So, I'm posting this on behalf of a friend who is having trouble with his 13 year old daughter. Like alot of kids her age( I know I was included here once too) she just doesn't give a hoot about school or the importance of her grades to her future. He's tried talking to her a bit but i get the sense he's run out of things to say. I don't know if anyone's gone through/going through this with your kids or if you remember how your parents got through to you but any pointer would really help and be much appreciated. Thanks guys

Views: 335

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Btw, thank you all for the advice and personal stories...I'm gonna sum them up and pass it on to my friend, so thanks for all the great replies:)

Thinking about this later it occurs to me that as you say that the problem may be that she has fallen behind and her attitude is a defense mechanism.

I always hesitate to give advice as I have to say we seemed to get a lot wrong in the parenthood business but it is vital to keep the lines of communication open.

It is vital that there is trust between parent and child, my wife was always better at it than me but we always sat and ate together after the day and they were encouraged to discuss everything at the table between themselves and with us and we often swallowed our tongues at some of the stuff that came out. We used to say to each other that it was better we knew what was going on even if we did not like it.

I think that we don't really teach they why we are teaching what we teach as well as we could.  Part of it is so you know how to do x or rather you will be able to relearn it faster when and if you need it and second it teaches you how to learn and gets you used to learning.  Learning take actions, actions take practice.  Also the why do I need to know this is a hard answer when the real answer is that you will be combining bits of everything you learn to do your job when we break it out into subjects.

You didn't post what income level the family has.  We've taken our children through neighborhoods with low income families and showed them the difference between what we have and what they will have if they don't do well in school.  That's not to say that college is right for everyone but we let them know that they are expected to do well.  I wouldn't be too sad for my step-son, who is unsure about college, if he took up a trade that would allow him to support his family (when he has one) at a decent level.  We've also let our kids know that we're not their fall back position if they don't give a good try.  We're of the sort who would rather teach a man to fish rather than give the man a fish.

Beyond spelling out the economic facts and forcing a clear cause and effect on grades vs freedom / access to fun.  I don't know what can be said.  The problem is the message leaders they have are not talking about hard work = success nor about creating opportunities for success.

Some of what I have done is to take one of my sons to the fields where people were working picking lettuce, we parked there and I made him watch them work for a while. 

I told him that if he wants to be uneducated he will wind up working stoop labor jobs that do not require an education, but they need fast hands and a strong back. 

After this I took him to the farm owners house and asked if he would allow my son to work there free of charge so he may know what it is to have to live like this, the farmer said he would be willing.  His grades came up shortly after.

Interesting.  Could backfire.

RSS

Latest Activity

Will replied to Mike F's discussion Young guys in the group New Warriors
"That man definitely does not speak for the greater MKP community, which welcomes young men (and sometimes has discussions about how to recruit more of them).  He may have spoken for his own "I-group" (a small group of 8-12 or so…"
2 hours ago
Michael B. replied to Titus Techera's discussion Healthcare ideas in the group The Great Debate
"Insurance is a small portion of the problem as a whole - a portion of which was actually formed by market forces. Insurance, in and of itself, has one purpose; to create access to healthcare. Full stop. In this, a successful ACA rollout only does…"
2 hours ago
Jai Chipperfield replied to Jai Chipperfield's discussion What to wear to a vineyard
"The vineyard is putting on the event to show its new products to re"
2 hours ago
Michael B. replied to Shane's discussion Government Services in the group The Great Debate
"I'm actually rather interested in reading - what I would see - as the anti-Randian Jennifer Government that the web-game Nationstates is based off of. Slippery slope dystopias are always a fun read."
3 hours ago
Mike F added a discussion to the group New Warriors
Thumbnail

Young guys

hey guys, I have been interested in the MKP for a few years now and even began pursuing my dream of attending a weekend. After many emails back and forth as well as a few phone calls with an influential guy there (who was very nice) I was politely told that the weekend is more for older guys and while there are annual meetings in my area, in which guys get together at a local church and further share and bond, because of the nature of these meetings (they discuss feelings and their deepest…See More
3 hours ago
Michael B. replied to Brett McKay's discussion How Do You Want to Go Out?
"I have instructed my wife that my body is to be donated to a local science program, so that I may forever be fondled by young coeds. Okay, cut the fondling part. My body is to be donated to a school for up and coming students, though."
3 hours ago
Mike F joined Will's group
Thumbnail

New Warriors

For discussing intense experiential work, owning the shadow, or any of the other things the ManKind Project is all about.
3 hours ago
Mike F updated their profile
3 hours ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service