I read the book club selection, "What are Men Good for?" and it was one of the most interesting reads I've ever had. Here is a video blog from a woman who came to the same conclusions: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vp8tToFv-bA

Views: 264

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Interesting video. Thanks for sharing. I like what she said about chivalry and feminism being built on the same principle, but in feminism, manhood is not honored and women treat man like crap.

I'm the oldschool chivalrous type she mentioned. I share Teddy Roosevelt's belief that generally the woman should be the main caregiver, and the man should be bringing home the bacon. I'm also against women in our military. The three P's mentioned on the site a while back are spot-on. This belief is derived from my upbringing and my religion. The Lord says that woman should submit to the man and not nag at him. But, He also says that while man should be the leader of the household, he must still honor the woman and respect her. He says that a good wife is a great treasure, but He also says that it is better to live on a rooftop than with a nagging woman. There is a balance: The wife is to follow the husband and try to please him, but the husband must honor his wife and try to please her.

Said all that and forgot to explain why I disagree.
I think that men are not disposable, but rather indespensable. Look at the inner city environments with rampant crime. You will find the vast majority of the male inmates had absentee fathers. Girls need their dad, too. I have two cousins (sisters) who had daddy issues growing up; one is a lesbian, and the other is whoring around with all kind of men. Many women who have trouble with men in some form often had trouble with male figures during childhood.
Societal masculinity is a social construct, yes. But it more than that. It is derived from biology, and should not be cast away. Back when everyone had spears and chariots, men were more cut out for combat and provision. The "Three P's" , along with the "Three G's", is ingrained in our physiology and our minds. The Three G's are Guide, Guard, and Govern. I like this better than the Three P's because it includes the Biblical and traditional role of man, as the head of his household. This does not mean that the Three P's are incorrect, but too many throw man's leadership role out the window, thinking that man is only good for protection. The Three G's explain why so many fatherless children grow up to be wayward adults. They have no man governing their home, and no man to guide them on the road to adulthood. Men who have trouble finding their manhood from my experience usually obtain confidence and security in themselves once they embrace the traditional societal views of manhood.
So, yes, it is up to man to guide and work and defend, as I believe it should be. This does not make us dispensable. It makes us necessary.

Here's a variety of perspectives of a variety of highly educated and highly successful women: 

Be it resolved men are obsolete…


I listened to most of it and thought it was extremely interested and also very funny. Definitely worth a listen if you've got some time to kill. 

Yea, it's old hat. 

 I don't agree with her in that I still feel the world is not such a perfectly safe place that Men don't need to step forward and take it for the team on occasion. 

 Because I think a woman shouldn't have to. 

  I also loath the "mens' rights" movement with a seething passion. I think they're a parade of gutless coward betamales who want to blame women and society at large for their inability to compete in the marketplace of a society of free choice. They're the last kid picked for the team and think it's a societal issue that they were last. Instead of nutting up and performing, they'd rather blame everyone else.

It´s a overly intellectual bullshit discussion. Take away men and society breaks down. Nobody who builds streets, houses, bridges, nobody who keeps water plants running. Yes, yes, women could do that too, but they dont. As long as they arent ready to get dirty they shouldnt talk smack.

Not to mention, who will take out the garbage and kill spiders?

Well to be fair, I know plenty of men who can't handle garbage or spiders. For that matter, I know a fair amount that could never do any of the things Jay D mentions, either. 

 Just mention a snake and the buttholes of half the guys on this board will slam shut so hard it bites a hole in their chairs. 


Latest Activity

Darren Holte replied to Portnoy's discussion Integrity
"Just a few thoughts. Why lie at all ? Your deadlines are not your suppliers concern. Every good plan has cushion and contingency.  I.e. your project deadline is july 31st. You need ten thousand widgets in your warehouse by july 15th in order…"
1 hour ago
Native Son replied to Portnoy's discussion Latest in Health Care in the group The Great Debate
"One thing I noticed about the entire debacle. In March, 2016, then Mr. Trump released a seven point healthcare plan outline that he wanted Congress to adopt. As far as I can tell, the only parts of his proposals that showed up in either the House or…"
3 hours ago
Native Son replied to Specs's discussion I need some work advice.
"Cool your jets.  This hill ain't worth dying on.  Let it slide, but make damn sure your emails actually get sent.  (I had a similar 'went to draft' email situation when I went to Windows 10.  A number, but not all,…"
4 hours ago
Native Son replied to Danny's discussion Militaria
"Just don't let the hobby take over and run your life to the exclusion of all else.  You do want to have provenance on stuff.  There's lots of reproduction stuff around, especially since "military recreating" became a…"
4 hours ago
Jay D replied to Portnoy's discussion Integrity
"Were i want to get at is less the lying part and more the part were we put other people under pressure. From the business perspective it makes perfect sense to put people under pressure so they make deadlines so your projects or your company…"
12 hours ago
Profile IconCaberry, Eder Prado, Moses Vandenberg and 9 more joined Art of Manliness
12 hours ago
Pale Horse replied to Native Son's discussion Political and Personal Advice from Rome. in the group The Great Debate
13 hours ago
Michael Hoogkamer updated their profile
13 hours ago

© 2017   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service