I think the notion of carrying a knife for protection is rather silly, not that it cna't be used for protection however I would venture to bet 99% of people who carry a knife and think it's protection have no idea how to properly handle a knife or use a knife in a self defense situation. Alot of knives people carry for "self defense" are more slashing weapons than stabbing but I bet most people would try to stab and probably wind up cutting their own hand up more than the offender they are going after.


One toher thing I would recommen not carrying a knife out drinking. We dont always have the best judgemetn or make the best decisions and oftentimes a situatin that could just be a fistfight turns into a murder or assault with a deadly weapon and even if you are in the right if your drunk you'll probably be said to have been aggressive, not in the rigth frame of mind, etc.

Views: 972

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

yeah unless you know how to properly use a knife, carrying one for defense is rather silly. I do carry a small folding Case knife, but not for self defense. Its just good to use for cutting and opening boxes, rope etc. But if you want one for self defense get a fixed blade knife, that way it wont fold into your hand accidentally

There is an old joke in fencing: What do you call the guy that gets brought into the emergency room after a knife fight? 

The winner. 

I carry a pocket knife as a tool but it probably is not one my top ten weapons options. 

Other than fighting, I always lock my blade open before using my pocket knife, cut away from myself, don't carry it open, hand it to other people handle first, never touch the edge,  keep it sharp and polished.  Isn't that the proper way to use a pocket knife? 

*taking notes*

Jeez I feel like such a pussy. I've never seen anyone threaten anyone else with anything greater than a fist. The only time anyone has directed anything remotely resembling violence at me was a drunk guy who drunkenly tried to take off all my clothes at a wedding reception back in 1987.
Ah yes, the exploits of my non-manly youth.

There was no threat of it; he just did it.

Closest I've been to being buck naked in a very public setting.

Most of the fights I have seen people getting stabbed in, involved them going down to a colossal barrage of fists and feet, and then a knife was stuck in them while they were at their most vulnerable.

Boy Scouts taught me how to use a knife pretty safely.  Cut away from yourself.  Likewise, if using a knife for personal defense, cut away from your self.  Oh, and for the love of whatever you believe in, slice don't stab.  Stabbing will only get you hurt, or it will lose you your knife.

In my opinion, if you are looking for a self defense weapon, you should get a expandable steel baton. The chances of you hurting yourself with one is very slim, and its an amazing self defense tool. You can disable the agressor in a few hits and you will only hurt your opponent for good if you really want to.

Agreed. An expandable baton (where legally viable) is a good option. Likewise a good tactical flashlight - disorienting/blinding + striking options. Not to mention awareness and signalling - all good.

And yes, if you are using a knife and not well trained to it - slice don't stab.

They're illegal in a lot of States.

 

I know you can't carry one in Texas under any circumstances.  Here, its easier to legally carry a handgun.  Knives under 5.5" are entirely unregulated (except switchblades or throwing knives).  But, a retractable baton, blackjack or nightstick will land you in jail.

 

JB

RSS

Latest Activity

Salt Dragon replied to Stewart M. Davenport's discussion Relatively new here; thought I'd say hello
"Hi Stewart, Welcome! I'm also an Eagle Scout, involved with my son's troop and a history major from when I was in college.  Being an electrician is definitely a stronger career path.  Congrats on your marraige and pending…"
15 minutes ago
Todd McFarland joined Herb Munson's group
Thumbnail

The Great Debate

"Iron sharpens iron." A place for men to impact each other by debate and exchange of ideas. This is a group where no ideas are off limits. If your motto is, "I never talk about politics or religion," this group is probably not for you. A "gym" for thinkers.See More
4 hours ago
Todd McFarland replied to Sir's discussion Racking
"Since you only braced the bottom, I suggest you put some weight on the upper half and see if you are still satisfied with its stability before you make the other three shelves."
4 hours ago
Todd McFarland posted a discussion

Hike on Saturday

I love hiking.  I usually go alone, or with my dog.  The solitude and peace "up there" is, for me, unmatched in the world.Here's a GoPro video link if you want to follow me along. Warning: It is 20 minutes long and 3GB.https://www.dropbox.com/s/8vz5u717yr8u03e/South%20Mountain%20%282017%29.mp4?dl=0See More
5 hours ago
Todd McFarland replied to arnab banerjee's discussion lost art of indian manliness
"Interesting list of arts.  I don't agree that all of these are necessary for a man to learn, but hey, neither is Minecraft and I enjoy it in my downtime.  I look forward to your next post."
5 hours ago
Todd McFarland replied to Stewart M. Davenport's discussion Relatively new here; thought I'd say hello
"Welcome, Stewart!"
5 hours ago
Kevin Morris replied to Josh's discussion Armpits shaving or not?
"Mine are completely natural. Don't trim or shave.  I have moderate hair on my chest, stomach, arms, legs, butt and manhood.  My personal rule is no razor below the neck.  Being hairy is one of the traits of masculinity and should…"
5 hours ago
Stewart M. Davenport posted a discussion

Relatively new here; thought I'd say hello

Hello men,I'm not new to Art of Manliness, but I am new to the community. I thought I'd take the time to introduce myself. I'm almost 30, married for just over a year, and we have our first child on the way. I'm Mormon. I worked for five years sewing men's clothing, which is perfectly fine as a manly career in my opinion, but it was a dead-end job ultimately, so I quit and became an electrician. I'm still in my first year as an apprentice, but I'm very happy doing it. Before that, I was…See More
5 hours ago

© 2017   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service