I'm looking to get some non-work boots and would like to get a USA made product. I was looking at the Danner Forest Heights and some Red Wing boots (iron ranger, beckman). Anyone have any experience with these brands? I know they're known for quality but with the prices being $200-$300, do you think they're really worth it? 

Views: 1674

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I do not have experience with those brands, but I do have some Allen Edmonds boots (one pair bought used, one new) and would certainly recommend them as being worth it.  The quality is much, much better than what you'll get for $50-100 (made in china, soles cheaply glued on).  Allen Edmonds will also recraft most of their shoes, which is their way of saying that they can do repairs up to replacing the entire sole (I'd have to check prices, but last time I used the service it was somewhere around $40 for new heels and $100 for a complete resoling, including a new cork footbed).

I have never seen Allen Edmonds before. Some very nice boots! 

I am a big fan of Red Wings.  I have worn steel toe Red Wings for my work boots for years.  They are consistently high quality, well made boots.  I also like that I can take them to the RW store anytime I want for a free pair of new laces, complimentary shine, and a complimentary boot oil treatment.

There is one negative with Red Wings.  Not all of their shoes/boots are made in America anymore.  Many are being made in China.  So if you want a pair made in America, be sure to check the label on the back of the tongue to insure that they were in fact made in America.  I have worn both American and Chinese made Red Wings.  I've found both to be very high quality.   I prefer to by the American made though.  I'm currently wearing a pair of American made Red Wing 2406's and I love them.

My dream is to have some custom made boots. Until then, I settle for Justin(No clue where they are made), Wolverine just went downhill for me.

I've noticed a trend among some boot makers, including my favorite brand.  Only their high-end boots are made in the US and they have started to import some of their low end boots. 

Those companies don't openly advertise this, of course, but if you search closely, you can find which models are made where. 

Just telling you to be diligent.  I was recently burned. 

Yes, I discovered this with Red Wing. I know their "Irish Setter" and "Vasque" line are made in China. Very disappointing, but I guess they're feeling the pressure (or just wanting more profit?). 

I've worn Dunham boots for a long while now.  Hold up well for my job, while I'm on my motorcycle, and when out doing yard work and the like.  Not too pricey and from what I can tell they're a subsidiary of New Balance, which IIRC makes it's shoes stateside.  I'd love to have a good pair of Red Wings but I've got the old, Dom Perignon tastes with a Miller Light budget so it's not always practical. 

The red wing iron rangers are made in the states, and are a good choice

What type are you looking for dress , play also lace up or slip ons ?

I may have missed it elsewhere, but what specifically do you want/need boots for?  Is there something in particular you are planning on using them for, or are you looking for some good looking boots just to wear about your day?  I don't mean to offend or insinuate anything by asking, I was just trying to see if there was a specific goal in mind for them that would help making recommendations more focused.

edit: Now see.  The poster right above me asked the very same question while I had left this tab open so I could read other stuff before I responded to this.  I fail.

I bought some Red Wing boots in Red Wing, MN about a month ago and love them. Initially very rigid and uncomfortable but after wearing them a bit, they've relaxed a bit and I really like them.

Found this site lingering in my bookmarks menu.  The concept looks great (crafted in the USA) and so do the boots.  I can't vouch for them though, they are a little out of this guys price range.

Oak Street Bootmakers



Latest Activity

Shane replied to Sir's discussion Europe's migrant crisis in the group The Great Debate
"So they have absolutely zero reason to be in Europe."
11 minutes ago
Shane replied to Sir's discussion Europe's migrant crisis in the group The Great Debate
"Now Germany decides to go to…"
13 minutes ago
Jay posted a discussion

A case study

A philological argument for the third eye.Subjectively I can say the third eye is real.It is the thought in my mind, the voice on my shoulder and the friend in hard times.See More
30 minutes ago
Mervyn Jordan updated their profile
3 hours ago
Mervyn Jordan posted a discussion


Hi everyone,My name is Mervyn. I am a 25 year old South African Indian, living in the beautiful city of Durban, on the east coast of South Africa. I have been reading AOM for a few years now but haven't really got the chance to be active on the AOM community.I am a business graduate, currently working in the business/software consulting field(SAP). I am an avid martial artist, training Judo for the last 4 years. I also enjoy strength training in my garage gym. I recently took up trying to cut…See More
3 hours ago
Max Dubois posted a discussion

Of Yuletide and Christmas Trees

Had to get this off my chest, figured I might as well post this here since AoM is pretty much my main source of inspiration for turning my life around.http://overlymanlymax.blogspot.ca/2015/11/of-yuletide-and-christmas-trees.htmlCopied the article here, I'm not really looking for traffic on the blog, I'm not sure I'll ever post anything on it again.  Thanks for reading, hope you enjoy.Of Yuletide and…See More
4 hours ago
Sam commented on Michael J. Austin's group Michigan
"Hey Gents, New to the site, and new to michigan. How's.How's it going? Do you guys ever get together, like a Michigan AoM meet? Also, how many fly-fishermen out here "
6 hours ago
Elliot James replied to Fabricante's discussion For The Gamers In Your Life
"I'd say a Steam gift card, or if they don't already have their own headset maybe splurge on a good wireless Logitech headset."
6 hours ago

© 2015   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service