Currently i live at home (i know i know) be cause of my mom and dads genrousity i do chores around the house like laundery. One of the chores im asked to do is wash dishes and clean the kitchen and i have no problem with this. My issue is that my family uses the fact that its my job to clean it to trash the kitchen to frat house levels every day as well as use dishes wastefully. when i bring up the issue im told im being ungrateful. i want to know is it ok to refuse to clean the kitchen.

Tags: fammily, kitchen, trash

Views: 585

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

No

If you do not pay rent then the answer is no, even if you are attending college, other school, or even working. If you are paying rent then I would set up an agreement with your parents as to how the maintenance of the house is to be divided among those paying rent and those not (you may have primary or secondary school age siblings) paying rent.

The problem is, you've taken on that task as condition of your residency.  It is now your responsibility until you leave.  If reasoning doesn't work, figure out a way to take a three day weekend away from home, so they can see the unnecessary work they put you through.  Other than that, carry on.

It is probably not OK to refuse to clean the kitchen. In exchange for a very valuable benefit, you're asked to do chores. Do the chores or pay for your own place.
Though, in my family, it's not like this. Members aren't valued based solely on what salable or cash contribution they make to the household. Everyone helps out proportionate to their ability, whether they bring in income or not - though bringing in income may mean a member has less time to help with chores.
But I'm not sure my family's attitude is healthier or better than yours. It has perhaps delayed independence, both financially and more broadly, for my little sister.
I think my family also wouldn't treat even a paid, non-family member this way - wouldn't make a task more difficult for someone else out of spite, or a sense of superiority, or "that's their job." My husband, however, used to never clear his tray at a fast food place; my family of origin always did. I married him anyway, and now he does. So, again, I don't know the moral value of making life easy for service people.

In my mind, it comes from a very anti-SF philosophy - that people are valuable beyond the monetary benefit they bring to me or to the family.

As a practical matter, it also has to do with coming from a family that had at least one young child for so long. You help out because that's what you DO in a family, no matter that your big sister can do it better or faster, or that the family managed fine before it had its youngest helper.

it seems that to me that there takeing advantage of my belife in helping as a excuse to make a gaint mess every day and then get mad that it takes for ever to clean it. i feel it has to do with a lack of respect for me from my family. i need to know if i deserve to assert my self as deserving of respect or if my liveing their rent free waves that right?

Think about it as your family seems to: If you were a paid housekeeper for non-family-members, and used your income to pay rent, and you felt your employers were being ridiculously messy, would you ask for more respect, or would you take your lumps?

Your situation just skips the middle step.

You want to live in their house ... then tell them how to use their own kitchen?  And, if they don't use their kitchen to your liking, you'll flatly refuse to do your part?

 

No.  You agreed to do the work.  Do the work.  If you don't like it, pay for your own kitchen and leave them to clean theirs.

 

JB

perhaps a exsample will help. my mom and sister will throw their pop cans in the sink rather than throwing them away. when i tell them pop cans go in the trash i set blank stares and dumb excuses. i think a normal person would say pop cans go in the trash espeicaly when asked.

Maybe.  But, a normal adult person also pays rent.

 

Your example doesn't change my answer.  Do your job, as agreed, or get your own place.  If you're looking for permission to shirk your responsibilities, so far you're not finding it here.


JB

Actually, in my house, they go in the sink, where they are rinsed with hot water, then a separate recycling bin.

It's somewhat unusual for a child of a family to have different standards of cleanliness and respect than the rest of the family, but everyone has their small bad habits and pet peeves.

Regardless of who's "right" in this situation, you have asked nicely for help, they've refused. Your options are to ask if you can stop doing chores and pay rent instead, or get your own place.

And a note on being "right" in adult family relationships: I've been married less a month, and I already know that being happy in your home life has very little to do with being "right."

A husband can be right or he can be happy but not both.

Do new brides get something in the mail or is it passed down by word of mouth?

RSS

Latest Activity

Penelope replied to Vince's discussion college:problem with procrastination
"Secretaries don't tell you to review discovery from X case before drafting the brief in Y case before conducting research in Z case.  Unfortunately, it's this kind of work - all independent and in the office, nose-in-the-books, so to…"
2 minutes ago
Jack Bauer replied to Vince's discussion college:problem with procrastination
"Who's going to schedule the interviews? JB"
25 minutes ago
Regular Joe replied to Vince's discussion college:problem with procrastination
"Except for the fact that so many lawyers depend on their admin assistants to manage their schedules for them. ;) "
26 minutes ago
Jack Bauer replied to Nick's discussion Th lonely life of full-time pastors
"First, you need a pastor of your own.  Just because you're feeding others doesn't mean you don't need to be fed.  You need an advisor, a counselor, someone you can go to the same way your parishioners come to you. Second,…"
37 minutes ago
Jack Bauer replied to Vince's discussion college:problem with procrastination
"Yep.  I've been wondering why a grown man in law school needs an anonymous woman on a message board to write his schedule for him.  Doesn't inspire a lot of confidence in his ability to practice law. JB"
45 minutes ago
Karl Helweg replied to Nick's discussion Th lonely life of full-time pastors
"http://www.gocivilairpatrol.com/  is happy to find clergy and would add a new social circle for you.  When our last pastor left I was surprised to find that they considered my wife and I their best friends here.  I do not feel like…"
55 minutes ago
Penelope replied to Vince's discussion college:problem with procrastination
"To be fair, the kid's posting has steeply tapered off. I'm a bit worried about the Italian justice system if its future lawyers can't figure out their own study schedules less than a year away from being licensed, but I understand…"
1 hour ago
Penelope replied to Nick's discussion Th lonely life of full-time pastors
"Denominations try to address these issues by requiring all the pastors in a region to meet periodically.  There's no concerns about sheep-stealing, because these aren't pastors in the same town.  There's fewer scheduling…"
1 hour ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service