Everybody has been frustrated when a good book gets turned into a bad movie. There are times however, when a good book becomes a good movie as well. I can even think of one not so good book that got turned into a pretty good movie.
I would be interested in hearing what books you think got turned into good movies.
Some for me are
The Marathon Man
The Lord of the Rings trilogy
The Hunt for Red October
I want to thank J. A. Greystone for his discussion "Books not yet turned into movies" in the Book group for triggering my thoughts on this.
I'm looking forward to seeing The Road as well. Great book. But the review I just read of the movie said they messed it up by putting flashbacks to the man's wife in it. The reviewer surmised that the movie makers decided that adding a woman would add appeal, so it wasn't a movie just about men, about the father and son. But come on.....that's the whole point of the story!
When I heard that "True Grit" was a book before it was a movie, and that it had been ruined by being put on the big screen, I assumed that the complaint was true. But it was done by Charles Portis purists who seemingly wanted a word-for-word adaptation of the novel. The truth is, the movie was remarkably true to the book, including quite a bit of the dialogue. The ending was a bit different, but frankly, the movie's ending was better than the book's ending, which was long, tedious and depressing, rambling on after the significant parts were concluded.
I don't mind a movie being a bit different from the book, as long as it's true to the original story and good. They're different mediums, and can't expect to be identical.
That said, the Will Smith version of I Am Legend was awful in its differences from the book. The changes made there didn't make sense to me, and the original story was so much better to begin with. That one irritated me.
"There's an aweful lot to unpack in the story.
Didjya know the Lentil Soup meal has significance?
It was a mourning meal
every word in the story has significance.... the lineage of the characters before and after has significance....…"
""The Amalekites were descended from Esau. Esau gave up his birthright for a bowl of soup"
In his defense, he was starving. Jacob could have just given him the fucking soup. Jacob also tricks his dad so that he (Jacob) got the…"
""Ritual train" isn't the official term, I'm sure, but I'm pretty sure you get my drift. In the movie, each priest from the local temple got a turn.
In the movie, you could tell that the mom was very sad about what was…"
" I can see how promiscuity with proper health education can be liberating and not damaging psychologically. No moral guilt for self pleasure or sharing pleasure with a partner. Removing this guilt allows couples to find joyful ways…"
"Consider the different heritages of the different city states:
The Amalekites were descended from Esau. Esau gave up his birthright for a bowl of soup, and cast his lot with the Ishmaelites. In the old testament, the Amalekites are symbolic of…"
" I had my 1st rectal & psa blood taken at 49. I had no symptoms, just wanted 2 get it done. I heard so many horror stories. My psa was .9, so I thought that all was ok. My doctor told me that he wanted me 2 have a biopsy. It took 2 weeks 2…"