Greetings,

A few days ago while my dad was taking my sister across the state to have her lymph nodes tested, he picked up a hunting knife for my 30th birthday.  I've never owned anything other than a pocketknife, so I don't know enough about hunting knives to tell if this is a good one.  I've tried finding product reviews on the Web, but only turned up a pic of the same knife from several online retailers with a wide range of prices from $6.00 to $25.00:

The label on the box says KA-475 but gives no information about who manufactured it.  The knife is 10-3/4 inches long with a 6-1/2 inch blade.  It's made in Pakistan, and the blade is stamped with "Hand Made - 440 Stainless Steel."  Has anyone on AoM seen/used this knife before?  What can I expect from it in terms of quality?

Views: 1231

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

440 steel, if it really is, is actually pretty decent steel - so it might hold an edge well once properly sharpened. 

However, it looks like it's been Chromed, which is not good (could be just a trick of the photography). I would also guess, at that price, that it is imitation stag and brass fittings - serviceable, but certainly not something you are going to save for your grandkids. I see one website that claims this knife is made by Ka-bar (Ka-bar makes some very good knives for the marines and others) - as far as I can tell, it is not. 

I've personally never been fond of the Bowie pattern as a hunting/utility knife. Thick blade and off balance pattern limits its usefulness for most tasks required of a knife. If you are looking for a serious working knife (heavy duty camping/hunting) I'd probably not bother with this one unfortunately. 

Thanks for your input.  Since I already have the knife, I do plan to test it while practicing some of the survival skills I'm learning in Les Stroud's book (I'm a big fan of Survivorman).  And I may try to obtain another knife for comparison, with the help of someone who knows what to look for in a quality knife.

I agree with everything Liam said. Just adding a couple other bits. 440 is the standard stainless used in many knives because of its resistance to corrosion. Unlike its high carbon counterpart, you're not likely to get any rust or pitting on the blade. However, This steel doesn't get as sharp as a high carbon blade will. I like carrying two knives because of this (one stainless the other high carbon) so I have one for any situation that may come up. I hope this helped and happy trails.

p.s. A good site to pick up a lot of primitive living and survival info is http://www.bladeforums.com/

It is a Paki a general term for a costume piece that can't really do the job.  My wife forgot she had a paki on her when she was going through the airport a may years ago and security looked at it and realizing what is was and the butter knifes keep a better edge let her keep it.

They are show pieces, cheap show pieces at that.

Use the knife in your kitchen.  If it works, holds an edge and doesn't dull with the first cut then it is a usable knife.  If you can't cut bacon or raw steak with it then it is a Pakistan show piece.  FWIW, a knife of this size that can be depended on would cost at least $75 to $100.

One of the best cheap knives that is out there is the "Old Hickory" line of butcher knives.  The steel is carbon, it does rust, but it holds an edge and cuts beautifully.

Buck76

RSS

Latest Activity

Connor James Frontera left a comment for Mongoose
"Thank you. This photograph is part of my series on manliness. I was definitely inspired by this website and try to incorporate this kind of stuff into my photography in general. Im glad it invokes some feeling. "
18 minutes ago
Mongoose left a comment for Connor James Frontera
"Very interesting photograph. It seems that you wished to convey meaning, and it does convey meaning to me. It sort of asks/answers "What is it to be a man?""
24 minutes ago
Mongoose replied to Daniel's discussion The Best Day of Your Life
"Incidentally, it drives my wife mad that I very much avoid rating/evaluating things. I don't know why, but I just relish being or savoring things. To rate the bite of food, the work of art, the outing, the anything just seems to make it more…"
26 minutes ago
Mongoose replied to Daniel's discussion The Best Day of Your Life
"I've always had difficulty with such questions, as I really dislike rating/categorizing such. I somehow feel that doing so decreases from the value of other events. Additionally, I have a very difficult time comparing events as I feel they are…"
28 minutes ago
Craig replied to Daniel's discussion The Best Day of Your Life
"I'm sure it feels like it now for you. Probably did for me too 10 days after. Time creates perspective."
2 hours ago
Craig replied to Daniel's discussion The Best Day of Your Life
"I pretty much agree with all of this. Another thing to add is that some of my best days didn't seem like it at the time but now I think back and wish I could relive every moment. I recall one late summer/early fall day. I think I actually…"
2 hours ago
Mongoose replied to Mongoose's discussion Muscle-Enhancing Shirt in the group Exercise
"I think I may have to agree. I have one shirt which does have tightness around my bicep (short sleeved) which looks fair, and I do find myself wanting to wear it more often."
4 hours ago
Wild Man replied to Mongoose's discussion Muscle-Enhancing Shirt in the group Exercise
"I actually like the round next myself, but what I think is more important is how the shirt fits on the arms. A tighter shirt around the shoulders and arms is what I look for and it is more important in accenting the upper body"
4 hours ago

© 2016   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service