Girlfriend sent me a link to this:

http://www.lowes.com/pd_128880-89707-CW001_4294857538__?productId=1...=

She also threw some jokes down because she knows I can keep a cool tool, and this is basically CNC for small wood projects.

My question is this:

CNC is typically used when you've got to crank out a lot of parts that are the same, not one offs. I do sculpture in my spare time using nearly any material, and I've never thrown a piece of barstock into a CNC to make a piece of art. I've done some unconventional things on a Fadal CNC to demonstrate my CADD skills by making a sold Aluminum Rose, but I wouldn't consider that art.

I suppose my question is, how do my fellow woodworkers feel about this product? would you use it to save time on cranking out designs, like CNC was intended for? or would you use it as a crutch for things you can't do by hand? Does it take away from the art of woodworking?

Views: 87

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I have been half way following this gadget and even though I am not much of a woodworker I am being tempted to get one.  My plan A is to tempt my brother who does woodworking to get one though. 

I've had a CNC machine in the planning stage for several years.  The mechanical part is simple, the electronic interface not so simple.

 

To that end, last summer I bought a 3-axis controller board that has yet to get used.  Busy, busy.

 

It is my belief that CNC is just one more tool in your arsenal.  It does not take away from the artistry, any more so than your use of a jointer or table saw...or are you one of those guys who believes a table saw takes away from the "handcrafted" aspect of your projects?  There are some who do feel that way.

 

CNC's great strength lies not just in its ability to make multiple pieces, but actually in its ability to make parts very precisely.  Inlay can be taken to a level that most would never achieve, even with the most exquisite level of craftsmanship.  I've also seen exceptionally beautiful dovetails made with CNC equipment.

 

My goal is to use mine for clockwork parts. 

 

Fair warning, though.  As CNC machines go the CarveWright is pretty low end in its capabilities, especially considering its cost.

 

http://www.cnczone.com is a great resource for this type of information.

RSS

Latest Activity

Rick Shelton replied to Herb Munson's discussion The Primacy and Existence of God in the group The Great Debate
"If you were interesting enough then yes; it is known as a biography or memiors.  Actually, some people may buy it even if you are not interesting and some people will publish even if they are not interesting."
2 minutes ago
David F. replied to Harry Cariaga's discussion Tips on being frugal.
"Make two days a week meatless.  That will cut a lot of costs."
23 minutes ago
David F. replied to Steve C's discussion Bedtime
"For me it is setting specific.  If it is the winter, I tend toward PJs because they are warmer then sheets.  In the summer if in a safe space it will be much less.  But I tend to have what I need to bug out next to the bed. One summer…"
25 minutes ago
Tyler M. replied to Max B's discussion losing my Dad
"We're coming up to the two year anniversary of when I lost my Dad to small cell lung cancer. He died a pretty slow, horrible death over the course of a couple years, and I understand how hard it is seeing it happen. If you're a Christian,…"
1 hour ago
Liam replied to Liam's discussion Moving towards my first muscle up
"Thanks, they have gone onto my "to buy" list. I can see they are pretty versatile! I have been able to control the transition on negatives to a certain extent but have been struggling. I like the idea of the elastics to help build up the…"
1 hour ago
Liam replied to Liam's discussion Moving towards my first muscle up
"I am trying to build up and maintain some level of endurance. Nothing fancy, I think sets of 12 - 15 pull ups is a good middle ground. I'm not looking to go higher than that.  In my observation a mixture of low rep, high level (like a…"
1 hour ago
LShieldes replied to Herb Munson's discussion The Primacy and Existence of God in the group The Great Debate
"Would people buy books where I talk about my own existance?"
2 hours ago
JonEdanger replied to Herb Munson's discussion The Primacy and Existence of God in the group The Great Debate
"The latter is a great example of the former."
2 hours ago

© 2013   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service