I should clarify the title of my post -- should I buy a birthday present for my best friend's fiance? They've been together for 5 years, and recently got engaged, and I'm best man at the wedding. I know the girl, we've hung out (all 3 together) a few times, and she and I get along. A few years back, I got her a Christmas present, but I haven't gotten her anything since (not for Christmas or bdays). And she's never given me anything on either dates. But I'm wondering now, after my friend's engagement, should I get her something? I'm just curious. I won't see her on her bday, but I will see my friend a few days before.

Views: 599

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

No, especially since you won't be seeing her on her birthday.  If you really want to give something, give your friend a bottle of wine when you see him that they can have to celebrate her birthday. 

I like that idea:  if you want to give, give THEM something. 

Hmm, not that I disagree with these replies, but any reason why not (why I should not get her a present)? Just curious.

Because she isn't your girl, she hasn't given you gifts, and she didn't invite you to a birthday party.

Why do you think you should?


JB

Jack,

+1 for all three reasons given.

Because giving gifts to a woman you aren't related to, that is within ball-part of your age of opposite-sex interest, is a great way to send the message "I find you attractive and would like to get to know you better."  That's not your intention, so it's best not to send a message that at least raises the question of whether that's what you meant.

You *should* get her something.  In fact, I disagree with the reasons listed, and here's why.  My assumptions are as follows...

 

1)  She is joining your circle of friends through marriage

2)  You want to acknowledge that act

3)  It is your intention to include her as a friend, at that different level that requires recognition at gift giving holidays

4)  You're not certain how to approach her, in this regard.

 

In other words, you need the excuse to make it happen "naturally."

 

Here's what I would do.  Since you don't currently exchange gifts, and because it's a birthday, use the excuse to begin the tradition.  She's joining your group, so go ahead and acknowledge it!  But, do it in one of two ways...

 

1)  Give her a really nice card.  It establishes that giving-receiving relationship without being too heavy handed.  OR...

2)  Give a gift to *them.*  That was a very good idea, and it would work to include her, without singling her out.

 

And, when giving it, "welcome her to the family," specifically  Make certain it's understood that your intention is to shift her into a different level of friendship.

 

It gracefully places her in that "close circle" of friends, without being too heavy handed.

Well said, Chuck.

 

 

If your friends name is Jessie " no "

Awesome response!

Not unless she was one of your good friends, too. So I don't think you need too. If you really feel you must, agreed--give "them" both something.

A further thought.

Do you and your friend exchange birthday and/or Christmas gifts? 

If you don't, DO NOT start by giving something just to her.

 

 

RSS

Latest Activity

Liam S. replied to Andrew D, USA Ret's discussion Militias, politics, anti-2nd amendment hysteria and the Bundy issue in the group The Great Debate
"Neither. Extremist positions (on either side) are not productive."
44 minutes ago
Nick H replied to Augustin's discussion The Mask You Live In - Don't tell boy to man up! (Says video)
"As a hyperactive kid, I would've been screwed in today's school. No way I would've made it to lunch without a break. Also, I'm sure in today's world I would've been drugged. My primary school teacher told my mother that…"
49 minutes ago
Andrew D, USA Ret added a discussion to the group The Great Debate
Thumbnail

Militias, politics, anti-2nd amendment hysteria and the Bundy issue

Much of the hysteria, hatred and vituperation slung against Bundy and his supporters, in my opinion have little to do with the legal matters and much to do with the frightening image to some of armed citizens confronting legal enforcers of the law, regardless of the cause. The anti-2nd amendment crowd is in full cry over this, like hounds baying at a treed rapist of color in the old south. Bundy's supporters have been labeled by some anti-gun hysterics as mouth-breathing morons in 2nd-hand…See More
1 hour ago
Will replied to Andrew D, USA Ret's discussion Atheism ascendant throughout the world? Evidence shows the opposite in the group The Great Debate
"I'd take info on any country.  Iran?  Afghanistan?  Iraq?  Turkey?  Yemen?"
2 hours ago
Will commented on Herb Munson's group The Great Debate
"So (John) which is worse:  to have company X cancel your plan, or to have the government outlaw your plan, so that no company can offer it? Whatever your answer, it should be clear that thinking governments should not cancel severely ill…"
2 hours ago
Will replied to Augustin's discussion The Mask You Live In - Don't tell boy to man up! (Says video)
"Worked with, in what context?  Teacher?"
2 hours ago
Will replied to Augustin's discussion The Mask You Live In - Don't tell boy to man up! (Says video)
"My home state outlawed recess one time.  I don't know if they repealed the ban. I tend to assume the public schools will get on board with random new and bad trends.  After all, they dumped phonics for sight reading, leading parents…"
2 hours ago
Andrew D, USA Ret replied to Andrew D, USA Ret's discussion Atheism ascendant throughout the world? Evidence shows the opposite in the group The Great Debate
"J. Muir: "Nope - the spread of the gospel is unstoppable." Muhammad's warriors felt the same about Islam, and still do. I do believe what you wrote to be just as much wishful thinking as the Chinese woman's in the quote I…"
2 hours ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service