'Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent.'  - Ludwig Wittgenstein

"Silence is golden when you can't think of a good answer." - Muhammad Ali

I wanted to start of this post with these quotes, though i am not a real Muhammad Ali fan, the quote is what i find intriguing. And for this post the quote of Wittgenstein isn't used specificly in his philosophical analysis. Though the my idea and question to you are based on my first interpetations of these.

Last year i have had a lot of stuggles with myself. For one in larger groups i am a very silent person. And mostly when i speak i do not use many words. The words i use are mostly well thought through. And opinions i create are mostly based off an analytic point of view.  

Though some people or teachers, like to give you an unexpected turn to speak. And to give your opinion in front of the group. And offcourse this is a part of growing up and you gotta be able to let your thoughts out in a group. But sometimes i just can't think of the right answer, and that results in a silence. Or well atleast in me not giving an answer to a question. Which frustrates the rest of the class or the teacher. 

It's not that i am scared of trying.. or giving a wrong answer. In some questions there aren't even right or wrong answers. But sometimes i just find myself without a possible answer and the other time i am spot on then the answer is almost, or atleast feels almost as the ultimate answer anyone could give.

And offcourse i've learned to form opinions quicker and sometimes that i need to do a little more work than others to form it. Or to why that particular part intrigues me. 

Actually i'm just interested if anyone recognizes this.. and i'm interested how they actually delt with it? Atleast i find it quite intereseting.. when is the time to speak or to be silent?

Views: 427

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I like to talk, but I would rather stay silent until I have something significant to add to a conversation. Everybody's thought process and personality are different.

...

like.

I've always tried to follow a quote I read somewhere (sorry I don't remembr who said it):

"A wise man speaks because he feels has has something to say.
A fool speaks because he feels he has to say something."

"Keep your mouth shut and your eyes open."

 

Silence is often a good thing. On the other hand, there is hardly any conversation in which common sense can't make a good conversationist. If you feel you do not have enough information, you should ask specifically if someone can update you. This shows your interest in the subject, and a willingness to change your ignorance. Ignorance is nothing to be ashamed of, unwillingness to change it is. 

As for answers in class, I think I can safely assume you're not talking about facts, but opinions and points of view. In that it's always easy to give your answer with two different points of view. This does not require you to make a statement, but allows you to mostly sum up what has already been said. This shows that you were paying attention, know what you're talking about, but haven't made a choice per se. To shift this to something looking like an answer, just emphasize one view a bit more, by using slightly stronger words. 

Your still not making a statement, even though it looks you are. 

It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool,
than to speak and be proven one.
I find that using less words makes each one more powerful. People who are constantly running their mouths are rarely a pleasure to listen to.

RSS

Latest Activity

Joseph Dean Phillips replied to Joseph Dean Phillips's discussion New Poems
"Here is a poem that I found a little while ago, very fitting for Father's day. It was written by someone that I know quite well. The Working FatherBy Bjorn Faknam He wakes afresh each new morn,With body clean and hair short shorn.Then goes to…"
25 minutes ago
Joseph Dean Phillips posted a discussion

New Poems

A Poem by some one that I knowTake nothing lightlyBy Bjorn FaknamTake nothing lightly. No vain promise give. Hold your honor tightly, In the one life we live.Do not throw trust away, Whether in you or from you. Live up to it today, In everything you do.Look with respect. Follow honor to the letter. Use the courtesy you expect. Nay, treat them better.No matter what gifts you were given, You are never above yourself. By whatever cause you are driven, Put yourself on the back shelf.Those around…See More
26 minutes ago
Joseph Dean Phillips commented on Anas Kababo's group The Poetry Club
"Here is a poem that I found a little while ago, very fitting for Father's day. It was written by someone that I know quite well. The Working FatherBy Bjorn Faknam He wakes afresh each new morn,With body clean and hair short shorn.Then goes to…"
31 minutes ago
Joseph Dean Phillips joined Anas Kababo's group
Thumbnail

The Poetry Club

The Poetry Club is a group for those who love poetry, anyone who is just curious, and everyone in between.See More
32 minutes ago
Joseph Dean Phillips replied to Christian's discussion Favorite Manly Poems
"A poem for Father's Day, by someone I know, admittedly a little late: The Working FatherBy Bjorn Faknam He wakes afresh each new morn,With body clean and hair short shorn.Then goes to work, with mind and arm,And works all day, though it holds…"
35 minutes ago
Liam replied to Liam's discussion Moving towards my first muscle up
"Thanks for the advice Sam. It is interesting that you didn't find the negatives very helpful. The elastic idea is really interesting. I have managed my first reps but what I found was I am taking one arm over the bar before the other, either my…"
36 minutes ago
Liam replied to Liam's discussion Moving towards my first muscle up
"Yes I agree, unfortunately I don't have anything to record myself with. I managed my first poor quality reps the other day which I am thrilled about but my maximum reps of pull ups has fallen significantly in the process (from 12 - 15 down to…"
39 minutes ago
Liam S. replied to Chris Hamm's discussion Who Wears a Watch Anymore?
"Well "stylish" can mean many things. Personally, for around $100, I would look at the Seiko 5 series. These are very solid automatic movements (no batteries, but no winding either - if you wear them). They are built well, and there is a…"
44 minutes ago

© 2013   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service