This seems to be an oddity from ranching culture---I first ran into it when I was with a group that visited a large ranch out west.  The men in the family (and apparently the boys) called their dad by his first name.  Much later, I ended up working with a woman whose husband grew up like that---he called his dad by his first name and (to his wife's chagrin) he wanted their son to call HIM by HIS first name.  Then last night at a political event, one of the speakers told us his son calls him "Bob"---we're not talking about liberal leftists, anarchists, or throw-backs to the hippie era, here.  I'm not being critical of the custom, but it sure seems odd to me.

It would never have occurred to me to call my dad by his first name, nor would I have allowed it in my own household.  What are the roots of this?  Is it just a western thing?  Just older boys?  Some kind of "you're a man, now" equality thing?  I'd think that having your son call you by your first name would bring you down to being like a peer rather than a parent.  Anybody grow up like this?  I'd really like to know more about it.  Comments?

Tags: Dads, first, name

Views: 2061

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

It probably comes from the parents (in this case the father) and works its way on down. For example, I have an uncle who eschews the title "Uncle" and insists that he's just called by his first name. It's not like this for my father though. I call him dad and couldn't imagine calling him by his first name. I don't think he could imagine it either!

Why, exactly, a father would not want to be called "dad" is beyond me. I'd be interested in hearing more about it too. 

That's the other thing, D.J.---not only can I not imagine why a son would be calling his dad by his first name, but I can't imagine a father wanting it, either---so it goes in both directions.  It's a mystery to me---looking forward to more comments.

different strokes

Never heard of it.  I like the idea of "you're a man, now," but it's still odd.

My in-laws, from the North, want me to call them by their first names, which in Southern culture is profoundly disrespectful.  I made a nickname for f-i-l; m-i-l disliked the one I made for her.  So I call her "Grandma."

im curious to what your nicknames were for them. haha

Mr. FIL (for "Father In Law").  I don't blame her for not wanting to be Miz MILlie.

I always think of Michael Jackson and his siblings having to call their father "Joseph." Not Dad or Pop, not even Joe, but "Joseph." I don't get it.

Then again, when I was younger, my Midwestern cousins called my parents by their first names and it seemed common there. My East Coast parents, however, did not appreciate, e.g., a nine-year-old being so informal with their aunt and uncle (treating them like equals, basically) and found it disrespectful.

I went through a lot to be a Dad and there are only two people in this world who can call me by that name. I work hard every day to earn that title.



Tim said: I went through a lot to be a Dad and there are only two people in this world who can call me by that name. I work hard every day to earn that title.


That's how I feel, too---you summed it up well.  I'd really be interested in hearing the other side, though, particularly from guys who grew up out west or something.

I agree with Todd and Tim.   Figuratively speaking, my wife and I "sneezed", or something, and 9 months later, we're parents of a son.  We didn't have any challenges at all, in the fertility dept. 

I'm sure that many of the fathers who ask their children to call them by their first name, don't feel any disrespect from their children, and the children themselves would say that they don't intend any disrespect.  I come from a time when disrespect to parents earned one a trip to the proverbial woodshed, where one was "helped to understand one's mistake".   One might as well slap The Virgin Mary as to call an adult by their first name.

One should refer to another by the other's earned title, if any.  Jesus said, "When you are invited to dinner, sit on the lowest level.  Do not go to the highest level, lest the host come to you, and say, 'Friend, come down lower, and make room for this guest."  It is better to be invited closer in, than be told to stand down.  Therefore, IMHO, one should call one's parents "Mom" and "Dad".  One should not use first names for one's parents.   If one's parents insist upon their children using their first names to refer to them, one should do so.  But one should never presume that one has permission to be that informal with others who have earned titles of respect.

I never could get myself to call my ex mother or father in law mom or dad, usually I called them by their name... but I don't think I could EVER refer to my parents by name.  I would be pretty disappointed in my children if they ever referred to me by my first name name as well.

Being called "daddy" by my little son is such a kick.  I yearned for so long to have that appellation that being called anything else just wouldn't work for me.  My stepson and stepdaughter call me by my name so even though I had a family I didn't feel like a 'daddy' or 'dad'.

I don't think it's restricted to western rural areas.  I knew a guy who called his father by his first name and they were part of an archetypal suburban family.  I was always struck by how unusual it was and I could never see myself doing it, but they functioned just fine.  From what I could see, they had a perfectly healthy father-son relationship.

RSS

Latest Activity

Pale Horse replied to Pope Paul's discussion 10 Rules to Being a Gentleman in 2015
"Rule 30."
7 minutes ago
Jason Boaldin replied to Douglas Jones's discussion Wanting to change careers and be a barbershop owner/barber. in the group The Barbershop
"I am in a similar spot.  Although, not really.  My wife took a better job, so we moved from Texas to Chicago.  Found AoM, read the article on vocation vs. career.  Now I hope to follow in my old mans foot steps and start Barber…"
7 minutes ago
Jason Boaldin joined Nolan Poulson's group
Thumbnail

The Barbershop

It's just seems natural that Art of Manliness should have a barbershop group.  My intent of this group is to gather and share general thoughts and experiences concerning barbershops. Anything from a good barbershop that you have found  to pictures and stories of shops you have visited to discussing anything barbershop.  See More
7 minutes ago
Pale Horse replied to Matthew Martino's discussion (Kind of) New to AOM
""If" never tickled my fancy either. The gist of the poem is nice, but I just never cared for it. It would be better to commit to memory something that speaks to you."
10 minutes ago
Shane replied to Jim's discussion Hey Y'all Marine here! in the group The Armed Forces
"Happened to my buddy. Got back from our tour in AFG where he was attached to an ODA. Goofy fucker decided to commission in the NG. Was texting me all night about the shit those wannabes were doing."
31 minutes ago
Profile IconJimmy Stewart, Tyler Robert Gerrior, Smith Amelia and 86 more joined Art of Manliness
37 minutes ago
Jim replied to Jim's discussion Hey Y'all Marine here! in the group The Armed Forces
"Hahahaha god I didn't even think of that!!! "I know my contract says Coast Guard Supply but I'll be a SEAL as soon as I finish Basic. My recruiter hooked me up!" Lol"
48 minutes ago
Will replied to Dann Anthony's discussion Heavy diagnosis - looking for manly advice.
"I'd say forgive S-in-law; she seems like she's no longer trying to be a problem. Are you ready for the great beyond?  You'll get there eventually... this just makes it more real. Recently a friend of mine diagnosed with lung…"
50 minutes ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service