Let's keep it short and sweet.

My girlfriend lives with her grandparents. I was told he'd be mad if I spent more than a few bucks (as in like 20) and already bought a $100 bracelet. If he gets upset or something (he's weird, some things he likes when I don't listen to him, others he gets mad about) what would a proper, gentlemanly response be? I'm sixteen, by the way.

Views: 229

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

"I chose a gift I thought your granddaughter would like and that I could afford, Sir."

However - Social taboos in play that the grandfather is reacting to, but can't articulate:

1. Expensive, ostentatious gifts

2. Jewelry as a first Christmas present, in a casual relationship

Both can (especially "in past generations") put the granddaughter in a tough position. They can imply you're trying to buy her. That the relationship is more serious than 16-year-olds should have. That your family is better than hers. That you're better than she is.

Consider, in my upper-middle-class family, full of adult professionals, very few gifts cost $100. I budget $100/person at Christmas, and only since I completed law school. My own family would be embarrassed - has been embarrassed - by gifts that expensive, even when there are no "How do they afford it?" issues. Expensive gifts from a teenager would have been rejected growing up.

People are just funny about presents. I often talk about how my in-laws give only cards at occasions (Father's Day, birthdays) when my family gives gifts and no cards. On AoM today was a story that could be interpreted as meaning a young person thought it was so important to give the boss a gift, she gave him stolen goods. My mother would be aghast to learn that I decided it wasn't worth the trouble to coach my new husband through giving me a gift. My husband is aghast at the inexpensive, unwanted gifts my mother puts so much effort into giving.

I know you don't mean any of those taboos I named. But they're part of our unwritten social fabric, or they were.

Stop using the word "like". 

 Make no mention, ever, to anyone about the dollar amount you spent on a gift. Ever. To anyone. 

If asked directly what you spent on a gift, respond with "What I could afford without going over my holiday budget". If pressed beyond that, respond with "I don't believe that is really' appropriate, to discuss the price of a gift". 

Your best response would depend on what he says.  But the best demeanor, I think, would be detachment from the attack, and focusing on other things.

And that may be wrong.  He may like a good fight.  A joke may turn it.  An excuse.  "

But I'll go with Rebekah:  if you're not, say, engaged, a $100 bracelet is a major statement that you aren't ready to make yet.  Women take jewelry gifts seriously (so women tell me).  Can you return it?  Or save it for a time when the commitment is strong enough to merit it?

RSS

Latest Activity

Sir replied to David R.'s discussion Transgender Persons in the Military in the group The Great Debate
"Naturally I read this as "Velociraptors designed for certain heart conditions."  And they surely are effective at causing them. I'd hate to be one of the leftovers from that trial."
50 minutes ago
Sir replied to David R.'s discussion Transgender Persons in the Military in the group The Great Debate
"You know, Milo, you could point out that you are a person of color and he's whiteheterosplaining you.  "
52 minutes ago
Liam Strain replied to David R.'s discussion Transgender Persons in the Military in the group The Great Debate
"The DoD and the Rand Corporation have both done their own estimates. I do not know the methodology for how they decided who counted under each term. The Rand corp's numbers are about half what the DoD reported. Here is a link to their…"
1 hour ago
Sean O' replied to Vendetta's discussion Men & Exercise
"Looks like a great hike. Beautiful view."
1 hour ago
Milo Morris replied to David R.'s discussion Transgender Persons in the Military in the group The Great Debate
"You're trying to move the goalposts.Nobody is talking about denying medical care to trans people. What we are talking about is denying them free treatment, therapy, surgical procedures, etc., related specifically to gender reassignment. The ED…"
2 hours ago
Dann Anthony replied to David R.'s discussion Transgender Persons in the Military in the group The Great Debate
"My pleasure. I point this out every time someone complains about the supposed prioritization of the male erection at the expense of e.g. breast cancer research. Living as I do in Massachusetts, I hear much, much such complaining. "
2 hours ago
Milo Morris replied to David R.'s discussion Transgender Persons in the Military in the group The Great Debate
"Nobody said "all." They pick and choose which ones they think are problematic."
2 hours ago
Profile IconAndy Mann and Tim joined Herb Munson's group
Thumbnail

The Great Debate

"Iron sharpens iron." A place for men to impact each other by debate and exchange of ideas. This is a group where no ideas are off limits. If your motto is, "I never talk about politics or religion," this group is probably not for you. A "gym" for thinkers.See More
2 hours ago

© 2017   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service