Let's keep it short and sweet.

My girlfriend lives with her grandparents. I was told he'd be mad if I spent more than a few bucks (as in like 20) and already bought a $100 bracelet. If he gets upset or something (he's weird, some things he likes when I don't listen to him, others he gets mad about) what would a proper, gentlemanly response be? I'm sixteen, by the way.

Views: 209

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

"I chose a gift I thought your granddaughter would like and that I could afford, Sir."

However - Social taboos in play that the grandfather is reacting to, but can't articulate:

1. Expensive, ostentatious gifts

2. Jewelry as a first Christmas present, in a casual relationship

Both can (especially "in past generations") put the granddaughter in a tough position. They can imply you're trying to buy her. That the relationship is more serious than 16-year-olds should have. That your family is better than hers. That you're better than she is.

Consider, in my upper-middle-class family, full of adult professionals, very few gifts cost $100. I budget $100/person at Christmas, and only since I completed law school. My own family would be embarrassed - has been embarrassed - by gifts that expensive, even when there are no "How do they afford it?" issues. Expensive gifts from a teenager would have been rejected growing up.

People are just funny about presents. I often talk about how my in-laws give only cards at occasions (Father's Day, birthdays) when my family gives gifts and no cards. On AoM today was a story that could be interpreted as meaning a young person thought it was so important to give the boss a gift, she gave him stolen goods. My mother would be aghast to learn that I decided it wasn't worth the trouble to coach my new husband through giving me a gift. My husband is aghast at the inexpensive, unwanted gifts my mother puts so much effort into giving.

I know you don't mean any of those taboos I named. But they're part of our unwritten social fabric, or they were.

Stop using the word "like". 

 Make no mention, ever, to anyone about the dollar amount you spent on a gift. Ever. To anyone. 

If asked directly what you spent on a gift, respond with "What I could afford without going over my holiday budget". If pressed beyond that, respond with "I don't believe that is really' appropriate, to discuss the price of a gift". 

Your best response would depend on what he says.  But the best demeanor, I think, would be detachment from the attack, and focusing on other things.

And that may be wrong.  He may like a good fight.  A joke may turn it.  An excuse.  "

But I'll go with Rebekah:  if you're not, say, engaged, a $100 bracelet is a major statement that you aren't ready to make yet.  Women take jewelry gifts seriously (so women tell me).  Can you return it?  Or save it for a time when the commitment is strong enough to merit it?

RSS

Latest Activity

Pale Horse replied to Augustin's discussion The Mask You Live In - Don't tell boy to man up! (Says video)
"Seems to me like the kids in that documentary are being told to go somewhere without being told the way."
12 minutes ago
Augustin replied to Augustin's discussion The Mask You Live In - Don't tell boy to man up!
"Who me?"
14 minutes ago
Nathanael replied to Augustin's discussion The Mask You Live In - Don't tell boy to man up!
"Not sure if troll..."
14 minutes ago
Augustin posted a discussion

The Mask You Live In - Don't tell boy to be a man!

There is a film coming out this year called "The Mask You live in". It is going to explore masculinity in the USA.It will discuss this danger of telling boys such as "be a man" or "man up". This will lead to boys growing up keeping their emotions inside and eventually develop behavioral problems.I'm not sure what to make of all this at all so I haven't really formed a solid opinion yet.This trailer will explain it better than I:(Website: …See More
17 minutes ago
Andrew D, USA Ret replied to Jack Bauer's discussion Nevada Ranch War ... in the group The Great Debate
"S. Dallas: "So your answer to me saying that there is no forest is to change the metaphor to one of sheep and wolves and sheepdogs in hopes to maybe win that one since this one turned to shit on you, forgetting that I called you out on that one…"
21 minutes ago
Andrew D, USA Ret replied to Jack Bauer's discussion Nevada Ranch War ... in the group The Great Debate
"Liam S: "Does believing yourself to be a patriot, make you one? Or is that job relegated to the hindsight and the history books?" Good question, Liam.  As I know you are fully aware, history tends to be written by the victors who…"
35 minutes ago
Pale Horse replied to Jack Bauer's discussion Nevada Ranch War ... in the group The Great Debate
"http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2014/04/16/why-is-us-senator-harry-reid-so-concerned-with-local-nevada-rancher/ Here, Liam. Of course this doesn't give him an excuse, but I agree with the author that there is more to this. Theu don't just…"
39 minutes ago
Southwind1948 joined Raj's group
Thumbnail

History Buffs

A place for history buffs to discuss historical issues and expand the knowledge of our past. Whether your into US history, European history, African history, or any other, come join us!See More
39 minutes ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service