I started shaving with a safety razor not too long ago after my brother gave me a kit for my birthday. I tried the samples that he included, including a sandalwood. I found one that is fantastic, and it was Lavender and Cedar from the Napa Soap Co. I slather that lather on when I have a shave, and feel like a new man afterwards. i was curious to see what scents other members here have tried and liked.
My favorite scents include Truefitt & Hill Trafalgar (and Grafton too, though both may be a little on the "old man" side, 1805 is a "younger" smell), Crabtree & Evelyn Sienna (a lot of people like Nomad too), Speick, and Castle Forbes limes (like getting smacked in the face with a key lime pie).
I currently use Taylor of Old Bond with sandalwood smell and I absolutely love it!