So, I write a comment on the post about veterans today. Hit the "submit" button. See the "this comment is awaiting moderation" message. Then -- about 5 hours later-- my comment is still not there.

I didn't used bad words, nor did I write anything that I could regard as offensive to others.

So why was it censored? Because I don't agree with the author or the site owner?
I'm really upset about this. I don't think my opinion is any better than the next guy's, but I certanly do think it's JUST as important as his.

Has anybody had a similar issue in the past?

P.S. If you were about to write something like "well, it's Brett's blog, so if you don't like it just leave", please note that I do like the blog --a lot. But I also like virtues such as intelectual honesty, opennes and transparency.

Views: 1209

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I've had it happen to me on many occaisions on a lot of sites....It's all about conformity....Sometimes your opinion just doesn't mesh with the general public's, you're not following the Sheeple.

 

I think it is very important to hear both sides of an argument....The opinion of men on both sides of the room.  But when the man on the other side of the room says something that goes against the mainstream and brings up issues people don't want to acknowledge, that man has to be silenced, because surely someone out of the masses will recognize this man is right, and then it spreads like a disease, and soon, there's a huge shift in thinking that the powers that be just cannot abide by as they feel threatened.

 

....I am NOT a right-wing lunatic, nor am I some weird conspiracy theorist...Just sayin....

It could be that Brett, or the other powers that be, simply haven't been around to approve the comment. Also I have noticed that Brett seems to try and avoid conflict in the main threads. This is why they have the Great Debate thread and such. So he may have felt that your comment, while not offensive in it self, may have cause the thread to become unruly.

To open a public forum and then avoiding conflict seems contradictory to me. I understand the need for moderation (avoiding spam and whatnot) but I'm positive my comment was rejected because of my point of view on celebrating war veterans.

Message Brett and ask him.  He's online now.

What was your comment?

Thanks for the heads up! I have just asked him.

Don't have a copy of the comment, but I wanted to say two things:

1) That I don't believe in honour people who kills other people

2) That not every war the US has fought had the purpose of preserving or achieving freedom

Yep. You probably got blocked.

Maybe Brett wanted his Veterans Day post, and it's comments section, to be about American Veterans rather than your petty European political gripes. I don't blame him for not letting you derail the comment section.

JB

I would argue that a great way to honor veterans is allow the exercise of the free speech that veterans protect.

I'm sure you would. But, this isn't a matter if free speech. It never was. AOM is not obligated to let somebody hijack it's comments section with a debate it'd rather not entertain at the moment.

JB

I feel like you're being hypocritical, JB. Calling Tomas petty while you yourself are. It's one thing to point out a man's errors. It's another thing to degrade his opinion in the process. 

I wouldn't want to denigrate your "feelings", but you're wrong.

To attempt to hijack a post meant to honor sacrifice, instead making it a debate about your personal non-American viewpoint on the American military is petty. Pointing out that it is petty is not similarly petty.

It is degrading, I suppose, but degrading and petty aren't the same thing. So, there's no hypocrisy.

JB

I'm an American and I don't think that there's anything wrong with non-Americans commenting on the meaning of Veterans' Day. It is also celebrated in many other places as Armistice Day!

I didn't attempted to hijack the post. I'm not a provoker. I honestly expressed my opinion. That's it. 

Do you think I should only comment when I agree 100% with the author of the post? If so, I'm glad democracy doesn't depend on you.

RSS

Latest Activity

Shane replied to Rob's discussion Paying for your own harassment and ritual humiliation
"This was the capstone case of a rather lengthy Harvard Law Review (you know that conservative rag your President edited). You obviously didn't read it. I'll sum up, this kind of shit is a trend."
18 minutes ago
Jack Bauer replied to Rob's discussion Paying for your own harassment and ritual humiliation
"That's an interesting point.  How do the race groups on campus feel about this kind of profiling?  For years, they've been fighting against obnoxious "Arabs look like terrorists", "Hispanics look like…"
26 minutes ago
Will commented on Pelagius's status
"BTW, thanks for making me look up "gracile."  Seriously."
29 minutes ago
Will commented on Pelagius's status
"A house of cards.   "
30 minutes ago
Rick Shelton replied to Rob's discussion Paying for your own harassment and ritual humiliation
"Guilt or innocence is not determined by a college administration but by a jury of peers or judge in a court of law.  The young man was determined guilty by reason of resemblance (not even a legal argument at all), and his freedom restricted by…"
44 minutes ago
Rick Shelton replied to Rob's discussion Paying for your own harassment and ritual humiliation
"I'm sure the Jews in Germany didn't look at statistics the same way either afterwards.  Nor do the girls that Boku Haram have kidnapped or the kidnapped journalist/aidworkers/tourists.  I mean statistically they're in the…"
57 minutes ago
Rick Shelton replied to Rob's discussion Paying for your own harassment and ritual humiliation
"This."
1 hour ago
Jack Bauer replied to Rob's discussion Paying for your own harassment and ritual humiliation
"He was talking about the policy, not the case.  The policy that sets this kid free is generally applicable.  We don't punish innocent people. This is also not as completely out-of-the-blue as it sounds.  There is a certain…"
1 hour ago

© 2015   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service