Hi all.

I am finishing my Engineering degree in a week’s time; I do not officially graduate until the end of March next year though. A couple of the guy I am good friends with and I decided that we needed to do something different, something classy, to mark the completion of our degrees. Not just the typical find the nearest bar and consume copious amounts of alcohol. The suggestion was put forward to celebrate by enjoying scotch and cigars on the roof of the engineering building.

This is where my dilemma arises; I don’t have the faintest idea about buying scotch.

So I am looking for suggestions as to what I should get.

Any help would be appreciated.

Regard,

D

Views: 2191

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

If you don't drink a lot of Scotch you may find that the more expensive brands are awfully smokey tasting.  Scotch is basically a whiskey which has had some ingredients dried over a peat fire, thus the smokey taste.  Spending $50 to $75 for a single barrel scotch that is too smokey tasting to enjoy is not fun.

I like Balvenie's Double Wood Scotch for special occasions.  The double wood in the name means that it has been aged in an oak barrel and a barrel that was used to age Port.  This Scotch is very smooth and easy to drink for non-Scotch drinkers.  A bottle will probably set you back about $50.

FWIW, the most popular Scotch that is drunk by the Scotch in Scotland is Famous Grouse.  This is usually the cheapest Scotch in my local store costing less than $20 per bottle.  I hold the taste to be as good as many of the more expensive Scotchs.

Buck76

+1 on the Balvenie Doublewood - really fine scotch, even more so for the price.

If you want something really special, try the Balvenie 21 year portwood is amazing.

With that said - I tend to prefer speyside scotches (honey/leather/vanilla/spice) rather than Islay and Highland Scotches (peat/smoke)

Agreed , however I prefer Drambuie , it's made by lords and earls whereas bourbon is made by toothless rednecks ( not my words stolen from there poster )

I've taken a liking to Scotch myself. Scotch is Oakey, peatey, and smokey. On top of that it might have other flavors deep down inside of it. If you're not comfortable drinking straight whiskey, then drinking a complicated scotch will be less than pleasurable. I've heard it said that if you want to develop your palate for Scotch, there's two methods: A) Start with scotch and soda, and increase your scotch to soda ratio until you can drink scotch straight(note, only do this with blends. Someone might smack you if you mix a single malt with anything. Of course, drink what you like. Ol' Dick Nixon loved VERY expensive scotch with his Canada Dry.) or B) Drink straight Scotch until you're used to the taste and begin to enjoy it. It's a developed taste, like coffee, or for some like wine. If you're looking for a blended Scotch(read: mellow, smoother, more balanced. It's a mix of several Scotch whiskeys.) that's pretty decent and won't break the bank, Chivas Regal 12 Year, Johnnie Walker Black Label, even Dewar's 12 Year is pretty good. Single Malts have more variety(they're a single malting from a single distillery, not mixed at all) and can be pretty feisty, but to the experienced Scotch drinker, they have much more liveliness and flavor. The Macallan 12 year Single Malt is around $50, and it's mighty tasty to me. Glenlivet 12 and a few others are good too. The older the scotch and the "purer" it is, the more expensive. Single Malts cost more than Blended Malts(a blend of Single Malt whiskeys) which cost more than Blended Scotch Whiskey, as a rule of thumb, but branding also plays in here.

Honestly, drink what you like is still thing to fall back on. To me, Scotch didn't take too long to enjoy, but others really don't like it. Maybe buy a small bottle of something you want to try beforehand and give it a whirl. If it's not your cup of tea you can still be classy drinking bourbon, brandy, cognac, armagnac, or even champagne, a nice beer. Don't drink Scotch to BE classy. Drink Scotch classily because you like Scotch, and you're already classy.

Bottoms up.

I just realized Richard Nixon's nickname was censored. Good times.

David—congratulations on your graduation!  Engineering is a tough slog, so yes, that accomplishment deserves a special celebration.  And on the roof of the eng building!  I like it!

May I recommend the 12 yr Glenlivet.  Its readily available at most grocery stores and is a good ‘starter’ Scotch.  A bit smoky and peaty without being too much.  I bought a bottle for my nephew last year as a graduation present from Annapolis—he really enjoyed it.   I would pair this with a light cigar, say a Man O’ War Virtue. Again, an easy cigar to get your hands on, yet very good.

Good luck and, again, congratulations.

I'd recommend Gragganmore as it is my personal favorite. That said. I'll add my voice to those who say that unless you particularly like scotch, spend your money elsewhere, like on a good Irish whiskey (Jameson).  They cost less and taste great. Though I like scotch, it's either Jameson or Makers Mark (bourbon) in my house simply due to the cost. I might buy 1 bottle Cragganmore per year. Mostly it is my rare night out drink.

BTW, most currently used single ply roofing materials don't stand up to cigar and cigarette ashes.  You don't want to celebrate your degree with a bill for $10K to fix the roof.

Buck76

First do you like scotch?  If not don’t blow your money.

My general rule is that they need to be neat, single, legal, and preferably old enough to drink themselves.

To translate that. 

  1. Drink it neat. Straight, no ice or water in the glass.  I have tall glass of water with mine to save my stomach.
  2. Single Malt Scotch not blended.
  3. At least 18 years old
  4. 21 years old would be better – smoother  (and more expensive).

Those ideas will provide you a fairly good drink. 

The next question is how peaty / smoky you like your drink?  The island distilleries use peat to cook their brew which gives it the smokiness to the drink.

I would suggest a Oban or a Glenmorangie.

But this is purely a personal taste.  My best suggestion is that you find a good bar and take a friend or two scotch tasting.  Try some different things to find what you like.

Agreed. Go out and try some first. I didn't like scotch until I tried some 18 year Caol Ila. It's extremely smoky...kinda tastes smoked. That very prominent smoky flavor somehow eased me into the scotch taste.

Listen to this guy; he knows his stuff.

A Scot owned bar that I frequent always sets a small pitcher of water next to a Scotch order.  I asked about this and the bartender replied that a little water helps to "open up" the taste.  So I tried the Scotch neat and then added a little water and was surprised at the difference in the taste.  A fun experiment.

Buck76 

RSS

Latest Activity

Drew replied to Drew's discussion Dealing with a depressing job
"Again thanks for the responses. 2 part-time roles may be an option, although I don't know how each employer would feel about me having another job. It wouldn't lead to any sort of tax penalty provided HMRC (our equivalent of the IRS) knew…"
48 minutes ago
J. Exalto replied to J. Exalto's discussion Globalism in the group The Great Debate
"Are you saying people in poor countries without such generous welfare systems don't need jobs more than people who live in North America?  It's hard to be unemployed anywhere, sure, but I can't imagine it being easier to be in…"
3 hours ago
Shane replied to Drew's discussion Dealing with a depressing job
"Why are you getting rejected?"
5 hours ago
Shane replied to J. Exalto's discussion Globalism in the group The Great Debate
"I'm sure they need them more than people in North America do. Stopped reading right there."
5 hours ago
J. Exalto added a discussion to the group The Great Debate
Thumbnail

Globalism

There's been a lot of talk about globalism lately, so I want to get people's opinions on whether it's a good thing or not (it's not necessary to read and respond to the following diatribe, a simple answer to this question would be appreciated).From my perspective, it's unequivocally a good thing that happens to have bad consequences for some people, but benefits the same people in some ways as well.  I understand that a lot of small, one-industry towns are dying, partially as a result of…See More
6 hours ago
Danny replied to Drew's discussion Dealing with a depressing job
"This may be a bit of a stress but have you considered doing two part time roles at the same time? I don't know if it will affect your taxes or impose a penalty on your 'second' income or anything like that but you could make the hours…"
7 hours ago
Drew replied to Drew's discussion Dealing with a depressing job
"Hi everyone, Thanks for the replies. My fiancee doesn't drive and there's not much public transport at night in this area (if any) so her getting a night job isn't really an option. I don't have a particular job in mind at the…"
8 hours ago
Danny replied to Drew's discussion Dealing with a depressing job
"Hello! Are you working mainly night shifts because there aren't any vacancies elsewhere in the hotel? A move to another department could work out better for your schedules. It's not ridiculous that you're unhappy about not seeing…"
8 hours ago

© 2017   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service