Looking for some input/ suggestions... I know a guy, very wonderful guy (only child) who is 35 yrs old and still lives at home (claims hes never had the $ to leave cause he has to pay for everything mom wants or get a huge guilt trip/bitching at). He is afraid to stand up to his mother. He hides the fact that he drinks a few beers, dips, and most importantly has a wife!! Been married for over a year but still cant tell his mom... His father knows hes married and is cool with it. Neither will say a word to her. Why?
And what can anyone do to help him realize his relationship with his controlling, manipulative, extremely over protective mother is very toxic to him and his marriage? To a women, whom I might add, that hes been in love with and waited for for over 15 yrs. Can anything be done to help him cut the apron strings and become the true man he was meant to be?

Views: 654

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

If he wanted to leave, he could've.  I don't believe people can change until I see it.  Nothing you can do.  Can't force a guy to grow a pair.  He's a grown man.  His life is his fault, not his mother's.

I don't even feel sorry for the wife.  She knew what she was getting into.  Not sure why anybody would marry a guy who doesn't have the stones to leave his mom's basement.  Good grief.

Where does the 'wife' stay?  With him at his mom's?  At her own place?

Tell your 'friend' to grow up, then cut him loose.  He's more likely to drag you down than you are to rescue him.  That goes double if you're actually the 'wife', rather than just a 'friend'.


JB

I have to agree with Jack on this.  You can't drag someone out of a situation they don't want to be in or can't see the exit for.  I had a friend who refused to get over being shy to find a job.  He got done with college, coasted for 2 years before his college fund ran out and went home to mom.  We tried and tried to get him a job.  Even when a mutual friend would have been the manager he refused to put in an application.

The best way I know to cut the strings is to move at least 6 hours away but even then not all strings will be cut.  Regardless this is an action that the couple will have do decide to do.

What is your relationship to him?

How do you know this?  Did he tell you?  If so, then he already knows.  Might trying active listening:  drawing him out to talk more.

I don't think you should give up on him.  Nobody is irredeemable.  However, "helping someone realize" something is pretty invasive, and people tend to resist.

He may want to become a man.  What old boy wouldn't?  A community of men might help him do that, by example and by (his) desire.

You are asking an impossible question. How do you help a guy to do something that he has to do by himself without help.

If you are his friend, I'd follow Jack's advice. Tell him to grow up and find better friends.

If you are his wife, I have no idea what to tell you. You chose to marry a guy who won't even admit he married you to his mother and is too much of a loser to be a man. I think you should forget about his issues for a bit and worry about your own.

@Will... This guy and his wife are both good friends of mine. I hear about it from both sides. I also agree that no one is "beyond saving".

I am only asking if anything can be done, and if so what/how? Theses two really belong together, they are great for each other! Really!! Im just curious, how some man's bond with their mom can be so detrimental to ones personal growth. Maybe its an "only child" thing. I dont know. I know its not my problem, but I truly care about them. And I know their both miserable. Her for the lies and him for having to lie. Anyway, thanks for everyone for their input.

Sincerely,

Confused & too good hearted!

Ergo, my suggestions are:

* Listen to him

* Invite him to things w/ company of men.  My two big venues are ManKind Project (which is all about men becoming stronger), and a fraternal order, where they're pretty un-self-consciously what they are.  When you're among those who aren't too screwed up and they expect you to be the same, it can help a lot

* Tell him, w/o harsh judgment or pressure, that you know he's unhappy, and there is a more excellent way, and it's well established:  men move out.  If he's at all sympathetic to Christian or Jewish perspective, there's that thing about leaving the parents and joining the wife.  Of course, he's pretty locked into the mother or he'd have never gotten in this situation.  But knowing there's another option... he's human.  Part of him must want to be free.

Be careful. You, despite your good intentions, might be viewed by either this man or his wife as meddling. And they would be right to think this since you are.

The two of them have some serious issues. Him with his inability to grow up and take his role as a man, and her with agreeing to marry him before he made such a change. This might not end well. And if that happens (or even if it continues in the unhealthy situation its in now) you might find one of them shifting the blame onto you, the meddler.

I know my opinion sounds harsh or selfish. But that's because it is. This is an issue between a married couple. It is one thing to wish them well and be supportive when help is sought but it is another to try to help when not asked. You would be better off distancing yourself from this issue. The fact you are here seeking help in solving it tells me you are already too close (which is why I assumed you were the wife in question). You are meddling in someone else's marriage and that sort of thing never ends well. You are not the one still afraid to grow up nor are you the one who married a childman, surely there are things in your own life that you would be better off devoting your time to?

Thx Will! I believe that he does want to be free. Sometimes I wish I had testicles, maybe I could help him more! Im not much of a "woman" in the "traditional" sense. I should have been my fathers second son!

Tomboy, eh?

The only one with testicles who could help this guy, other than himself, would be his father. And his help would come in the form of a swift kick in the ass out the door.

But the fact he knows his son is married but has not told his own wife (the mother) tells me he's either not living with the mother (and the son) or if he is then the fact he hid it from his own wife tells me he's a much of a child as his son is.

It does not take testicles, if he want to be free he needs to find a job away from his current location and move.  Or simply tell his father to write and move out and not give his mom the phone number.

This guy sounds like a he has a very nice personality.  Unfortunately for you, the four folks you talk about all are living in their own special little worlds of crazy. 

You simply can't help someone who doesn't want to help themself.  Unfortunately too bad for your excellent intentions and concern.

RSS

Latest Activity

Pale Horse replied to Sir's discussion 50 gallon water heater heats 25 gallons
"What do you have the thermostat(s) set at? Sounds like either a thermostat issue or an element issue."
2 hours ago
Native Son replied to Jay D's discussion Fun date ideas for the winter
"There's always dinner and a movie."
3 hours ago
Native Son replied to Chris C.'s discussion Need to put my dog down, suggestions to tell my kid
"If the dog is in pain, it's probably best to bite the bullet, tell the girl the truth.  I'd advise taking the dog to the vet.  Make sure everybody gets a chance to say goodbye to the dog.  You might want to bring the girl…"
3 hours ago
Native Son replied to Sir's discussion 50 gallon water heater heats 25 gallons
"Gas or electric?  If gas, are the valve & piping to the heater in good shape?  (I had a wall furnace that didn't really work well...until I found out the valve handle was bent about 45 degrees.  Didn't work too well with…"
3 hours ago
Lumpy52403 commented on Mongoose's photo
Thumbnail

Proof Knitting is Manly?

""I feel sorry for men who don't knit.  They lead dull lives.""
3 hours ago
Liam Strain replied to Sir's discussion 50 gallon water heater heats 25 gallons
"We're considering a tankless heater for this reason. :/ "
3 hours ago
Sir posted a discussion

50 gallon water heater heats 25 gallons

Brand new 50 gallon water heater still can't fill a standard sized tub, but starts giving tepid water at 25 gals or so.  Service call couldn't find a problem.  I'm beginning to wonder if I'm crazy to expect a hot bath,  or if there's a spell in the house.  Any idea what's wrong?   I'm planning to call the installer again and if he can't fix it have him take it out...but will the next be better?  it has to be the heater, right?See More
4 hours ago
Liam Strain replied to Chris C.'s discussion Need to put my dog down, suggestions to tell my kid
"Just my $.02, but I think 10 is old enough to be pretty honest about the subject. I would not surprise her. Death happens, it's part of life. Dogs do not live as long as people tend to, and our dog is getting older and sicker, and more in pain.…"
5 hours ago

© 2016   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service