet someone, with verbiage meant to start a conversation.

Ok; so the man was an ass? Very confusing.

Yes, he was an ass. You hold no obligation to answer his question to you, even if he thought he was being nice and social.

Yes, he was.

"Fine" is fine.

Yes, he was an ass. He took the opportunity to be nasty to you. It was completely unnecessary.

I think a good response would be a simple "Hey. Good. You?"

You bumped into an a-hole.  Next time he asks that just say "Good but a little to the left".  leave him wondering a bit.  To anyone else a good answer would be "Good, you?".

Alternate, a simple quick small raise of your head (kind of like nodding yes but only in the up direction) while looking them in the eyes.  Acknowledges their presence and their greeting and you don't have to say anything.

That's my answer to "how's it hanging." "How's it going" gets good thanks, how are you?" or "I'm great man, how are things with you." The jerk Carl encountered may have a hearing problem, or is really simply a douche.

RSS

Latest Activity

Holden Shepard joined Herb Munson's group
Thumbnail

The Great Debate

"Iron sharpens iron." A place for men to impact each other by debate and exchange of ideas. This is a group where no ideas are off limits. If your motto is, "I never talk about politics or religion," this group is probably not for you. A "gym" for thinkers.See More
1 minute ago
Holden Shepard joined Josh Helfferich's group
Thumbnail

College Gentlemen

Young men, trying to learn the ways of becoming a true gentleman.
2 minutes ago
Holden Shepard joined Stephen Farrar's group
Thumbnail

The Armed Forces

This group is for all AoM readers who have an association with the armed forces, be it past, present, or future. If you served in a branch of the military yourself, please tell us about your experiences and what the military has meant for your life.See More
2 minutes ago
Holden Shepard joined Steven C.'s group
Thumbnail

Geeks

If you are a geek by trade or hobby, join up! You can be a geek and manly at the same time.See More
2 minutes ago
Holden Shepard joined Tookie's group
Thumbnail

Christian Men

Regardless of the specifics, we can all agree on one thing. Jesus Christ was the perfect Man who died and rose again for us such that we could have fellowship with Him
18 minutes ago
Shane replied to Jim's discussion book on body sculpting/beginner bodybuilding?
"Unleashing the Wild Physique - Vince Gironda Arnold: Education of a Bodybuilder"
25 minutes ago
Sean O' replied to Jim's discussion book on body sculpting/beginner bodybuilding?
"WTF is body sculpting?!? There are a lot of references for beginning body building. Most of the best stuff is free. You can get a lot of stuff about 5-3-1 for free over at t-nation. Stronglifts has some really good 5 x 5 routines. For some light…"
58 minutes ago
Will replied to Pale Horse's discussion Called It in the group The Great Debate
"That's the part the extremes of fashion are missing:  health.  Styles can come and go, but health isn't just a matter of opinion, but objective fact.  So I'd say anyone who's attracted to emaciation or gross…"
1 hour ago

© 2015   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service