Hey fellas. I'm Patrick and am new to the forum.

As a Christian, I'm curious how everyone seems to balance their spirituality/religious beliefs (considering you "practice" a religion or call yourself "spiritual") while still maintaining their manliness. I ask because spirituality seems to have grown to be extremely passive in today's society. Take Jesus, for example, who is depicted as a meek and gentle wimp and not so much a man's man.

Hope my question isn't too vague. All opinions are welcome.

Tags: and, manliness, spirituality

Views: 1847

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I was brought up in a home where religion was much more than just something we believed; it was a way of life.  As an adult, I have chosen to hold to those beliefs after a brief time of questioning and doubt, and have never looked back.  As a man who feels strongly that all things masculine are under fierce attack in our culture, I do not see manliness and spirituality as being at all in conflict, at least, not within the relm of Christianity.  I kind of get what you're saying about Christ being portrayed as a pasafist, but I don't believe he was.  He encouraged people to get along with and love their neighbors to be sure, but he also stood up for what he believed and absolutely never backed down.  I believe the greatest weakness that many who call themselves Christians around the world have is that we do not stand up and fight harder for what we believe.  Many of us are far, far too passive when it comes to defending what we see as right and moral and good and just, perhaps believing that the conflict that is usually the result of us taking a stand is not in harmony with the teachings of Christ.  Obviously, I do not subscribe to that way of thinking.  But that, in my view, does not at all mean that spirituality and masculinity are at odds.  I see Christ as one of the greatest (if not THE greatest) example of manhood that there has ever been.  He loved little children and blessed them, he treated women with respect, charished his mother until the very last, yet he stood up to the political and spiritual leaders of his day and boldly told them how it was and pointed out the hipocracy of their teachings and beliefs, he rid the holy temple of all that defiled it, and he was willing to  pay the ultimate price, not only for our sins, but also for angering the leaders, as well as many of the people, of his generation.  That, to me, is a man I want to model my life after.

^ this guy nailed it right on the money. I couldn't have said it better myself.

Absolutely.  I hate how He is traditionally portrayed by Hollywood.  This was a strong and masculine man.

And lets not forget, his ministry didn't start until he was 30.  Up until that time he was a carpenter.  Mostly likely he was fit and strong. All those Chuck Norris jokes should be changed to Jesus.  I think Chuck would agreee.

How many people are manly enough to carry their own cross up a massive hill and then be nailed to it without making a massive scene? I think Jesus was pretty manly, 'turning the other cheek' can be manly in the right context. He certainly held himself (at least in my mind's eye) with poise and power. If you look collectively at the stories of Christ he exemplified manliness pretty well.

Don't try and separate your spirituality and manliness, it is in-congruent, instead try to look at Jesus as the embodiment of manliness. I think when you do you'll see him in a different light. When asking the question 'Was that manly?' at the end of the various stories of Christ I think the answer will normally be yes.

...not to mention Christian martyrs, saints and most holy men from other religions who endured sacrifices and pain way beyond those any normal 'man' would ever do.  In truth we mistake meekness for weakness.   Inner strength is what makes a true man, any a fool can just be physically strong as even the beasts of burden are.

Seconded.

This isn't the main forum.

It most certainly is.

You are certainly right.  I stand corrected.

It's a fair question.  Manliness is at least partly a set of virtues focused around being big:  confident (bigger than the problem), generous ("that's mighty big of you"), brave (bigger than your fears), etc.  There are also virtues about being small:  humility, servanthood.

The last shall be first.  There is paradox.

I have not resolved the paradox.  I do remember thinking:  what I *am* is a man, and that includes power, confidence, daring.  And God can have all of it.  If we kept only one side of that paradox, what would we have?  A man who is powerful in taking care of number one; or a weakling.  Neither is a destiny I want.

One important thought here is how to reconcile opposites.

I do not believe Aristotle's view (and I think the Stoics followed this) is that virtue consists of being in the middle.  For this issue, consider whether you should be half as strong as you can and half as humble.  Better to be at 100% strength and 100% humility.

--

And here are a couple of other perspectives on manliness, bravery, &c., and God.

"Ballad of the Goodly Fere" by Ezra Pound

"Tired of Speaking Sweetly" by Sufi poet Hafiz

--

This discussion may get closed eventually if we don't behave ourselves.  The purpose of rule 4 is to stop arguments from dominating the forum, but not to prevent us from talking about life as men in all its aspects.

Glad you mentioned books. I've been reading Wild At Heart, which I'm sure you're familiar with.

And this discussion was intended for more than just Christians but ALL who practice any religion or spirituality. (Seeing as how most religions have strict moral codes that make them deemed "wimpy" from an outsiders view.) I only used Christ as an example because I could relate most to him from my beliefs. I'm merely asking for others ways or perspectives on how folks stay manly yet spiritual.

Great response though sir!

RSS

Latest Activity

Regular Joe replied to Peter Arkson's discussion Request for daily, short news radio program/podcast
"AKA Google worked."
2 minutes ago
Max replied to Jamie Q's discussion What is your dream guitar?
"hmm.. this is tough... As far as electric goes probably a tele, pretty plain, but they sound great and I never really had the need for a third pickup and I think they handle gain better in the bridge than a strat for some reason... I seem to have a…"
4 minutes ago
John Lee Pettimore replied to Josh Williams's discussion I touched her butt.
"Well, it was an insult. Just a different target than you were expecting."
10 minutes ago
Logan Hickerson posted photos
24 minutes ago
Michael J. K. replied to Joe W's discussion Happy Fathers' Day in the group Fathers and Sons
"yes I know the the relationship with the stepsons is nor really like father and son they have their dad for that.   But I am happy with grandkids and step children.   Never thought I would have either."
26 minutes ago
Thomas Patrick replied to Jamie Q's discussion What is your dream guitar?
"Gibson Pete Townshend Les Paul Deluxe  Mini humbuckers in the bridge and neck position, a DiMarzio super distortion in the middle Has a Phaser switch and a soil splitter for the DiMarzio A nice Wine Red finish would do me good too"
32 minutes ago
Peter Arkson replied to Peter Arkson's discussion Request for daily, short news radio program/podcast
"Thanks for the snarky remark.  That was very helpful.  First off, I did google 10 minute news radio, to little avail.  That being said, let's see what your link turned up: A list of 94 BBC podcasts, all of which are at…"
39 minutes ago
Jack Bauer replied to Josh Williams's discussion I touched her butt.
"Ah.  My mistake.  I was trying to figure how you were going to insult me with that (your usual usage of 'too easy').  I was curious enough to invite the insult just to see how you did it.   JB"
59 minutes ago

© 2014   Created by Brett McKay.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service