So the discussion about the Boy Scouts of America and their policy excluding gays and atheists got me curious about the subject so I started googling. In particular, I wanted to see if Lord Baden-Powell, the founder of Scouts had anything to say about homosexuality. I remembered that he was big on sexual abstinence and decried the evils of "self-pollution," ie whacking off.  

Well, was I surprised that my search results came up that Baden-Powell may have been a repressed homsexual himself and maybe even a pedophile. Two biographers have come to that conclusion, at least. Again, it's their interpretation and it's highly debated. 

Some of the evidence they look to:

-Powell recorded his dreams in a diary and most of them were about young boys (this could be because he worked with boys all day, not because he was gay)
-Powell enjoyed watching naked boys swim and got upset when swimming naked was banned. He disdained female nudity.
when Powell was staying overnight at the school with his old friend A. H. Tod, who had been in the Rifle Corps and in the football 1st XI with him. In November 1919 Tod was over the retirement age but still teaching because it was wartime and all the younger staff had joined up. 'Stayed with Tod,' Stephe wrote in his diary. 'Tod's photos of naked boys and trees etc. Excellent.'. That a bachelor housemaster should have taken large numbers of nude photographs of his boys evidently did not strike Baden-Powell as undesirable. A few days later he wrote to Tod about starting a Scout troop at the school and added that he would soon be visiting Charterhouse again, 'which will give me the opportunity of seeing the football; and possibly I might get a further look at those wonderful photographs of yours!'
- He didn't marry until he was 55 years old. When he did, he married a 23 year old and had her change her looks so she looked more like a boy. She flattened her breasts, hid her cleavage with a neckerchief, cut her hair, and wore outfits that looked like boy scout uniforms. They had three kids, but descriptions of the Powell's relationship with his wife make it seem like there wasn't much romance there.
-Like alleged pedophile Michael Jackson, Baden-Powell loved Peter Pan. I don't think the love of Peter Pan makes a man a pedophile, but he definitely had some Peter Pan syndrom going on in that he seemed to relate better with boys rather than men his age. Which is sort of creepy when you're 55 years old.

Again, this is pretty speculative and historians will never be able to truly determine Baden-Powell's sexuality because most of his private correspondence were destroyed. Even if was gay or even a pedophile, there's no evidence that Baden-Powell acted out on his feelings. The man was obsessed with stifling sexual feelings and even counseled young men to go stick their wiener in cold water if they had the urge to masturbate. But again, we'll never know.

I don't really have a point with this. I just thought it was interesting.

Views: 3827

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

We've decided to spell it "Catholick" now.
Oh! A pot-shot taken against the Catholic Church that cleverly invokes the accusations of child abuse against less than 1.5% of our priests (with fewer actual convictions) from the safety of an anonymous internet forum! How original! Seriously, I've never seen this! You must be a delightfully creative person. Not to mention the care and sensitivity you show with the careful referencing of a very painful event in the lives of those who were abused. Then you go even further to stretch that sensitivity (and obvious acceptance of those with views contrary to your own) to encompass the Boy Scouts as well! You must be so amazingly funny in person!

Sorry, I have to stop because the sarcasm is starting to soak into my keyboard, and it's so difficult to get that smell of disdain out once it's really seeped in there.
All good and well. But as I seem to recall, the Catholic church did nothing but move those offending priests from one church to another. I don't know that you can feel justified in defending the church... just saying
At the time psychologists believed pedophilia could be cured, and were telling the bishops that those men were. Obviously the bishops should have realized this wasn't the case after a repeat offense, but I was in no way defending the actions of the bishops or priests. I stand firmly by my previous statement; the comment (which is no longer there) was deliberately provocative, outright rude, not helpful or constructive in any way, not respectful of those abused or of those who still hold the Catholic faith.

Now that's all I'll say, because this is off topic.

It is easy to definitively disprove that RCC did nothing but move disgraced priests around, or cover it up, or whatever.  I wrote it up once here.  That should take care of it.

Karma, you recently had a thread going where you had an open discussion about your magick beliefs which you opened with saying that you thought others would insult it. Not only did they not but they even held a mature discussion on it. Its bit hypocritical of you to now turn around and insult another's beliefs.
Lets all please stop insulting my church. Every religion has some bad history, the Catholic church is no exception. But this is isn't the correct forum for church-bashing. Go to 4chan if you want to do that.
Anyone who curses so much, blames "women" (not one woman) for the issues he had with his ex, spews out blame to Brett (for not approving his group -- which Brett did), Catholic Church, and anyone who presumes to disagree with either his tone or his content . . . he's not here for a meeting of the minds. He's here to be right and angry. We may as well let him. He's not a troll, but in terms of the effect on our discussions, he may as well be.
After reading this (and trying desperately to brain-bleach some of those mental images. Thanks, Brett!) my thoughts are somewhat conflicted.

First of all, I have little respect for biographers who view activities of the past through a current social lens and ascribe a modern meaning. For instance, it is well known that Abraham Lincoln was very fond of his secretary, a man. They had a very close friendship and some of their letters were quite intimate, in a brotherly way, IMO. Some biographers have interpreted this to mean that Lincoln and his secretary were gay lovers, because men today don't write to each other that way unless the relationship is more than platonic. However, there are many examples of contemporaries using such intimate language with one another.

However, if true, these things about Baden-Powell are troubling. On the one hand, I can see how he truly wanted to help boys. On the other hand, it's easy to question his motives given this background. Does this make Boy Scouts fruit of a poisoned tree?

The other thing to keep in mind is that while Lord Baden-Powell is credited with creating Scouting worldwide, the Boy Scouts of America has roots in not only Baden-Powell's Scouting, but other boy's clubs with an emphasis on Indian lore and other American traditions.
Agreed with not respecting biographers who view activities through our current social lens.

But, I'm sure it was weird even by 1900s standards for a man to have his wife change her appearance so she looked like a boy. This was a time when there were clearly defined gender roles, particularly in Victorian England.

The naked boys thing is weird, too. Apparently the photos were "posed" so as to create some sort of Ancient Greek setting or something. Victorians were big on this sort of thing. When cameras first came out, they were big on taking pictures of naked people but they usually posed people in ways that harkened to Classic Art. Just look at pictures of strong men from this time. They're usually completely naked except for a fig leaf covering their twigs and berries. Also, pictures of naked women were done in the same way. Personally, I think it was their way to class up naughty photos. A Victorian man could collect postcards of naked ladies without the fear of being called a cad and a pervert as long as those naked ladies were posing like Da Vinci's Venus de Milo. There's lots of websites dedicated to arching this Victorian-artsy-erotica stuff. Compared to today's standards, there's nothing really sexual about them and a lot of it does look like pieces of art. But who's to say that Victorian gentlemen didn't get their rocks off to them.

So Baden-Powell may have had the kiddy version of this Victorian erotica stuff.
Lord and Lady Powell:

Interesting tidbit from Wikipedia. If you look up "Girl Guides", you will find that Lady B-P's clothing is the uniform of a Girl Guide leader. Girl Guides are the female equivalent of the Boy Scouts. In the US, the equivalent organization is the Girl Scouts.


Latest Activity

Irish Skot updated their profile
3 hours ago
Liam Strain replied to Sir's discussion Looking for two quotes in the group The Great Debate
"“George Bush’s faulty and offensive historical analogies aren’t going to end the war in Iraq, make America safer or bring our troops…"
4 hours ago
Liam Strain replied to Braeden's discussion Why do American Schools tolerate this? in the group The Great Debate
"I often would tape record lectures that I had trouble with, then review later in conjunction with my notes. This happens on occasion. "
4 hours ago
Liam Strain replied to Native Son's discussion The Current Travel Mess. in the group The Great Debate
""What damage is it actively causing?"Beyond the obvious - to those coming here. It plays directly into the narrative that terrorists and islamist radical want. It gives them another reason to say "look, we were right, the US hates…"
4 hours ago
Liam Strain replied to Native Son's discussion The Current Travel Mess. in the group The Great Debate
"I've heard the Obama Iraq decision characterized as like going to the DMV and finding new regulations in place. It takes longer, but they still were processing. Politifact breaks it down nicely. the TL:DR version, trying to make the…"
4 hours ago
Dominic replied to Native Son's discussion The Current Travel Mess. in the group The Great Debate
"There are so many important differences between Obama's action and Trump's as to render equivalency null. The 2011 action was predicated on a specific and credible threat. That action only halted the processing of refugee visas from one…"
8 hours ago
Clinton R. Ausmus replied to Native Son's discussion The Current Travel Mess. in the group The Great Debate
"I stand corrected.  Still just one country, not seven.Guess this is the whole "Bowling Green Massacre" we've heard so much about...I appreciate the link and the correction on my facts..."
8 hours ago
Clinton R. Ausmus replied to Native Son's discussion The Current Travel Mess. in the group The Great Debate
"This is the largest refugee crisis since WWII.There are 4.9 million Syrian Refugees alone, and at least 6 million displaced with in Syria trying to get out. That's far from a couple thousand.  You should step outside of this whole,…"
8 hours ago

© 2017   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service