So, I write a comment on the post about veterans today. Hit the "submit" button. See the "this comment is awaiting moderation" message. Then -- about 5 hours later-- my comment is still not there.

I didn't used bad words, nor did I write anything that I could regard as offensive to others.

So why was it censored? Because I don't agree with the author or the site owner?
I'm really upset about this. I don't think my opinion is any better than the next guy's, but I certanly do think it's JUST as important as his.

Has anybody had a similar issue in the past?

P.S. If you were about to write something like "well, it's Brett's blog, so if you don't like it just leave", please note that I do like the blog --a lot. But I also like virtues such as intelectual honesty, opennes and transparency.

Views: 1205

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Point taken. 

I just went and looked through the comments.  There are a few in disagreement, and one exchange of disagreement, with the author.  So it's not an issue of disagreement, but rather your particular disagreement.  My opinion, it was just too inflammatory for that article.  Too political and too off topic.

Maybe you firmly believe 1 and 2. Okay, your business. But was it necessary to say it in a forum of honoring vets? Then complain if it's not posted by they guy that owns the blog? With free speech comes responsibility, and a right to free speech does not guarantee an adoring, simpering audience.

Can you really say you like intellectual honesty if your post on a veteran's day blog is intended to cause trouble? You were not being honest with yourself if you didn't think it through. Sometimes, a man must self-censor so as not to do harm.

Glad I typed all that coz my first reaction was nasty, but I self-censored as an example. Capisce?

To be fair, you have no legal right to post your comment on the article. Indeed, Brett reserves all rights to censor as much or as little as he wants. That's just the nitty gritty legal side of things.

I would agree with you that transparency (yeah, that buzzword) and the principle behind free speech should permit you to post your comment, especially if your comment was not vulgar, inflammatory, or otherwise offensive. Perhaps Brett just skipped over some comments and wasn't able to approve them all. Running this blog and being an active father would be a busy gig. Give him the benefit of the doubt. As you say, he runs a great site. I trust him in the comment sections as well. 

I know I don't have any "legal right" to post my comments (it's not like I wanna sue him!).  I actually agree with Brett in many aspects, but not with this.

It is a comment section on a private blog. You aren't being censored, you aren't having your honesty and "opennes" challenged, they aren't practicing a lack of transparency. Try using your virtue of being "intelectual" and realize that sometimes shit you say doesn't really matter and won't be put out there.

If you don't like it, you can always start your own blog and say whatever shit that you think needs to be said over there. Hell, say it in great debate or the blog feature here.

Either way, be a man and suck it up

LShieldes's got it.

Did you even read what I wrote up there? I will assume you didn't, so:

1) I don't think much of my opinion. It's as valuable as yours

2) I like AoM. It's my favorite blog. That doesn't mean I can't disagree with some aspects of it

By the way: next time you feel like being sarcastic, try harder.

Shieldes and I rarely agree, but we're of the same mind on this one.

 

You're not being censored.  Your comment was, apparently, found to be unworthy or unwelcome.  Frankly I'm curious what it said, but apparently I won't get to read it.

 

And, just for reference, I noticed no sarcasm in his reply to you.  

That's because he is lousy at it :D

I won't rewrite my comment, but I explained it's content to Shane in this thread.

I haven't read the comment sections on the main blog in a while, but I've never seen any comments censored for disagreement.  Simple or violent.  I didn't even know Brett was moderating them given some of the anti-AoM replies I've seen.  Also, given some of the disagreements I've had with Kate on this board, and me still being here, I'd be willing to bet it was an honest overlook.

I didn't know Kate waded into the forums. Never seen her here. 

RSS

Latest Activity

John Muir replied to Shane's discussion Ignorance of the Law is No Excuse... in the group The Great Debate
"Well that sucks. You don't know the name of the case, do you? "
16 minutes ago
sebenza replied to Tayton Mahone's discussion I'm going to try Intermittent Fasting. Anyone else had ago? Anyone have any results?
"im going to try this myself when i get back home from holiday . been reading up on it and it seems to have a lot of benefits . gonna try 24 hours first and the appple fast for 3 days the following month , seems to make sense to me anyway . "
17 minutes ago
Shane replied to Ramsay Bolton's discussion Zombie Thread
"Use you as bait to get away. Shoulda left my family out of it."
21 minutes ago
Shane replied to Shane's discussion Ignorance of the Law is No Excuse... in the group The Great Debate
"Supreme Court just ruled it doesn't matter. We get to have even dumber cops because now there is even less liability."
23 minutes ago
Josh100LuBu replied to Christian Schmidt's discussion Let's Have A Spoiled Christmas
"You could never afford one. "
32 minutes ago
sebenza replied to Ramsay Bolton's discussion Zombie Thread
"1) dont get bit , 2) stay away from odd looking people eating raw flesh . i have built a small but quality collection of knives recently and have a pellet gun if that will do much . just waiting for you americans to invent the zombie and im ready…"
35 minutes ago
sebenza replied to Christian Schmidt's discussion The Word "Manly" Is A Burden
"it is if you worry about what little things are and are not manly  . thats not what i get from this blog ?? i get that being strong , capable and tough are what i need to work on personally . most men do manly stuff , hunting fish metal work…"
41 minutes ago
Ramsay Bolton replied to Ramsay Bolton's discussion Zombie Thread
"Learning to make alcoholic beverages woukd be great for trade and bartering purposes"
48 minutes ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service