Hello my fellow men, I'm in the market to get myself a new scent.  Personally I have always really enjoyed Old Spice, but I would like some suggestions for a good cologne that your average joe doesn't have..but has a similar smell profile.  Does anything come to mind?


Views: 2120

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

For me its still hard to beat the original POLO

Once you go Polo Black, you don't go back!...

but seriously, Ralph Lauren Polo Black is great.  Not too sweet, not tangy and not offensive.  Been using it for 6-7 years now. 

I've been using the Bay Rum that the Duluth Trading Company sells.  I get alot of complements on it, but the scent doesn't last long.  I'd like to try another brand of bay rum, if anyone has suggestions. 

I believe Bay Rums are generally aftershaves so will probably never last overly long. Order the Captain's Choice Bay Rum. It seems to have some staying power. It's good stuff, made by hand in small batches. It has a few extra aromatics added to it. For the authentic scent from back when sailors first started infusing bay leaves (they're not the same bay leaves that you use in cooking) in rum get a bottle of Dominica Bay Rum. It's grain alcohol and bay leaves. Nothing else, just like it should be. Again this is an aftershave so it won't be lasting all day.

Here recently I have been using Brooks Brothers cologne.  I got hooked on it when a co-worker of mine told me it's what he used.  I would suggest the Brooks Brothers travel pack, and see which scent you like best.

I'm a big fan of Pinaud Clubman Special Reserve.  Smells like a classy man who would enjoy drinking cocktails in the evening before taking a lovely young woman out to a show.

I too love that brand. Felt cheesy buying it at first, but my wife likes it.

Gucci Pour Homme is amazing but I understand it's been discontinued. Rich, woody, incense tones. Lasts all day on me. Makes me want to pull the neck of my shirt up over my face all day just to smell it. This one is more of a winter/cold weather scent. If you ever see a bottle, buy it immediately.

Rive Gauche by Yves Saint Laurent is a great summertime scent. Very clean, makes you smell like you just came from a manly barber shop. Should be a good choice to wear if you work in an office environment.

I use the Sandalwood Cologne from Taylor of Old Bond Street. It's a great, deep, woody spicy scent so similar to Old Spice in some ways. It's relatively cheap for a cologne but isn't of cheap quality one bit, it smells like it should be a lot more expensive. Comes in a nice glass splash bottle, simple with no overdone packaging. It's not a easy cologne to find so your best bet would be to buy it online.

Guerlain Vetiver is a classic. Guerlain Vetiver Extreme is a modern variant.

My favorite is Guerlain Habit Rouge. My wife's favorite from my collection is Guerlain Heritage.

What's a smell profile?

Grey Flannel


Latest Activity

Will Norman replied to Jim's discussion So what games are you playing? in the group Video Gaming
"I've been mucking around in Borderlands 2 and The Pre-Sequel. Rather enjoying myself."
51 minutes ago
Seth Weyh added a discussion to the group Riflemen

Most Cost Effective Rifle

I'm fairly new to shooting and really interested in hunting. Unfortunately I didn't grow up in a situation to learn from family members. I don't have a whole lot of expendable cash lately but i'd really like to at least get a rifle to start shooting with. Recreation, small game, that sort of thing.  Recently I came across the  Savage Arms Mark II GXP Bolt-Action Rifle for about $175.  I've looked into some reviews and it seems pretty decent. But I'm wondering if maybe there's something I'm not…See More
8 hours ago
Seth Weyh replied to Jim's discussion So what games are you playing? in the group Video Gaming
"I mostly use PC  I've got a ps3 I haven't set up yet and a wiiu in my garage somewhere. Mostly i just use my pc though. I do have and use a 3ds but that's almost exclusively for pokemon and monster hunter  Currently i'm…"
8 hours ago
Profile IconSeth Weyh and Chris Pogon joined Jim's group

Video Gaming

Video Gamers is a group for men who actually like to play video games and discuss all things related to video gaming. See More
9 hours ago
Chris Pogon joined Mike Norris's group


A group for watch aficionados
16 hours ago
Liam Strain replied to IThinkTherforeImMan's discussion Stoicism and Plato's tripartite theory of soul in the group Stoicism
"I honestly don't see how they can be directly compared. They seem like such different ways of approaching different questions, that trying to contrast them is nearly futile.  Can you expound a bit on where you think the central conflict…"
18 hours ago
Chris Pogon joined Rob Markoski's group


For the discussion of the Philosophy of Stoicism.
18 hours ago

© 2016   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service