Wax, Clay, Pomade, Putty, Paste, Gum - has anyone else built a collection of hair styling products in the little round containers? Whenever a new product hits the shelf, I have to try it.


I have really thick hair, so I usually need a product with very strong hold. Some of my must have products are:


American Crew - Defining Paste

Alberto - Texturising Gum

Bedhead - Matte Separation

Redken For Men - Working Wax Manuever


Since I have tried every product under the sun, I have noticed that many cheap products are just as good as the really expensive ones. In fact, one product I loved - was actually made by Gillette and was called Precision Putty. Gillette's hair products didn't take off, so it was discontinued, but it was a fanastic product.


Currently I am trying Old Spice's new hair styling product line - so I will let you know what I think.


So is anyone else a little obsessed with hair styling products?

Views: 943

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I've tried putties, waxes, creams, sticks, glues (etc.) but cheap gel is always my preference. Used sparingly, it does the job without making me look like a greaser.

Cool if that is what you like best. For me, I prefer a matte look and I find gel gives more of a slick shine look.

I am curious - what made the cheap gel better than the expensive ones?

The hold. I have thick hair. I've got a Wooster-ish haircut so the top is longer. Most products don't have the hold I want for my hair. For whatever reason, cheap gels are usually thicker or more dense and work best.

Runny gels don't hold at all or not long enough, waxes and putties and sticks usually leave clumps and I don't like the feeling those products leave on my skin, creams are usually just as ineffective as runny gels. Mousse is useless like tits on a nun and it flakes.

I also do not want to spend much time on my hair so thick gels let me get the look I want within a few strokes of the comb (or my fingers) whereas everything else seems to require a lot of work and combining products. 

I totally understand - with all the products out there, everyone has a preference with what works best for their hair.

My wife loves that Ain't Nobody Got Time For That lady.

Water from my tap, and a brush.... Anything more is preening...

I don't use many, but when I do, it's either:

American crew pomade

Groom & Clean

Depending on what my intent is. I have pretty fine hair, so I just need something to give it a little shape/body - I don't need much hold. Just massage in, and comb (or hand style) as normal. 

I'm a huge fan of American Crew products, lately the Forming Cream and Fiber.  I usually go for a medium to strong (but not gel-stiff) hold and don't like anything super-shiny.  A much lower-cost alternative that I found works surprisingly well is Suave Professionals Men's Styling Paste.  It claims to be similar to AC Defining Paste, but I would not go that far.  The hold is a little less, but the price is a lot less at $4 per 1.75 oz puck.  Good luck finding it on a shelf though- I ordered a 3-pack via Amazon several months ago.

I tried Groom & Clean per AoM's article on oldschool hair products. Hands down my favorite.

I was a big fan of American Crew products until they recently discontinued the Tea Tree shampoo and replaced it with that foul smelling Daily Moisturizing shampoo. It now smells like a cross between a sickly sweet kitchen cleaner and a feminine hygiene product. I complained to the company (which appears to be based in Korea (??)) and received a response that said essentially they consider the old Tea Tree shampoo equivalent to the new Daily Moisturizing formula. Blech.

I'm still looking for a suitable replacement.

For mustache wax, I use Rock-a-Billy Rub, and for beard oil, I lean towards those with pine or forest scents.

I wear a pompadour style.

Some of my favorites are:

Suavecito Pomade- Good hold with high shine. Probably my favorite pomade out currently.

Krew Comb- I love this stuff if I am just wanting to put something in my hair for added definition and hold, not going all out with the greaser look.

Murray's Pomade- Good in a pinch and cheap as heck.



Latest Activity

Seanwm42 replied to Ian M's discussion Told "I love you" after two months, I responded with silence
"Respect. Sounds like you have a good head on your shoulders, man. Just treat her like she's somebody's daughter and you'll be all good :)"
2 hours ago
Ian M replied to Ian M's discussion Told "I love you" after two months, I responded with silence
"That's true. And that's why I won't tell her I 'feel' it until I do. I feel very strongly for her, and I'll tell her that but I won't tell her I love her until I know it for sure. "
2 hours ago
Craig replied to John Smith's discussion Creating an Online Freelance Business?
"Yeah sorry...to take a step back.  You'll need to purchase a domain and hosting. Bluehost can accomodate that AND install wordpress (i believe). You'd need to look into that or call them. Wordpress gets installed and basically acts as…"
2 hours ago
Vendetta replied to Jim's discussion So what games are you playing? in the group Video Gaming
"I am a PS4 guy. I am currently playing Battlefield 1. Its amazing so far. I wish I could play more. I can only get in about a half hour or hour before bed.  "
2 hours ago
Seanwm42 replied to Ian M's discussion Told "I love you" after two months, I responded with silence
"I don't think it's something you can "pro and con" though, bro. That's like for buying houses and cars. I think its supposed to feel....like...right. Have you ever said it to any girl before? "
2 hours ago
Vendetta joined Jim's group

Video Gaming

Video Gamers is a group for men who actually like to play video games and discuss all things related to video gaming. See More
2 hours ago
Vendetta replied to Ian M's discussion Told "I love you" after two months, I responded with silence
"If you don't feel it, don't say it.If you feel it, but don't say it and you aren't saying it for the soul reason of passage of time, I think you are robbing yourself. Every couple is unique. Some couples don't say it for…"
3 hours ago
John Smith replied to John Smith's discussion Creating an Online Freelance Business?
"Craig, you're a gold mine. Thank you for this. So that I'm clear, Wordpress is basically the "engine" powering a domain name of my choosing (www.testsite.com)? But then I need a place like Blue Host to "host" the…"
3 hours ago

© 2016   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service