I asked a girl, whom I liked for several years, out on a date. She said she was seeing someone else, thus I was rejected. She is someone I often see at our local church every week and at some events. What would be the manly thing to do in this situation when I do happen to see her? I think that showing anger, sadness, or any other negative emotion is not the solution. Things might feel a bit awkward now when I do see her. I would still like to be civil with her.

Even though I do feel that emotional sadness, I don't want to show it. Should I simply act happy and normal when I see her, and act like the rejection never happened? I thought about ignoring her, but that seems like a childish thing to do. Ignoring her would be sending the message that I am bothered by the rejection.  I would appreciate some advice and tips on a situation like this. Acting confident is what I should do, but how can I implement that?

Views: 2485

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Don't take it so seriously. If you want to get laid, you may face rejection, and often. It is the risk we all take.


Well, she's not into you, so you're wasting your time being anything but casually polite and civil with her, as though you barely knew each other. Save the passion for a woman who is actually interested in you and cut this one loose.

He didn't know she was seeing someone?

My thought exactly. Did you merely like her from afar? If you really do know her, do you think  she is lying about another fella to put you off? If she isn't lying how could you not have known? It sounds weird to me.

Regardless. She made her choice so respect it. If you can't be around her and do that, then don't be around her unless unavoidable. You control your emotions. They don't control you.

If they only see each other at church events, and the boyfriend attends another church, he could easily not know.

Exactly, which makes me think it may have been a bit premature. Women are so much more subjective in choosing a mate that you can't "just ask." You have to be yourself around them for a while, without going after them, and if they like what they experience, they'll make it known.
It would be childish to treat her any differently than you did before . Make it a point to ask a different girl out every week , otherwise in your old age you will wonder what if .

I agree with this.

Sea is plenty of fishes.... MOve on... Shift+delete the negative incident....

Confidence is key, even if you're putting on an act.

The tail-beweeen-legs approach is highly unmanly in my opinion, and you actually have no reason to lose confidence. Here is why:

Before you asked her out the chances of her saying yes were 0%. Now you have the idea in her head that you like her - which may not have been there in the first place - that idea can be a planted seed that may grow and eventually blossom in the future. Just because she said 'no' now doesn't mean she won't reconsider in the future. Even though you may have been rejected your chances of dating her in the future may have actually increased, not decreased. 

For that reason it is important to show nothing but your finer points; take it in your stride and act as if it was nothing. Patience..

Don't hang onto false hope, however.. if another opportunity arises then take it. As one door closes another one opens.

Excellent respone, Michael.  I was going to say almost the same thing.  If you can behave like a gentleman, and treat her with the same attitude and approach that you do with other women (whether or not you're interested in them), then that is evidence of a man who is confident in himself.  Be polite, if you have a conversation with her, ask her about things in her life, but not the relationship.  You don't want to be seen as someone who is pining.  It may not ever turn her head towards you, but who knows?  Maybe she has a friend, and wants to introduce her to a guy who has his stuff together.

The response to

"I have a boyfriend."

"I'm seeing someone." etc.

Is: "Does it matter?"

Unless she says I'm not interested this is the response you give.

If she says no to the "does it matter" question, then further pursuit is appropriate. If she says yes, further pursuit. . . well it is a bigger game.

If she's married and has kids. . . that should matter to you.

I think the problem is that you worked yourself into a froth about it before you asked.

I have a friend who is not a player but does ask a lot of women out on dates to coffee, dinner etc.

His view is simple, they are nice attractive girls.  If they say "No" that is fine and he moves on, no arm no foul.  Also he had many more attempts per success because he does not build up in waiting anticipation and fear until he asks.  He is much more off the cuff without the build up.  So while he success rate is probably about normal his attempt rate is so far greater that he always had 3-4 girls he was going out on dates with.  He always had a good time even if the relationships did not progress beyond, someone fun to spend a bit of the day with.

I don't know what you should do to deal with the rejection other then brave it out until the pain fades and don't act like an ass.  I do suggest you take a page out of my friends book.  Ask many interesting girls out to coffee or lunch etc.  Some will say yes most will graciously decline.  Regardless increase your attempt ratio with people that will not make you feel burned for rejection.


Latest Activity

Ian M replied to Ian M's discussion Told "I love you" after two months, I responded with silence
"Thanks, I agree totally. I don't know if we're seeing each other tomorrow, but if we do I will have the talk then."
6 minutes ago
Mongoose replied to Ian M's discussion Told "I love you" after two months, I responded with silence
"Oh, and based on what you disclosed, you certainly have not made a grand mistake: the fact that she is still into you means she did not feel it was a deal-breaker. It means she still finds that you have significant worth to her. I do advise you to…"
15 minutes ago
Ian M replied to Ian M's discussion Told "I love you" after two months, I responded with silence
"Thanks for your thoughtful response. The analogy with the volume knob definitely makes sense, I certainly love her on one level, as I think she is amazing and feel very strong emotions when thinking about her. I just haven't know her very long…"
32 minutes ago
Ian M replied to Ian M's discussion Told "I love you" after two months, I responded with silence
"Thanks for your reassurance, I feel a bit better knowing that others don't think I acted really out of order.  I do really, really like her. I just don't know if I can call it 'love' yet. "
34 minutes ago
Mongoose replied to Ian M's discussion Told "I love you" after two months, I responded with silence
"I suspect communication will make both of you feel better. What happened is very natural and does not mean a bad thing has happened. She said something that you were not prepared for. Silence was your brain pausing so it could process…"
1 hour ago
Liam Strain replied to Ian M's discussion Told "I love you" after two months, I responded with silence
"I think it's ok to apologize, tell her that she caught you a bit off-guard and in that moment you were not sure how to respond. That you really like her, are happy to know how she feels, and to give you a little time to let your feelings catch…"
1 hour ago
Ian M posted a discussion

Told "I love you" after two months, I responded with silence

Hi there,I've been seeing a girl for about two months and last Friday we were out at two of her friends' engagement party, everyone was drinking a lot of alcohol and after we left the bar we were walking along and she told me that she loved me. I was pretty drunk and didn't know how to respond. Unfortunately, her response was met by silence, which I feel pretty bad about. She put her heart on the line and I didn't respond.I suppose I felt that two months was too soon to really be feeling things…See More
2 hours ago
Ian M replied to Stuart Charles's discussion Work, work...
"I'm an investment manager and manage private client portfolios. We don't earn anywhere near as much as people managing funds, but I enjoy it most of the time. There's always stressful periods, like when the markets are tanking, but I…"
2 hours ago

© 2016   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service