Hello gentlemen,

I am in the market for new shoes after the sole in my old shoe ripped apart. Frankly I do not want to have this same situation 3-5 years down the line, so I want to invest in a quality product. I don't mind spending $200 dollars as long as the shoe last a decade or two. That being said, what are some shoemakers you men would recommend to me? I am size 9.5 and flat-footed.

I am looking for a shoe with these characteristics:

- Can take a beating ( I usually walk 3-4 miles everyday so this is the most important)

- Comfortable

- Can be worn in a formal and casual environment 

Views: 273

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Isn't that expecting a bit much? even at 3 miles a day, you'd walk over 1,000 miles a year, expecting shoes to last 10 years without resoling or rest, you'd be demanding 10,000 miles out of them! :)

The British shoe makers "Loake" offer a resoling service, I'm sure that a few entry level/high end American makers also offer this service as well...but I doubt that any maker can claim 10,000 miles worth of use on a single sole.

 

You'd probably get 10 or 20 years if you were rotating through several pairs of shoes, but I personally don't see any single pair lasting that long...interested to see if any other responders to this post have shoes or boots that have taken such a pounding and still look good though!

I see. I'm pretty new to this whole thing, so the more info I attain from you gentlemen, the better. I know no shoe will last THAT long, but the point is I don't mind spending money to buy and resole it once it's worn out. I currently have two shoes in rotation now, and need a new pair of black shoes. 

Buy an insole for your foot.  Put them in the shoes you are inspecting and see how they work with that insole.  It made shopping a lot easier on me when I did it that way.

If you get leather soled shoes have a cobbler put Vibram soles over them and the heal of the shoe after you break them in.  The Vibram sole will help them last so that you only have to have the heal touched up every so often.

You will need to have shoe trees to reset your shoes between wearings and need to give them 24-48 hours rest.  IE wear no more often then every other day.  Also keep them in good polish to deal with the weather.  Every 2 weeks or so you should polish them.  Some say every 6 wears, really you need to just pay attention to them and feed them when needed.

Good shoes take maintenance to make them last.  But they also age well and it feels good pulling out things you actually cared for and about when getting dressed.

Thank you, I did not know this info!

A pair of shoes you wear daily will need to be resoled in roughly 3 years anyway.  Depends on what you want to spend.  And if you're on your feet all day, you may be buying "service oxfords" from Redwing.

Get a pair of nice Allen Edmonds. Clean and polish them regularly, keep them on ceder trees when not wearing them. AE offers resoling and full rebuilding of their good shoes (they do have some with rubber soles that can't be rebuilt, I'd avoid these). They have some with doubled up leather soles, but you are looking at close to $600 for those.  Most of their oxfords are in the $300 range.  I own one pair and plan to purchase more as time goes on. They are great shoes.

Thanks for the recommendation, I will definitely try a pair of AE's at Macy's tomorrow. Is it ok if I walk around the store in the pair of shoes for a few minutes? I normally would just walk for a minute and some shoes would become too uncomfortable to wear!

I own a auto detail and lube shop so I'm on my feet all day. I would buy cheap shoes because I get them dirty and wear them every day. Two years ago, I went to Payless and bought a pair of leather Oxford type slip on shoes for $9 on clearance. I immediately fell in love with these shoes. I bought some waterproofing stuff to oil them with and I shine them once a week. They discontinued that shoe and the name has worn off the inside. I had them re soled for $25. Yes that was more than I payed but I'm happy with them. I bought another similar pair recently for $45 to have a pair to rotate. So for around $80 I got 2 pair of decent shoes that I work in everyday and one has lasted 2 years because I take care of them. And they get wet everyday. What you spend does matter as far as quality but how you care for them matters a lot too

RSS

Latest Activity

Sir replied to floyd james's discussion What has happened to masculinity
"I remember thinking that in the 90's.  Hillary Clinton, then in the news too of course, was praised as someone who made no apologies for who she was.  I don't know why anyone would apologize for who she is ("Hi, I'm…"
19 minutes ago
Liam Strain commented on Will Maurer's group Scouts & Scouters
"The role of religion in scouting seems to vary a bit by location, and troop. As laid out in the handbook, it cannot be ignored, but it doesn't require significant personal practice - pretty much as long as you are not an atheist, you are…"
27 minutes ago
Profile IconLiam Strain, Matthew Green and Matthew Chase Heslop joined Will Maurer's group
Thumbnail

Scouts & Scouters

For Boy scouts & those involved with scouting as volunteersSee More
29 minutes ago
Liam Strain replied to floyd james's discussion What has happened to masculinity
"I don't recall GQ being a bastion of masculinity. Fashion is different - not necessarily related. There is nothing inherently masculine in refusing to apologize when you screw up. If anything, that seems a lot like not taking…"
33 minutes ago
Liam Strain commented on Nolan Poulson's group The Barbershop
36 minutes ago
Northumbrian commented on Bruce Uall's group The Shirtless Man
"I have no problem being shirtless inside during the winter"
1 hour ago
Profile IconDouglas Perry and Matthew Green joined thehuhman's group
Thumbnail

AoM PhotoGroup

Alright, all of you budding and seasoned photographers out there. Here's your official AoM Group. Let's do ourselves proud, by becoming the largest group here!See More
1 hour ago
Matthew Green commented on Will Maurer's group Scouts & Scouters
"Many years ago when I was a kid I joins the Boy Scouts. I regret not sticking with it. I was considering volunteering, maybe as a Assistant Scout Master. My only concern is that I am not a very spiritual/religious person. I know that religion is a…"
4 hours ago

© 2016   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service