This was inspired by something I read in Oprah magazine, but whatever.

If your wife passed away, would you remarry? Have you ever talked about this topic with your spouse?

For some, I know, it's an awful, morbid thought. On the other hand, one set of my grandparents discussed the issue openly. Grandpa's sentiment now that it's a possibility for him is different from what it was before Grandma passed away, for whatever that's worth.

And, of course, any wives out there can answer re: husbands.

Views: 3936

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

If I was in love with the person, and wanted to share my life with them. Probably (but not immediately, one needs time to grieve and learn to be alone before moving into that kind of relationship again). Based on how I feel now anyway, but I reserve the right to change my mind.

Much would depend on my age, my son, and of course, the woman.

I have not discussed this with my wife. But I expect she would answer similarly (and cannot conceive of a reason that marriage would be expressly taboo after one of our deaths).
Why wouldn't you? To me, not allowing yourself to be happy due to some sense of obligation to a dead spouse seems illogical and unhealthy.

My grandfather remarried after his wife's passing and lived with my step-grandmother (whose first husband has also passed) for many decades in one of the most beautiful examples of marriage that I have ever seen. For either of them to have forfeited all those years of love and happiness is inconceivable to me.

Sorrowful things happen but life goes on. Asking your spouse to, or preventing yourself from, experiencing joy and happiness in what remains of their own life seems downright selfish if not cruel. Marriage should be about wanting whats best for your partner as well as yourself, even after death. Plus, what would you care if you are dead anyway?

If I were to die today I hope that my wife would seek out another relationship because I love her and I want her to be happy.
The line in the magazine was something like, "Your grandfather's been gone 45 years now. After him, there was no one else." It wasn't a sense of obligation to the dead, but that no one else could live up to the standard set by the first spouse.

I have quite a few widowed-and-remarried friends. With some, I had no idea I was observing a second marriage, until it came up. With others, there's a definite different quality to the second marriage. It's more about friendship and companionship, less about children, of course, and partnership.
I guess I can see that, but that idea also seems unhealthy. They have basically set up the standard for a new relationship to be the clone of their old relationship which is just as impossible as a person making a detailed list of things they look for in a relationship and then complaining that they can never find Mr. or Mrs. Right. Besides, who would want to be in a relationship with a partner who is constantly judging and comparing them to some platonic ideal?

It also sounds like a defense mechanism designed to prevent themselves from opening up to a new relationship complete with the possibility of new loss and sorrow. By intentionally setting impossible goals they have justified their fear and refusal so attempt to love again.

You seem to assume that people are largely replaceable, which is odd, seeing as marriage should surely be born out of an extreme love - a love that, perhaps, you wouldn't feel for every Jane and Becky or John and Brad you meet in life.  Some people we meet in life are unique, and are people you probably won't ever encounter again, so what's wrong in not wanting to settle for anything less?

I told my husband that if I get killed, I expect him to get remarried (unless we were very, very old and there was no point to it). If he meets a good match and I'm in the ground, I'd like him to be happy.
I have thought that if my wife were to pass away I could only marry a woman who had lost her husband. My wife will always have a place in my heart and nothing will ever replace her. There will be times when I would get sad and miss her. If I remarried a woman who had not gone through something similar in loosing a spouse they would most likely get upset and ask why I can't forget my first wife. Marrying someone who had also lost someone would help help each spouse be able to deal with the loss and not worry about upsetting the other when we remember the first spouse.

A lot of it also depends on the ages of my children. The younger they are the more they need a mother in the house.
I've already told my wife that if she dies she's getting replaced -- a weekend alone with the kids is enough to convince me that I'm NOT cut out for single parenthood!! ;-)
What if the kids were in high school, college or out of college?
Jeff Foxworthy [imitating his wife] -- "If I die ... you have to promise me [you'll remarry] for the sake of our children."
Jeff Foxworthy [as himself] -- "Well ... OK. [pause] Hey, you don't think the kids'd mind having a young stepmom with some big 'ol hooties, do you? ... Hey! ... Where you going!?!"

JB
I was was talking to a guy and he joked that if his wife passed away he would ask his daughter to set him up with some of her friends.
This is a topic my wife and I have discussed extensively. While I don't believe it is illicit for a widow or widower to remarry, I most likely would not remarry if my wife were to pass. There are circumstances where I could see myself remarrying, but it is not my primary contingency. My wife has expressed a similar desire.

"Why wouldn't you?" - Travis

I am Catholic, and our understanding of Holy Matrimony is that of a vocation (in the same way as being a priest, or a missionary, etc). It is a vocation I am completely dedicated to, and which I came to after considerable discernment. In deciding to undertake Holy Matrimony I chose a certain path to the exclusion of some others. However, I have also discerned that if my wife were to pass and I were left fit enough I would likely take up another path. For instance, I may pursue seminary to become a priest or deacon. Priests cannot wed, and one cannot become a deacon if they have married twice. I have also considered monastic life.

"To me, not allowing yourself to be happy due to some sense of obligation to a dead spouse seems illogical and unhealthy." - Travis

We do carry obligations to the dead, especially our spouse. Discernment over remarriage must be considerate of a late spouse and you obligations to them. That person will be part of the new marriage. That does not mean that all widows or widowers must discern the same path.

Note: This is not meant to start a religious discussion or argument. It is an answer to a specific question asked by Travis. Please do not debate the merit of Catholic teaching on marriage as a response to my post. That is not the intent.

RSS

Latest Activity

John Bravo posted a discussion

What does the AoM communtiy think about one night stands?

Had my first one with a girl I met at a bar the other night...Always been a LTR kinda guy and I'm not sure if I've just become jaded or lost my morals here or what.See More
1 hour ago
leadership posted a discussion

Meeting a girl online: A good introduction message

The introduction message which you send to that cute girl online in which you attempt to cultivate a relationship with her is supposed to be the "attention getter", that determines whether she will message you back and continue the conversation, or just move on hoping to find a better man.I have been using online dating services for over a year now, as a second method in my arsenal NOT as a substitute to meeting a girl offline in the "real world". I have no problems talking to women and asking…See More
2 hours ago
Pale Horse added a discussion to the group Christian Men
Thumbnail

Black Hebrew Israelites and GOCC

Just now heard of them. Apparently one of their ministers went head to head against apologist James White. Smells like heresy. What is it and is it heretical?
3 hours ago
jazzgirl205 replied to Persona non Grata's discussion Men who whine about women?
"I hear this from both women and men.  The problem is not in their stars, dear Brutus, but in themselves.  These whiners are usually not attracted to decent human beings.  They always seem to be drawn to troubled people. …"
5 hours ago
Kevin Morris replied to David R.'s discussion Answered prayers in the group Christian Men
"Good analysis David.  There have been times when I have thought how wonderful it was that God said "no" to something.  He cares for each of us and we have to entrust that He knows what is best.  We may not understand why…"
6 hours ago
David R. added a discussion to the group Christian Men
Thumbnail

Answered prayers

We frequently hear stories of how an extremely important need was "saved" after prayer, such asShe was near death but we prayed for her and she lived.Our marriage almost fell apart but we prayed and God saved our marriage.My job was nearing being taken from me but we prayed and God saved my job.But if we think of God as a Father, any parent does not always say, "Yes" when a request is made.  Sometimes a parent says, "No," and sometimes a parent says, "Not now," and sometimes a parent says,…See More
6 hours ago
David R. joined Tookie's group
Thumbnail

Christian Men

Regardless of the specifics, we can all agree on one thing. Jesus Christ was the perfect Man who died and rose again for us such that we could have fellowship with Him
6 hours ago
Shane replied to Robin Holmström's discussion Tarzan flick as date?
"I used to live where we still had party lines. Not only would I be calling her whole house, but also two or three of her neighbor's houses as well."
9 hours ago

© 2016   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service